alex13_zen

Active Member
Sep 30, 2019
611
802
Is everything we see now in the past, retold by the MC? That's what I understand from the phrasing in the library scene from ep 3. He says he never would have kissed Bella had he known the real reason for her tears. Sounds like he knows it now, right?
screenshot0005.png
 

The Glorious LIME

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2019
1,769
10,149
Is everything we see now in the past, retold by the MC? That's what I understand from the phrasing in the library scene from ep 3. He says he never would have kissed Bella had he known the real reason for her tears. Sounds like he knows it now, right?
View attachment 2265025
Yupp, a few times he narrates. Just like in the fuck fuck fuck fuck at the end of episode 8. MC is retelling the event of his life that probably lead to the end game.


lol I didn't get this line in my previous playthroughs. Then I remembered chatting with Tyballs on Tybalt's post. Seems that even Rooster comment sections alter the dialogues.

View attachment 2265024
Indeed, DPC is known for attention to detail and rewards people who deep dive his game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xummu

DaimonFey

Member
Oct 28, 2021
448
756
Since Quinn is already falling for MC, I hope when she finally admit her feellings for him we can dump her for Riona or Lily and tell her to her face. And then when she, disappointed, shocked and sad asks why we play with her like this, MC will smile and say:
"Remember when you took my clothes and made run around the campus naked and not even feel sory? This is payback bitch"
I think that you should seduce and then dump all DIKs since as far as I remember they told her to do it.
Of course I might be wrong since I played that part long ago.
 

Hahn1900

Well-Known Member
Jan 3, 2021
1,497
3,358
Is everything we see now in the past, retold by the MC? That's what I understand from the phrasing in the library scene from ep 3. He says he never would have kissed Bella had he known the real reason for her tears. Sounds like he knows it now, right?
View attachment 2265025
Well, of course the MC is telling his story and its kinda a "flashback". Read the introduction of the game again... "let me tell you what happened" thats the sentence you see before the game really starts.

Overall, i think he is telling us about his first year on college and after the first year is done, the game will end with a view on the present and a little ahead in the future maybe, based on the choices of course.

I had a different approach in mind too... like the movie american beauty. Maybe, and its a BIG maybe... the MC will die at the end and is just telling his sotry of his last year alive... but i have no "proof" for that, just a gut feeling... many many books, movies, stories starting like this where the protagonist tells a already happened story, the protagonist gonna die, is already dead, or facing death.

Those phrases where he talks like everything already happened and he is just telling his story are at several points of the game.

Well it is certain though that the MC is just the storyteller about his time at college and everything we see already lies in the "past"

Doesnt really matter much for the time being. But its already a heads up to how the game ending can be made.

And because its a story of the past, it does explain more that we can see so many scenes without the MC in it... cause in the end, he knows those things after everything happened the way it does.

This way to tell a story which already happened is a easy way for an author to go over plotholes especially about things the protagonist cant know about if he wasnt there... but if it all lies in the past, of course somebody could have told him after all, or something.

Overall DPC isnt really following those approach though... sometimes he jump to a phrasing where you can assume that everything already happened, but most of the time telling the story like nobody knows shit. If you tell a story like that, sometimes a "narrator" is needed. But this is missing here. Mqaybe cause DPC doesnt care about it, or he want to set up the illusion everything is happening just now, but if he wanted to create this illusion, he shouldnt let the MC talk the way he did in your screenshot for example, and thats not the only time he does that. But we always should keep in mind... DPC is not really a great author. Not even close.
 
Last edited:

herugrim123

Newbie
Dec 25, 2020
29
39
I thought it was interesting that depending on certain variables, I didn't figure out exactly what I did (or didn't) do but on the Isabella route, Jill does in fact not tear the picture she has of MC with the "Are you my destiny" written on it. Whereas she rips it in another path/route I did, which I guess was not Isabella. So she still believes in the possibility when MC is with Isabella/ or other variables that aren't clear to me.
 

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,425
41,172
lol I didn't get this line in my previous playthroughs. Then I remembered chatting with Tyballs on Tybalt's post. Seems that even Rooster comment sections alter the dialogues.

View attachment 2265024
Damn I don't know how I missed this. Probably one of the options in Rooster led to "reply Tyballs". If only I could remember which post.
With your girlfriend humiliate her loser brother in Rooster, what could be better?
 

Crepusculum

Member
Jan 4, 2018
279
266
lol I didn't get this line in my previous playthroughs. Then I remembered chatting with Tyballs on Tybalt's post. Seems that even Rooster comment sections alter the dialogues.

View attachment 2265024
Yupp, a few times he narrates. Just like in the fuck fuck fuck fuck at the end of episode 8. MC is retelling the event of his life that probably lead to the end game.
Indeed, DPC is known for attention to detail and rewards people who deep dive his game.
I am so curious about how he does that and keeps track so well and so consistently, he must have hundreds (if not more) of these occurrences.

Didn't you get like a SINGLE chance to respond to her balls account?
 

Jericho85

Engaged Member
Apr 25, 2022
2,132
7,388
I thought it was interesting that depending on certain variables, I didn't figure out exactly what I did (or didn't) do but on the Isabella route, Jill does in fact not tear the picture she has of MC with the "Are you my destiny" written on it. Whereas she rips it in another path/route I did, which I guess was not Isabella. So she still believes in the possibility when MC is with Isabella/ or other variables that aren't clear to me.
Yep, that's triggered under specific conditions.

