Ilhares

Engaged Member
Aug 19, 2019
2,934
11,447
But that would still make Jade his Aunt and even non-blood relatives are considered incest under Patreon's TOS and under the law in the U.S., so this is probably not what it will be.
The TOS are much more important here. He does biz with them, he'll likely avoid it.

Incest laws in the US vary by state. Some include non-blood relations, others don't care as long as it isn't mother/father or son/daughter connection.

I think the MC is pretty safe all around, though I can't recall if we ever got much more detail about Neil's family. Does MC have any cousins that he knows about?
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,368
13,969
That "Oh!!!!! I came!!!!" is some Oblivion NPC level acting from the MC.

Also, did you really just name him MC?
It's not exactly "When Harry Met Sally," is it? Good thing drunk, horny college kids are an easy crowd!

And no, I don't name him MC normally, I just try to rename him for screenshots when practical. Avoids that moment of confusion.
 

ratttta

Member
Jun 8, 2018
166
411
MC being a Burgmeister would be such a cheap 'small world' reveal. I would like to think DPC is a better writer than that.
Exactly, also, extremely predictable. Why pass on the opportunity to reveal the mother´s family to be even more powerful than burgmeister or royce? Just to see some jaws drop (im looking at you, tybalt :cautious:) and make the mc more of a badass/ass when he refuses/uses that power. Wishfull thinking but I can dream. :cool:
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,555
10,288
Exactly, also, extremely predictable. Why pass on the opportunity to reveal the mother´s family to be even more powerful than burgmeister or royce? Just to see some jaws drop (im looking at you, tybalt :cautious:) and make the mc more of a badass/ass when he refuses/uses that power. Wishfull thinking but I can dream. :cool:
That's IT, you've finally hit on the problem I have with the MC as a B or R, big fish/small pond. The way some people talk about the Burgmeisters and Royces you'd think the were the Rockafellers or the Vanderbilts, their values might be no more than $8 to $12,000,000; not to be sniffed at but certainly not in the 0.0001%.
 

ratttta

Member
Jun 8, 2018
166
411
That's IT, you've finally hit on the problem I have with the MC as a B or R, big fish/small pond. The way some people talk about the Burgmeisters and Royces you'd think the were the Rockafellers or the Vanderbilts, their values might be no more than $8 to $12,000,000; not to be sniffed at but certainly not in the 0.0001%.
Sure, I got carried away :ROFLMAO:. Thinking clearly now, you are completely right. We want the MC to remain relatable.
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,555
10,288
Sure, I got carried away :ROFLMAO:. Thinking clearly now, you are completely right. We want the MC to remain relatable.
His family background, whether it be a family with a few million in the bank, earned over the last 2 generations, or an inherited wealth of billions accumulated over 200 years and retain through mutliple stock market crashes, shouldn't really affect how we see him. How he reacts upon learning about this background might.

My point was about the B&R names not mattering all that much once you leave the college environment and venture out into the real world. At B&R, Jill's last name matters, that doesn't mean it matters everywhere and the fact that Rusty was rejected by the Preps supports that (if he were a hot girl, maybe things would've been different and s/he'd have got a room too.
 

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,533
I honestly don't get why people think that if the MC turned out to be Burg that it would be such a terrible thing.

If this letter has anything to do with him discovering who is mother's family are, it doesn't carry as much weight for the story if he turns out to be from a rich family that we don't know about, even if they are, in this fictional world, considered to be a more prestigious family then the Bs and Rs. Whilst he does still gain a link to a (presumably) prestigious family and possibly access to money, gaining the name of Burgmeister has a far greater impact because of its, and by extension his, link to the college as well as to certain other characters. The implications of this revelation would also have far greater resonance than if he were from some other random high society family, because it's all well and good that he's from that family, but being from a family so closely linked to the story is much more relevant.

DPC is a good writer and they've crafted a very involved story with characters that people have really come to love, but they're not Shakespeare, or Hemingway, or even Stephen King. This is, at the end of the day, a porn game based on the college/school comedy genre of movies, and whilst I do expect some twists and turns, and I fully accept that the Burg theory may not turn out to be true, it is not outside the realms of possibility and would work perfectly well without bringing down the quality of this game and its storytelling in any way.
 
