ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,453
14,245
Fair. I wasn't a huge fan of the 'fatal attraction' thing in AL, but I thought 'the choice' and the whole cancer storyline were done fairly well. To each their own, though.

That said... I think it's a bit strange to see people saying in previous pages in this thread that they'll be upset if BaDIK takes a dark turn. I mean, the game STARTS with a 'if you're in a dark place, don't play this!" disclaimer. Things are obviously going to get dark at some point. I don't know if it'll be 'crazy killer' AL dark or 'My Name is Luna' levels of dark, but it wouldn't surprise me.
For what it's worth, I thought Liam's cancer plot was very well handled. If BaDIK can pull off that level of dark, I don't think I'll object. Unfortunately, while serious, that's not really the dark part of AL. Hence my concern.
 

Darkdevil66

Magnificent Bastard
Donor
Apr 16, 2020
1,703
41,842
I still view Quinn as a prime suspect for the Cathy pic though, but I don't believe she will have conspired with the Jocks to do it if it was her doing. More likely I see it as Quinn unilaterally deciding to do it thinking that by getting the DIKs in trouble it would take some of the heat of the Jocks and she could try to persuade Dawe to make good on their previous deal.
Sounds like a terrible gamble. First of all, there's no evidence getting the DIKs in trouble will take some heat of the Jocks. Chad crossed a line without providing any kind of justification and Dawe isn't the perfect student either. They are perceived by teachers as potential bullies. Actions of others frats shouldn't change anything.

Secondly, Quinn intended to accept Tommy's offer. He provided her a safe and spacious place for their "private parties" and suggested her to involved more Diks as customers (Jaime, Leon and potentially the MC). Getting the Diks in trouble would definitely compromise everything. Her drug business requires several sources of profits. Sacrifice one for another isn't really smart. At this point Diks and Alphas should both be under surveillance.

Furthermore, time isn't on her side. Considering she has already been late with her suppliers, I doubt she has the luxury of waiting for the jocks to make good on their previous deal. Her attempt with the preps was a desperate move to get a lot of money quickly.

I still think Nick or Vinnie are more plausible suspects. Their potential motives are unclear but Vinnie is probably not mentioned so many times for no reason and Nick seems very uncomfortable with it. As a Dik, Nick has access to the vault and the laptop. Chad's blackmailer also sent personal pics of Arieth and the Diks. A selfie of a previous year including Rusty and Arieth and more recent pics (Jaime & Leon threesome during the cumpetition and Jakobs & Derek in janitor closet ). Which implied the blackmailer had access to Diks' old and new privates pictures. To me, a high scope plan to destroy the Diks sounds more interesting than a desesperate gamble. :unsure:
 
D

Deleted member 2739658

Guest
Guest
And yet those are prety clear cut facts that form a pretty solid conclusion. Hard to call it a theory when the evidence is clear as day.



That's a separate issue. Quinn being responsible for the pic leak is a theory, but what we're talking about here is that Quinn had a deal to sell pills to the Jocks and Dawe cancelled it once the Jocks got put under surveillance after the Chad incident and that's why he showed up at Quinn's room.
No, take it from someone who proposes a lot of theories on this game, and has considerable IRL experience with investigation, there is no conclusive proof to any theory in this game because ultimately it's the authors decision.
 
D

Deleted member 2739658

Guest
Guest
I'm fairly certain it was Quinn though I think it had to be in order to get in the DiKs safe. It's just too coindental that the safe was uncovered.
What's the safe have to do with it? Rusty doesn't keep the laptop in the safe until after the Cathy cluck. It's mentioned several times that the laptop was just left lying around most of the time.
 
D

Deleted member 2739658

Guest
Guest
Sorry to bring this back again, but I just can't help it. The infamous "MC warns Maya about Quinn" scene. This is the script:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Yeah, It is a huge plot hole. Once the MC becomes closer to Sage why doesn't he just tell her that Quinn is using the sorority as a front for prostitution?
 

ThePresident451

Yuno Gasai NEVER EVER follows you back
Donor
Apr 22, 2020
56
1,799
And yet those are prety clear cut facts that form a pretty solid conclusion. Hard to call it a theory when the evidence is clear as day.
Just like when you kept saying for months that mc wouldn't join the DIKs in ep 5:LUL:
If I were you I wouldn't be so sure about my assumptions:BootyTime:
Dude no offense but you always treat your theories like they are proven facts, add a bit of humbleness in your holy wine, it wouldn't hurt(y)
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,528
Just like when you kept saying for months that mc wouldn't join the DIKs in ep 5:LUL:
If I were you I wouldn't be so sure about my assumptions:BootyTime:
Dude no offense but you always treat your theories like they are proven facts, add a bit of humbleness in your holy wine, it wouldn't hurt(y)
I never said that he wouldn't join the DIKs, just that something could happen to delay it for a few more episodes.

