lordfridge9

Emperor of Universe 7
Donor
Aug 24, 2017
3,273
3,934
Ok got to ask your mother's mother had a miscarriage? or your mother's mother was micarried? Cause the way you typed that?
My grandmother had it, my mom told me about it and as a kid when we went to the cemetery, they'd always tend to his grave
 

lordfridge9

Emperor of Universe 7
Donor
Aug 24, 2017
3,273
3,934
But that theory is still predicated on Jill knowing or at least suspecting there's a thing between Bella and the MC, and that's certainly not the case. Also, in that theory of yours, Jill would almost be saying that her tempting a guy away from Bella is what's "not going to happen again", and why would she think that if she has no clue about Bella and the MC?

So I think the idea that Bella's husband made a move on Jill doesn't really seem to make a lot of sense.



For me, it's all about those renders where they appear to be looking intently into each others eyes.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Bella breaks the eye contact in a way that makes it feel like she thought something would happen if they kept looking at each other like that. After all, they've had a fairly nice, relaxed evening with a few glasses or perhaps even bottles of wine in an intimate, canled-lit ambience with a guy they both like, and who may also have played the guitar for them.

That seems like something that might make them both feel a little in the mood and it may be similar to how something happened before, hence why Bella ends the eye contact and why Jill tries to assure her that, "It's not gonna happen again."
You're probably going to end up right. I hope that it won't be one of those where something is shown, information is given but we never get any answers and it's just swept under the rug
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,535
You're probably going to end up right. I hope that it won't be one of those where something is shown, information is given but we never get any answers and it's just swept under the rug
I don't think this is going to be swept under the rug. It's too big of a thing to drop into this episode and not expand upon later. The strong hint that something, possibly sexual, happened between them in the past is something that people are most definitely going to want to know more about, especially if we get a flashback of it. :sneaky:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cndyrvr4lf

lordfridge9

Emperor of Universe 7
Donor
Aug 24, 2017
3,273
3,934
This theorizing can give anyone a headache. It's like watching a TV series and realizing that you, as the viewer see more things than the characters can and end up thinking about wild ways stuff can go, even when sometimes there's no reason to do so. Well there's certainly reason here, as Bella's invisible husband is the biggest mystery in this game. However, do we not know that it doesn't end well? After you and Bella kiss in the library, the MC monologues that if at the time he'd known everything, he wouldn't have kissed her. Hope this doesn't fuck Bella up :confused:
 

Cndyrvr4lf

Well-Known Member
Donor
Jun 16, 2017
1,225
1,331
This theorizing can give anyone a headache. It's like watching a TV series and realizing that you, as the viewer see more things than the characters can and end up thinking about wild ways stuff can go, even when sometimes there's no reason to do so. Well there's certainly reason here, as Bella's invisible husband is the biggest mystery in this game. However, do we not know that it doesn't end well? After you and Bella kiss in the library, the MC monologues that if at the time he'd known everything, he wouldn't have kissed her. Hope this doesn't fuck Bella up :confused:
Heck it started with the MC's introduction. Go back and read that and see how dark it can be interpreted.
 

TundraLupus

Well-Known Member
Apr 8, 2020
1,768
2,074
This theorizing can give anyone a headache. It's like watching a TV series and realizing that you, as the viewer see more things than the characters can and end up thinking about wild ways stuff can go, even when sometimes there's no reason to do so. Well there's certainly reason here, as Bella's invisible husband is the biggest mystery in this game. However, do we not know that it doesn't end well? After you and Bella kiss in the library, the MC monologues that if at the time he'd known everything, he wouldn't have kissed her. Hope this doesn't fuck Bella up :confused:
i remember the scene, but had another tone in my mind, do you have a screenshot of it? or now where i can find it?
And yeah, the theorizing is both awesome(because shows how much people love the game) and terrible(Because of how nonsensical it is).
 

lordfridge9

Emperor of Universe 7
Donor
Aug 24, 2017
3,273
3,934
I don't think this is going to be swept up under the rug. It's too big of a thing to drop into this episode and not expand upon later. The strong hint that something, possibly sexual, happened between them in the past is something that people are most definitely going to want to know more about, especially if we get a flashback of it. :sneaky:
You're probably gonna hate this, but it will only lead to adding more theorizing to the existance of a BellaxMCxJill path
 

mindern

Active Member
Jul 7, 2017
542
2,223
But that theory is still predicated on Jill knowing or at least suspecting there's a thing between Bella and the MC, and that's certainly not the case. Also, in that theory of yours, Jill would almost be saying that her tempting a guy away from Bella is what's "not going to happen again", and why would she think that if she has no clue about Bella and the MC?

So I think the idea that Bella's husband made a move on Jill doesn't really seem to make a lot of sense.



For me, it's all about those renders where they appear to be looking intently into each others eyes.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Bella breaks the eye contact in a way that makes it feel like she thought something would happen if they kept looking at each other like that. After all, they've had a fairly nice, relaxed evening with a few glasses or perhaps even bottles of wine in an intimate, canled-lit ambience with a guy they both like, and who may also have played the guitar for them.

That seems like something that might make them both feel a little in the mood and it may be similar to how something happened before, hence why Bella ends the eye contact and why Jill tries to assure her that, "It's not gonna happen again."

As much as I dislike the notion they hooked up, because it's wildly out of character but whatever... another line that could have some significance is this one from the night MC got drunk and kissed her.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Way back when the theory was she hooked up with Stephen people discussed this line as proof they didn't do anything. It is slightly odd she clarifies it's been 3 years since a man made her aroused. On it's own it easily could just be an oddly specific word choice but given the conversation with Jill in Ep5 it could be more. I still don't like the theory but it's got a lot of evidence at this point.
 

ThatGuyWho

Newbie
Jun 8, 2020
91
80
I think the miscarriage scenario is a good sad plot line without being as dark as AL, so it's probably gonna be it anyway.
 

lordfridge9

Emperor of Universe 7
Donor
Aug 24, 2017
3,273
3,934
I think the miscarriage scenario is a good sad plot line without being as dark as AL, so it's probably gonna be it anyway.
We should now put an end to this and start a new discussion. A better one! A lighter one! Who's the best side girl or HOT?
 

JohnDelfino

Member
Mar 27, 2020
169
415
I just hope that all the LI's get at least a normal or neutral ending, instead of "well you didn't pick this one so now her life will be crap" I literally played this Jap. Kinetic VN., where the MC was really questioning whom to choose as he liked each one individually very much, but if he didn't go for the harem, the one's who didn't get chosen wouldn't get a good life.
Funnily enough my main reason for leaning towards choosing Jill is to save her from ending up with Tybalt.
 

TundraLupus

Well-Known Member
Apr 8, 2020
1,768
2,074
Something along the lines of "He wouldn't have kissed her, he would have screamed for help"

It's right after he ask's Jill out
yeah, i don't know, from a chick mc perspective i would think it refers more to the fact that persuing her might have bad consequences for her, more than for himself, but yeah, i'll have to replay that part to form a proper opinion, if i remember correctly this was in the beginning of the game right?
 

lordfridge9

Emperor of Universe 7
Donor
Aug 24, 2017
3,273
3,934
yeah, i don't know, from a chick mc perspective i would think it refers more to the fact that persuing her might have bad consequences for her, more than for himself, but yeah, i'll have to replay that part to form a proper opinion, if i remember correctly this was in the beginning of the game right?
Towards the end of ep3, should be after gender studies class were you accept/reject Jade
 
4.80 star(s) 1,599 Votes