Last edited:

Holy Bacchus

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 13, 2018
7,748
19,533
His family background, whether it be a family with a few million in the bank, earned over the last 2 generations, or an inherited wealth of billions accumulated over 200 years and retain through mutliple stock market crashes, shouldn't really affect how we see him. How he reacts upon learning about this background might.

My point was about the B&R names not mattering all that much once you leave the college environment and venture out into the real world. At B&R, Jill's last name matters, that doesn't mean it matters everywhere and the fact that Rusty was rejected by the Preps supports that (if he were a hot girl, maybe things would've been different and s/he'd have got a room too.
But this is a self-contained story, and right now this college is his world and will be his world for the next 4 years. What happens after college isn't the concern, what happens now is, and as is so often the case at that age, everything seems much bigger than it is and a person's social standing means a lot and carries a lot of weight. Therefore, having the name of Royce and Burgmeister at this college carries some perks, like Jill being able to live in the Prep mansion and the campus authorities looking the other way so Rusty can get alcohol in to the DIK parties.

The purpose of potentially revealing the MC's heritage would be to affect both him and those around him as part of the overall narrative. It's not meant to have an affect on the player's perceptions, but seeing how it impacts the story is, and that's why it would be done, because it adds extra flavour/drama to the story.

Also, Rusty was turned away from the Preps because he didn't fit the snooty, preppy mould. Had he been more of an elitist snob as all other Preps seem to be, then he may have been accepted. So it's not that he was rejected for being a Burgmeister, he was rejected for not being like them.
 

NinjaHanzo

Newbie
Aug 18, 2020
70
99
I love this game, bought it on Steam and it was amazing, i even bought it as a present for a friend.

I will buy Season 2 too. (The wait feels long!)

DrPinkCake keep the good work my man!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Real Kreten

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,368
13,969
I honestly don't get why people think that if the MC turned out to be Burg that it would be such a terrible thing.

If this letter has anything to do with him discovering who is mother's family are, it doesn't carry as much weight for the story if he turns out to be from a rich family that we don't know about, even if they are, in this fictional world, considered to be a more prestigious family then the Bs and Rs. Whilst he does still gain a link to a (presumably) prestigious family and possibly access to money, gaining the name of Burgmeister has a far greater impact because of its, and by extension his, link to the college as well as to certain other characters. The implications of this revelation would also have far greater resonance than if he were from some other random high society family, because it's all well and good that he's from that family, but being from a family so closely linked to the story is much more relevant.

DPC is a good writer and they've crafted a very involved story with characters that people have really come to love, but they're not Shakespeare, or Hemingway, or even Stephen King. This is, at the end of the day, a porn game based on the college/school comedy genre of movies, and whilst I do expect some twists and turns, and I fully accept that the Burg theory may not turn out to be true, it is not outside the realms of possibility and would work perfectly well without bringing down the quality of this game and its storytelling in any way.
His mother's family carries as much weight as the narrative gives it. No more, no less.

For all the talk about Burgmeisters and Royces being special, at the end of the day they have had a lot less say in the way things in the game world work than the Burkes have. The Episode 5 flashback made that perfectly clear. And it's not like learning Jill's last name has shown her a new light.

Why would the Lynette's family be any different? Even if the MC becomes the new heir of the Burgmeister clan, it will still be up to future episodes to establish exactly what that would mean; there's no existing role he would automatically assume. The name itself means nothing.

If DPC wants the MC to suddenly gain campus-wide notoriety, or plot-bending amounts of money, or Tybalt sucking up to him 24/7, he can do it. He'll do it via the dialog and actions of the scenes that establish this new status quo and its consequences. But whatever that narrative establishes could apply every bit as much to, say, the Warbucks as it would to the Burgmeisters.

So no, it's not that the MC being a Burg would be a terrible thing. It's just that it would be a pointless thing that insists on a bunch of unnecessary contrivances and coincidences to accomplish its mission. It's a redundant thing.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes