ChipLecsap

Conversation Conqueror
Aug 4, 2019
6,094
22,978
Honest questions, since you are clearly a fan of the MJ route:
1. Why is it easier to tolerate Maya shitposting?
2. Why do you put Josy above Maya in that route(seems like it).
3. If the game had the option from the start, would bother with MJ or go solo Josy?

I'm asking this completely honestly.

I personally enjoyed aspects of the MJ route but can't say I can list it among my favourites. Hence I'd enjoy the input on these questions from someone who is a MJ route fan :D
1
Easier is not the right word , but it's has been going on for so long that most of the time its not worth to bother with. I was here back in the day, when this started, I had my fair share fight with Quins fans, most of them are disappeared btw, :p :LOL:
and I've seen everything. What is going on here and what her haters says, are exactly the same thing, like it was back in the days, the only difference is now some folks suddenly realize that Josy is best girl, and they think it's cool to be one of the Josy fan, but they use her as another tool to attack Maya, so fuck them. :p:LOL:

2
I simply Like Josy more, but I want Maya to be Happy, and I want her to end up with Sage who eventually realize that Quinn is a fraud, , and the Hots are doomed if she end up as a leader, so she put her Faith in to Maya, and name her as her successor :cool:. Can you imagine how freak out the Quinn fans would be?!:devilish::ROFLMAO:

3
I don't like "what if " Questions, they are stupid:p
 

The Glorious LIME

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2019
1,747
9,678
1
Easier is not the right word , but it's has been going on for so long that most of the time its not worth to bother with. I was here back in the day, when this started, I had my fair share fight with Quins fans, most of them are disappeared btw, :p :LOL:
and I've seen everything. What is going on here and what her haters says, are exactly the same thing, like it was back in the days, the only difference is now some folks suddenly realize that Josy is best girl, and they think it's cool to be one of the Josy fan, but they use her as another tool to attack Maya, so fuck them. :p:LOL:

2
I simply Like Josy more, but I want Maya to be Happy, and I want her to end up with Sage who eventually realize that Quinn is a fraud, , and the Hots are doomed if she end up as a leader, so she put her Faith in to Maya, and name her as her successor :cool:. Can you imagine how freak out the Quinn fans would be?!:devilish::ROFLMAO:

3
I don't like "what if " Questions, they are stupid:p
But in a way you did answer #3, since you are aiming for solo Josy, and want Maya to pair up with Sage. If MC could influence outcomes more than he can(as of now), seems to me you would've played a solo Josy route and try helping Maya on the side.

I think a lot of people would've done that.

I think some take issue that they liked Josy from the moment they booted BaDIK(first LI), and just don't like the package she comes in later on.

Like you said, you like Josy more and want Maya to be happy. I think a lot want the same(silly shitposting aside). But for them to follow Josy, they are forced to have a romance with a character they'd never pick as a LI but probably help out game/story wise. It's the forced nature of Maya that leaves people with a bad taste. That's how I see it.

And seeing how Episode 9 added the balancing in MJ's feelings and Josy going off behind Maya's back(if you rejected them), I think Josy would ultimately also prefer a solo route with the MC. And I think DPC understands that well. Josy is amongst the hottest characters, currently locked down in a path many don't wanna play due to feeling forced to "love" a character that they actually wouldn't have minded helping out in the first place, regardless of relationship or not.
then the new gen Quinn enjoyers dont get it. she is interesting precisely because she is flawed :WeSmart:
Indeed, it's the imperfect nature that gives things the spark that makes them unique.
I myself am a Quinn enjoyer/fan. But at the same time, after playing both affinities, I can even say I'm somewhat of a MJ enjoyer too, great humour often in that path. Liking one doesn't mean I have to hate the other.
 
Jan 31, 2023
335
825
then the new gen Quinn enjoyers dont get it. she is interesting precisely because she is flawed :WeSmart:
No one ever claimed that she isn't flawed, she's a drug dealing pimp, her 'tsundere/troll/scared of her true emotions' attitude is a great hook, I always go for the tsundere.

Actually is Quinn even a tsundere? She's into MC from early on so I don't think so.
 

The Glorious LIME

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2019
1,747
9,678
No one ever claimed that she isn't flawed, she's a drug dealing pimp, her 'tsundere/troll/scared of her true emotions' attitude is a great hook, I always go for the tsundere.

Actually is Quinn even a tsundere? She's into MC from early on so I don't think so.
Tehnically, she ain't due to not playing hard to get when playing a DIK.

Also, all this talk about best girls just circles around the fact that the best gurl is: The friends we made along the way in this thread, playing the game :KEK:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ffive

ffive

Forum Fanatic
Jun 19, 2022
5,263
11,415
Actually is Quinn even a tsundere? She's into MC from early on so I don't think so.
I think Bella is closer to the type, but she too warms to MC pretty quickly. Perhaps Sally could fit here, eventually, but then she doesn't get much of a role in general.
 

frostpaw

Member
Jan 11, 2018
212
368
Actually is Quinn even a tsundere? She's into MC from early on so I don't think so.
That's something I thought about, too. When I think of Quinn being tsundere, this is what comes to mind:

Would be kind of crazy, if DPC would go about it like that.
 