I think most of us interpret it as Jill isn't quite done with MC and may try to take him back from Bella.
 

Jericho85

Engaged Member
Apr 25, 2022
2,132
7,388
Damn I don't know how I missed this. Probably one of the options in Rooster led to "reply Tyballs". If only I could remember which post.
With your girlfriend humiliate her loser brother in Rooster, what could be better?
Yeah I think it's one of Tybalt's clucks where you either have a choice to respond to Tybalt or respond to "Tyballs". If you respond to tyballs it turns into a hilarious back and forth between MC and Tyballs, all of which gets flagged for harassment by Tybalt.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: John Ness and ffive

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,425
41,172
Yeah I think it's one of Tybalt's clucks where you either have a choice to respond to Tybalt or respond to "Tyballs". If you respond to tyballs it turns into a hilarious back and forth between MC and Tyballs, all of which gets flagged for harassment by Tyballs.
I just realized that I need this route.
 

walker188

Active Member
Apr 30, 2017
744
2,239
Ok, Guys, Guys...
WTF.

Pretty much every day since this episode came out i saw people talking about how Sage reverted all of her character progression, ruined her character, etc - please explain wtf did i miss and what were people talking about?

Since she is tied for first in my book, i posponed her to be last and nearly forget - it was a really nice route!
View attachment 2259031
Eh.

Sage is/was my main girl since season 2 when I switched off Maya (who had become unbearable by that point), but I kind of agree with people being disappointed in her last few episodes. I'm not sure DPC knows what he wants to do with her, and frankly, I've said it before a good portion of her dialogue and Quinn's feels like it ought to be flipped. Instead of adding depth to the character, the constant back and forth between super wild slut and deeply emotional girl (with a healthy sex drive) is starting to give me whiplash. Which Sage am I going to get today?

It's not about the quality of the sex. Frankly, the sex scenes in BaD are extremely well made, but I care so much about the characters, its much harder to objectify them. Which is great. But it also creates a problem with a work like this that is more than just porno. This isn't the only character to have this problem either. Different girls jump personalities from scene to scene rather than slowly growing or deepening.

I think I understand what he was going for with Sage, he just did a shitty job of conveying it to the audience. Sage starts out as a 'slut' and then reforms to a good girlfriend in our mind. But that's not it. Sage is an adventurous girl (its one of the things I like best about her). She starts the story in a shitty relationship. But you don't save her from it. She rides it out, because of her own issues until it collapses and then you're there for her after. But Sage isn't turning into the good girl she was always meant to be. She's a hound and she's finally found the ideal partner to explore all her impulses with (you). She trusts you. She wants you. But she also wants you to help her discover all the things she would have felt shamed for for the past few years. (Chad guilted her over her high sex drive, remember?) From this context, the story makes a lot more sense.

But its delivered poorly, Sage shouldn't have opened up emotionally to the MC so soon. Instead she should have told him in Ep8 that she wants him to be a fuck buddy and nothing more.

Not only would this have made her distinct from all the other characters (sorely needed), but it would also have made it much much harder to choose her. Which gives the choice e more narrative weight. Down the line, she would open up more (the stuff we saw in season 2 and more still) climaxing (heheh) in her finally admitting that she WANTS to be in a real relationship with the MC.

I think it's time for DPC to admit some of his failings as an artist (which isn't to say he isn't amazing, but no one is good at everything). He writes good concepts and dialogue and decent plotting, but the man needs an editor. Someone who helps him smooth out arcs between scenes and keep characters consistent within their own voice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roroorigina

alex13_zen

Active Member
Sep 30, 2019
611
802
Well, of course the MC is telling his story and its kinda a "flashback". Read the introduction of the game again... "let me tell you what happened" thats the sentence you see before the game really starts.

Overall, i think he is telling us about his first year on college and after the first year is done, the game will end with a view on the present and a little ahead in the future maybe, based on the choices of course.

I had a different approach in mind too... like the movie american beauty. Maybe, and its a BIG maybe... the MC will die at the end and is just telling his sotry of his last year alive... but i have no "proof" for that, just a gut feeling... many many books, movies, stories starting like this where the protagonist tells a already happened story, the protagonist gonna die, is already dead, or facing death.

Those phrases where he talks like everything already happened and he is just telling his story are at several points of the game.

Well it is certain though that the MC is just the storyteller about his time at college and everything we see already lies in the "past"

Doesnt really matter much for the time being. But its already a heads up to how the game ending can be made.

And because its a story of the past, it does explain more that we can see so many scenes without the MC in it... cause in the end, he knows those things after everything happened the way it does.

This way to tell a story which already happened is a easy way for an author to go over plotholes especially about things the protagonist cant know about if he wasnt there... but if it all lies in the past, of course somebody could have told him after all, or something.

Overall DPC isnt really following those approach though... sometimes he jump to a phrasing where you can assume that everything already happened, but most of the time telling the story like nobody knows shit. If you tell a story like that, sometimes a "narrator" is needed. But this is missing here. Mqaybe cause DPC doesnt care about it, or he want to set up the illusion everything is happening just now, but if he wanted to create this illusion, he shouldnt let the MC talk the way he did in your screenshot for example, and thats not the only time he does that. But we always should keep in mind... DPC is not really a great author. Not even close.
I just feel that if everything has already happened, it cheapens the experience so I'm kinda sorry I noticed it. After all, there's no time like the present :)
 
4.80 star(s) 1,584 Votes