- Jun 21, 2018
- 149
- 385
I will have to point out that this is a game. Acceptable breaks of reality to better enjoyment of the player and so he can actually juggle everything he can do. In real life, it's more likely you will find people willing to put up with cheating or even enter a polyamorous/free love relationship than the daughter of a multi-millionaire/billionaire, like Jill (and maybe Sage) are implied to be, dating outside their circle. Realistically speaking, MC/Josy/Maya is more probable than Jill/MC having any future. People should mind that realism goes for everything and not just specific reactions.First, plot hole is literally any impossible or unlikely event or inconsistency with the plot, so yes it definitely is one. Secondly, it matters not at all that you have an option to tell them that "you're fooling around" because you have an option not to as I did and that changed fuck all in their reaction to what happened. Thirdly I understand that porn games have completely rotted the minds of people in here but if MC tries to pursue relationship with 2 girls and fucks one of them while having done a bunch of sexual things and coming close to having sex with the other one he indeed is cheating on both of them. You don't have to to get a government certified license that would recognize you as a couple before you can cheat on someone.
I find Maya and Josy reaction hardly that impossible. They were suffering due to the lack of communication. They always liked and cared for each other but it got cold. Then they find out that of all things, their taste in men is similar enough that they sought emotional support in the same person. That's something that ought to get you talking.
Per definition of Wikipedia: In fiction, a plot hole, plothole or plot error is a gap or inconsistency in a storyline that goes against the flow of logic established by the story's plot. Such inconsistencies include things as illogical, unlikely or impossible events, and statements or events that contradict earlier events in the storylineI'll adress those by order.
No, a plot hole is a glaring contradiction of something previously stablished. Jill working in the Pink Rose could be a plot hole, because it contradicts everything preiously stablished for the character. Josy, Maya and the MC reacting the way they did doesn't contradict their personalities or anything. Bad writing? Maybe. But not a plot hole.
Telling them you're foolin around with other girls or not is irrelevant. Josy is on a relationship and Maya is only asking you to help her, neither of them demanded exclusivity from you. It's not cheating. Even Jill agrees with me.
View attachment 526386
And lastly, people in this thread are very sensible and discuss about pretty much anything peacefully. Saying that porn games corrupted our minds is disrespectful towards me and the others. You're entitled to your opinion, but you can express it without insulting others.
MC behavior isn't illogical or impossible. It's certainly kinda inconsistent but not for all players. Some who focused solely on Maya or mostly on her will think it's consistent. Or those who focused on Josy. Thats the issue with multiple choice games. If you do obligatory events, you will run afoul of someone gameplay unless you make the events with no flavor or emotional depth whatsoever.
Also you can't cheat per se when there's no commitment, no promise or intent to commit or even any demand by the other side of commitment. No one asked exclusivity of any kind of the MC. He is helping cheat for sure, and that's almost as scummy but the emotional situation is made very clear that everyone was super down and needing affection and they had no communication.