SomboSteel

Active Member
May 8, 2017
572
3,433
No one ever claimed that she isn't flawed, she's a drug dealing pimp, her 'tsundere/troll/scared of her true emotions' attitude is a great hook, I always go for the tsundere.

Actually is Quinn even a tsundere? She's into MC from early on so I don't think so.
the lady in the meme said "she is amazing and without flaws". thats what i was referring too, if she is representative of new Quinn fans lol
 
  • Haha
Reactions: The Glorious LIME

Geralt From Rivia

Forum Fanatic
Jun 15, 2022
5,360
32,766
Okay, since Maya was mentioned, I want to make a serious post of white knighting and normal reasoned criticism. I don't hate Maya. In fact, I feel sorry for her as a human being that she got into this shitty situation and she has such a retard father.

Here I agree with The Glorious LIME , all these jokes and Maya shitposting due to the fact that her storyline has a number of wrong decisions.
First, this story line is too long. Maya and her problems run through the whole story of Being a DIK. The first season is Maya and her mysterious money problem + cliffhanger with Josy. Then it was okay. The second season, more precisely, it's second half is Maya and her problems, we found out the reason. And this storyline, like a virus, began to infect the rest of the characters, dragging Sage into it. Ok, end of Season 2, there was hope for this issue to be closed, which gave rise to many theories after episode 8. I'll go into more detail about this in the second claim.
Season 3 is again Maya and her problem, which remained unresolved, now Jill is involved in this matter. This storyline is just herpes.:LOL:
Second claim. The player cannot influence this problem in any way. He is just an outside observer who can morally support Maya, nothing more. His $5,000 will not fix the situation; in a good american college, this money is enough for one semester!

What irritates me most of all is that MC and the decisions he makes don't affect Stephen Burke's decision at all. This is what the players were hoping for, that if you were assholes and allowed fuck ups with this family before, then result would be negative, if you did not commit these actions, positive. It turned out that the storyline was just static and Burke turned down Maya when she said too much about the free tutotion at HOT's. Now that storyline has switched to Jill's lawyer (the mysterious Jonathan, I guess:illuminati:). MC just goes with the flow along the way.

Third claim. If MC is just an observer, why is this storyline one of the core of the game and not optional? Let's say the player is not on the M/J route, can't they just skip that part of the story if they don't like it?
For example, the option in episode 4 when talking to M / J at a party: "I wish you happiness, but I don’t see the possibility of us being friends in the future. All the best to you" I certainly would never choose this option because of Josy, but I think it is the place to be for the "dark lord players".
Or at the end of Ep.6: "Maya, I don't know how to help you. I'm poor."
And that's it. Players would sidestep Maya's problems, they wouldn't look intrusive, and there would be less hostility. Plot holes could be closed in other ways, although they would not exist, Maya would still be at the meeting with Burke, but MC would not know about it.
I am friendly to Maya from the very beginning and want everything to end well for her, no one deserves persecution for sexual orientation, this is not the Middle Ages. And Patrick should go to jail for blackmail and bank loan fraud. This is my position. This story is very long and I wish it to be closed as soon as possible.
Fourth. Josy. As a girl and as an LI, she is much more interesting than Maya, but due to Maya's storyline, she doesn't have her own. It is fixed on Maya and her problem. This is a problem that needs to be fixed and Josy needs to have her own story arc.
As for Maya as LI, she's not exactly my type. But I have to admit that she got better in Ep.8-9 - she doesn't behave like a damsel in distress, she becomes bolder and more relaxed. Damn, a lesbian who realized she was bi. At the beginning of the game she was touchy, now she fucks in college classroom, at the party and deep throating like a pro.:cool: She's definitely better than Jill.
Another small "BUT". Okay, not small. Her skin needs to be fixed, texture upscaling went really badly. :HideThePain:
scaryMaya.JPG
But if DPC has done such a job with all her renders like this, then that's good. I don't want to see that horror from Ep.9 again
4.jpg
 
Last edited:
Jan 31, 2023
335
825
  1. Josy, I like Josy she's a very expressive character, she wears her feelings on her sleeve and she doesn't mind getting down laughing at DIK MC's clowning on Tybalt etc. She's like the inverse of Maya in a lot of ways, and that discussion you have with her about her dad dumping her mom to become happy is pretty obviously DPC hinting at MJ breakup, at least IMO. I at least can't wait for the Josy solo path, easily my favorite of the MGs.
  2. Maya is a nice girl, she doesn't know how to deal with her emotions properly and she doesn't trust others, my favorite moment with Maya is ironically when she slaps Quinn (she deserved it tbh lmao). First time I played the game I was legit pissed when MC got rejected by MJ cause I was DIK affinity.
  3. Bella is an interesting character, I like her for the most part, but I was really never very interested because of the age gap, I always end up putting myself in MC's shoes and the simple answer is that it wouldn't work.
  4. Sage, my first playthrough was pretty much a Sage playthrough, she's undersexed and overworked due to her being in her final year in combination with having been used by a gay dude as a beard, I foresee her potentially getting kicked out as HOT president due to Quinn's decisions that Sage is getting the blame for, if you listen to what the other HOTs have to say none of them seem too pleased with how things are currently going.
  5. Jill is fine if you're into that kind of thing I guess, I just find the character to be a bit boring, and as others have pointed out I find that she's deteriorated over time as a character, Jill in the early seasons seems to be a well put together character, but at some point she just shifts and starts becoming silly in my opinion, first time I loaded my Jill save for E9 and saw the banana .
  6. Riona is actually a really cool girl, she's not full of herself, she seems genuine, but she's really not fit for anything more than a fuck buddy kind of thing due to reasons I don't think need further explanation.
  7. Sarah/Mel are an iconic thot duo, they know what they are, and they have no problem with it, Sarah's banter with Mel is hilarious.
  8. Camilla is pretty forgettable honestly, not bad, but there's not much about her that stands out (except that ass :BootyTime:).
  9. Lily is third place after Josy, despite her cocky demeanor she's obviously sensitive about being judged for being a stripper, and she has some kind of deeper secret, hence "don't fall in love with me", and she looks so sad when she says it too, aw :cry:.
  10. Quinn, fucking hilarious, I don't give a shit about her drug dealing and pimping, even if she did play tricks at first she stopped, I hope DPC doesn't corner MC into being henpecked by her, she obviously needs someone to put her in her place to be happy.

Could keep writing but those are the only characters I have anything to say about, all members of the MILF squad is a shitshow waiting to blow up in MC's face. Nicole is nice, but bruh she's got a 10 YO kid or something, dodge that fucking bullet lmao.

I started out trying to write nice things but meh whatever I just wrote what came to mind in the end.
 

Wizard_Shiryuu

Engaged Member
Sep 6, 2019
2,741
5,958
Lily's reaction is strange at the end of Ep 9 and this cold shower leaves players guessing and theorizing why she did it. But what if, in fact, Lily is already in love with MC? We've seen the preview and this look:
View attachment 2440372
And this is not at all clear, we see that she definitely likes him, but she protects herself from typical boyfriend-girlfriend things.
Lily is one of the most mysterious characters.
If I analise it with porn game logic on I'd say she totally likes him and she's lying to herself about it but if I try to use real life logic I'd say she means what she says. She likes him, but she doesn't want a guy around her being all jealous and possessive about her being a stripper and all and then she seems to have her life figured out, so she doesn't want a man interfering with that.

we are really close as a 'danger'

Quinn, we've seen her do worse, but at the same time we've also seen her fail in every one of her plans, while Lily hasn't missed a move. and the shady dealings they're involved in are pretty much the same.

is Lily's lucidity, which seems at all times like a girl with a plan, or Quinn's often self-destructive unpredictability more frightening?

we're very close, everyone make your bets
To me the most mysterious thing about Lily is her line in the HOT's house. "You're not the man you're supposed to be. Not yet anyway". What was that about?

Madame - The amazing reward you get for not helping the elderly when rebuilding the mansion.
Working on the Pink Rose and getting the "Prize" for Madam are two different events.

No one ever claimed that she isn't flawed, she's a drug dealing pimp, her 'tsundere/troll/scared of her true emotions' attitude is a great hook, I always go for the tsundere.

Actually is Quinn even a tsundere? She's into MC from early on so I don't think so.
Tsundere is not about liking the MC or not. It's about lying to herself and others saying she doesn't when she does.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Geralt From Rivia

Geralt From Rivia

Forum Fanatic
Jun 15, 2022
5,360
32,766
If I analise it with porn game logic on I'd say she totally likes him and she's lying to herself about it but if I try to use real life logic I'd say she means what she says. She likes him, but she doesn't want a guy around her being all jelous and possessive about her being a stripper and all and then she seems to have her life figured out, so she doesn't want a man interfering with that.
The fact that she is afraid of jealousy from a man and relationship problems because of her work as a stripper, I think the most normal and logical explanation for her "don't fall in love with me." This behavior is expected in real life and the least conspiratorial version.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wizard_Shiryuu

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,172
21,832
To me the most mysterious thing about Lily is her line in the HOT's house. "You're not the man you're supposed to be. Not yet anyway". What was that about?
without going down the rabbit hole, it will be a generic reference to the rumours about MC, probably referring to the fact that MC is not yet 'dominant' over DIKs as it should be according to both Quinn and Sage (who are probably Lily's source)
 

XCharlie

Newbie
Apr 28, 2021
20
41
Moral of every comments here is "MC" is the golden apple, and every girl with any type of past wants to take a bite of it. Talk about being so charming.
P.S: just saying, don't start debating on it or anything.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,538 Votes