- Aug 4, 2020
- 3,506
- 19,701
My wife was done with GOT when Sean Bean died. Just think of all the other gut wrenching end of season twists she missed out on because of that attitude!I have to say, as a Maya fan (see icon/sig) and a fan of the throuple of Josy/Maya/MC, if he pulls an "AL" level twist on those three, I think I'd be done with his products. There's no reason to go with a nuclear level twist in every drama game/story, specially one that's supposedly based on 80's/90's college comedies etc. There's nothing wrong with just having happy endings for all involved who chose the right options. But to take away player agency and just destroy relationship to be "edgy" will just end up tanking his following.
I like the writing in both his projects so far, the characters are all well rounded and spoken, but falling back on a previously used (and controversial) twist/mechanic would only hurt him in the long run from a business standpoint.
Remember Jill warned at the beginning that this game would make you angry and sad. We're not going to get out unscathed. I like it, it makes the games more memorable when it leaves you contemplating suicide for a week or two afterwards...