Obviously, that didn't happen, but this is different. We have very clear evidence that Dawe went to see Quinn to renege on their deal because she tells Riona that what she talked about with him was "bad news", and then flat-out admits to Tommy that her deal with them is done.

So the nature of that clandestine meeting seen at the end of the ep 3 is hardly a "theory", it is what happened because the game pretty much says so.
 

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
905
2,364
What's the safe have to do with it? Rusty doesn't keep the laptop in the safe until after the Cathy cluck. It's mentioned several times that the laptop was just left lying around most of the time.
The laptop is a distraction for her to get in the safe.

My theory goes like this. Camila is fucking Rusty (we know she is off somewhere after the conversation with Mona) while Rusty is distracted someone (Riona) steals the laptop and posts the cluck. When all hell breaks loose Quinn goes in search of the DIKS stash of cash they use to fund the frat. She may or may not know about the safe. She wants the money to pay for her drug addiction. she may hope the safe isn’t locked or think she knows the number. Who knows? But the picture being dislodged to reveal the safe suggests someone was looking for it.

This is pure speculation on my part but it makes sense. Remember Quinn was there during spin the bottle, but suddenly when the lap top is gone she is nowhere to be found.

Sorry to bring this back again, but I just can't help it. The infamous "MC warns Maya about Quinn" scene. This is the script:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I agree he could be a bit more forthright in the moment. However perhaps the argument is he isn't against sex workers (he seems to have a soft spot for Camilla and Riona) but he doesn't trust the way Quinn gets the girls involved. So in essence if Maya wants to be a sex worker who is her to judge. But if Quinn tries to force or blackmail her that's different and he Maya should know it's a possibility.
Yeah, It is a huge plot hole. Once the MC becomes closer to Sage why doesn't he just tell her that Quinn is using the sorority as a front for prostitution?
My assumption is the MC would think that Sage knows about the escorting. It's going on right under her nose and involves all of the second years and possibly some of the first years not to mention the 'Daughters'
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: ename144
D

Deleted member 2739658

Guest
Guest
The laptop is a distraction for her to get in the safe.

My theory goes like this. Camila is fucking Rusty (we know she is off somewhere after the conversation with Mona) while Rusty is distracted someone (Riona) steals the laptop and posts the cluck. When all hell breaks loose Quinn goes in search of the DIKS stash of cash they use to fund the frat. She may or may not know about the safe. She wants the money to pay for her drug addiction.

This is pure speculation on my part but it makes sense. Remember Quinn was there during spin the bottle, but suddenly when the lap top is gone she is know where to be found.




My assumption is the MC would think that Sage knows about the escorting. It's going on right under her nose and involves all of the second years and possibly some of the first years not to mention the 'Daughters'
How would she know the combination to the safe?
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,528
The laptop is a distraction for her to get in the safe.

My theory goes like this. Camila is fucking Rusty (we know she is off somewhere after the conversation with Mona) while Rusty is distracted someone (Riona) steals the laptop and posts the cluck. When all hell breaks loose Quinn goes in search of the DIKS stash of cash they use to fund the frat. She may or may not know about the safe. She wants the money to pay for her drug addiction.

This is pure speculation on my part but it makes sense. Remember Quinn was there during spin the bottle, but suddenly when the laptop is gone she is know where to be found.
I can see that being a possibility, but Quinn isn't needing money because she has a drug addiction, she needs it to pay the dealers that she gets the drugs from that she supplies on campus because she's coming up short on the payments to them.

How would she know the combination to the safe?
She wouldn't, probably because she naively wouldn't think it would be in a wall safe. She might have thought she'd find it in a lock box that she could carry out of the mansion or even break open and take what she needed from it.

Then again, maybe she was able to get the combination out of Tommy when he was wasted on drugs but ended up not having as much time as she thought to get it open.
 

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
905
2,364
I can see that being a possibility, but Quinn isn't needing money because she has a drug addiction, she needs it to pay the dealers that she gets the drugs from that she supplies on campus because she's coming up short on the payments to them.



She wouldn't, probably because she naively wouldn't think it would be in a wall safe. She might have thought she'd find it in a lock box that she could carry out of the mansion or even break open and take what she needed from it.

Then again, maybe she was able to get the combination out of Tommy when he was wasted on drugs but ended up not having as much time as she thought to get it open.
I’m fairly sure the reason she is coming up short is because she is getting high on her own supply. She blames it of Riona (classic junky move) but I frankly don’t think she would dare to go against Quinn in this way. Plus when she has the conversation with Riona I don’t think she even mentions the idea it might be her fault.

She is the only one we see injecting drugs, and trying to get other people on board with that. She’s already selling the Jocks sugar pills if she isn’t using where exactly has this inability to pay her dealer come from?

How would she know the combination to the safe?
As HB says, she might of thought she new the code, or hoped it would be unlocked or simply not realised it was in a safe and been hoping it was just hidden somewhere.
 

Tserriednich'sNen

Engaged Member
Jan 16, 2020
2,257
6,061
I have a question which may possibly be a glaring plot hole. So the real reason Quinn convices Sage to go along with her plan to go to the Preps Hell Week party was so that she could try and sell to them out of desperation to make money. However Heather tells Riona that the HOT's make more than enough money to support all the new pledges and questions why they had to be there which begs the question wouldn't Sage as the President of the HOT's be well aware of this and shut down Quinns idea in the first place?
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member 2739658

Guest
Guest
I’m fairly sure the reason she is coming up short is because she is getting high on her own supply. She blames it of Riona (classic junky move) but I frankly don’t think she would dare to go against Quinn in this way. Plus when she has the conversation with Riona I don’t think she even mentions the idea it might be her fault.

She is the only one we see injecting drugs, and trying to get other people on board with that. She’s already selling the Jocks sugar pills if she isn’t using where exactly has this inability to pay her dealer come from?



As HB says, she might of thought she new the code, or hoped it would be unlocked or simply not realised it was in a safe and been hoping it was just hidden somewhere.
So she's going to destroy the DIK's, the Frat where a good number of her customers are members, just to try to carry out a poorly planned scheme? You guys are really reaching here. I think it's much more likely that Quinn has just mis-managed her drug business just like we've already seen her mis-manage her prostitution business.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 311 and Darkdevil66

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,528
I have a question which may possibly be a glaring plot hole. So the real reason Quinn convices Sage to go along with her plan to go to the Preps Hell Week party was so that she could try and sell to them out of desperation to sell to them. However Heather tells Riona that the HOT's make more than enough money to support all the new pledges and questions why they had to be there which begs the question wouldn't Sage as the President of the HOT's be well aware of this and shut down Quinns idea in the first place?
We know that Sage pretty much leaves the running of the HOTs to Quinn and she seems like a pretty hands-off President. So maybe she's unaware of how much the HOTs make from their non-illegal ventures and Quinn was able to convince her they needed to to do this to support all the new girls joining.

Heather also may be blissfully unaware of how much the HOTs make from the non-illegal ventures and is ignorantly under the impression that all their charitable and community ventures make more than they actually do because they're bolstered by Quinn's drug and prositution rings, and Quinn essentially "cooks the books" to hide it.

So she's going to destroy the DIK's, the Frat where a good number of her customers are members, just to try to carry out a poorly planned scheme? You guys are really reaching here. I think it's much more likely that Quinn has just mis-managed her drug business just like we've already seen her mis-manage her prostitution business.
Everybody always gets this part wrong. IF Quinn were behind the Cathy pic, it's not because she's intentionally trying to sabotage or "destroy" the DIKs, or that she even thinks this would accidentally result in any kind of serious harm. It would simply be a rash and impulsive move out of desperation that she would naively and perhaps also arrogantly believe would be something the DIKs can easily bounce back from and that she'd get away with.

Quinn likes to mess with people, particularly if it suits her best interests, but certainly doesn't seem like someone who really thinks through the potential consequences of her actions, and this would certainly fit that bill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ExDeath730
D

Deleted member 2739658

Guest
Guest
We know that Sage pretty much leaves the running of the HOTs to Quinn and she seems like a pretty hands-off President. So maybe she's unaware of how much the HOTs make from their non-illegal ventures and Quinn was able to convince her they needed to to do this to support all the new girls joining.

Heather also may be blissfully unaware of how much the HOTs make from the non-illegal ventures and is ignorantly under the impression that all their charitable and community ventures make more than they actually do because they're bolstered by Quinn's drug and prositution rings, and Quinn essentially "cooks the books" to hide it.



Everybody always gets this part wrong. IF Quinn were behind the Cathy pic, it's not because she's intentionally trying to sabotage or "destroy" the DIKs, or that she even thinks this would accidentally result in any kind of serious harm. It would simply be a rash and impulsive move out of desperation that she would naively and perhaps also arrogantly believe would be something the DIKs can easily bounce back from and that she'd get away with.

Quinn likes to mess with people, particularly if it suits her best interests, but certainly doesn't seem like someone who really thinks through the potential consequences of her actions, and this would certainly fit that bill.
No, that's just not plausible in any way. The whole theory just feels very flimsy. As I said before I think you're really reaching on this one.
 

Tserriednich'sNen

Engaged Member
Jan 16, 2020
2,257
6,061
We know that Sage pretty much leaves the running of the HOTs to Quinn and she seems like a pretty hands-off President. So maybe she's unaware of how much the HOTs make from their non-illegal ventures and Quinn was able to convince her they needed to to do this to support all the new girls joining.

Heather also may be blissfully unaware of how much the HOTs make from the non-illegal ventures and is ignorantly under the impression that all their charitable and community ventures make more than they actually do because they're bolstered by Quinn's drug and prositution rings, and Quinn essentially "cooks the books" to hide it.
Maybe however wouldn't Quinn keep all the dirty money for herself since she owes her supplier?
 
4.80 star(s) 1,573 Votes