Walter Victor

Conversation Conqueror
Dec 27, 2017
6,009
20,452
The entire story is being told by the MC. "Let me tell you what happened.." He is telling you about things he knows now because he knows the entire story now. There is no information we have that the MC doesn't have because he is telling us the story. The fact that he may not have had all of the information at various points in the story is irrelevant. The story is not being told in a chronological sequence. It even skips calendar days. The MC may not have known about Quinn's drug sales at some point in the story but he knew about it when he told us the story, which was after the story was over. The MC can't tell about events that haven't happened and of which he has no knowledge, and, again, he is the one telling the story.

View attachment 1188314
So who told the MC about the conversations between Melanie and Sarah, that only they are privy too, especially if I only play the CHICK route and have nothing to do with either of them. Did the MC tell Jill to do the intro?

There are details shown in this game that the MC would NEVER learn of. He was never there, and no one would ever think to relate them.

Of course, like I do, maybe he just read the script!
 

Bloom12345

Member
Nov 14, 2018
140
90
I've played both max chick and max dik paths, is neutral one that different and worth trying?
chick and dik are a bit like ntr while neutral does the hard choices automaticly.
Nice example is the option to go further in Bella's car with Cathy, neutral chooses auto to finish their relationship keeping you on Bella's path.
 

Bloom12345

Member
Nov 14, 2018
140
90
Ya hate that I don't get the lake scene with her since I'm DIK affinity, but I'm not changing that. Maybe when the game is done I'll give scrappy's mod a go. :) Jill does look good in that bikini.
All seems to go back to wearing the helmet the first time(forced as DIK), after that you dont get the tennis showerscene or the lake scene watever you try....
 
D

Deleted member 2729089

Guest
Guest
Gosh, this game has made me nostalgic for my college years, even though I was a complete loser, had zero friends, the girls weren't as hot, and I was a virgin :cry: . As a side note, Bella rejected me, not poggers guys, not poggers at all...
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Trysexual

Newbie
Apr 13, 2021
57
229
So who told the MC about the conversations between Melanie and Sarah, that only they are privy too, especially if I only play the CHICK route and have nothing to do with either of them. Did the MC tell Jill to do the intro?

There are details shown in this game that the MC would NEVER learn of. He was never there, and no one would ever think to relate them.

Of course, like I do, maybe he just read the script!
There are holes in the writing that may or may not be filled in later. I am not arguing that point. That's the kind of detail that can easily be overlooked when you're trying to do everything yourself. I'm just saying that we were told the MC is telling the story and so we have to take that at face value, even when it makes no logical sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RukiRG

Irgendwie Irgendwo

Engaged Member
Jun 30, 2018
2,805
3,437
Finally finished the Neutral Path playthrough, so I'd like to give some of my musings. I'm sorry for any repetitions, but this thread is impossible to keep up with.

- Opening Gambit: There goes the fan theory that Jill's sister is our deceased mom. Age-wise this doesn't check out at all, even if she might have given Neil a false name.

- Love the new phone interface (and the money limit upgrade), especially the bios.

- I feel the destroyed DIK Mansion is this game's fire, so there won't be anything burnt down. We should be safe once it's fully renovated.

- Updated possible complications for the five love interests:

* Maya: Patrick finds out and goes through with the blackmail, despite Sage's help.
* Josy: maybe her "bi-ness" swings more to the female side again? Otherwise I can't think of anything right now.
* Sage: Too busy with her diss, will be gone after this year.
* Isabella: Obviously her husband will return. Still don't think that he is dead or wandering around the locked room as a mummy.
* Jill: Jealousy variable. She could make our life hell if she's p.o. with us. Could she even be this game's Leah? Other than that, her parents may have a problem with the class difference.

- I won't get into politics as per forum rules, but FU, Tybalt Burke. Or rather, nobody FsU, Tybalt.

- Maya and Neil should go on this world's version of The Amazing Race as the second coming of Team BuBGAS (Bubbly Blonde / Great American Superdad), Mallory and Gary Ervin. (TAR 17 and 18, Mallory additionally on 24 as replacement candidate for the first two legs) Even though Josy is bubblier and had dad the rosary rattler.

- You gotta enjoy the little things in life. Tommy behaved like a HUGE DIK, and was a shitty father, so his room is getting treated last. :D

- Sometimes it's good to play catchup because you locked yourself out of scenes. I finally understood why Elena was consoling the crying Ashley during the ANO Party.

- Did anybody find out the significance of Karen Rebecca's hearing aid? Why spend two renders on closeups? Or did she stuff something else in there?

- So Sally is hyper due to pill abuse. That slap was justified though.

- If it's true what the WT is saying that you get girls for free if you haven't used the "restaurant" but have to pay for the same scene if you did then I find that a little bit illogical.

- Chad's fan theory held, although Troy was a surprise, at least for me.

- WAY TMI, Wendy! Seriously, nobody cares.

That's what was on top of my head, I didn't fully understand some of the stuff that were going on in the ending montage as it was pretty cryptic again (Maya's involvement with the HOTs as a full member, Karen Rebecca as mentioned, Sage's plan, Tommy's overnight guest (looks like that wasn't Heather) and some other stuff) - bring on the Season Finale!
 
Last edited:

Casmyr

Quarters
Donor
Dec 6, 2018
1,906
6,477
Finally finished the Neutral Path playthrough, so I'd like to give some of my musings. I'm sorry for any repetitions, but this thread is impossible to keep up with.

- Opening Gambit: There goes the fan theory that Jill's sister is our deceased mom. Age-wise this doesn't check out at all, even if she might have given Neil a false name.

- I feel the destroyed DIK Mansion is this game's fire, so there won't be anything burnt down. We should be safe once it's fully renovated.

- Updated possible complications for the five love interests:

* Maya: Patrick finds out and goes through with the blackmail, despite Sage's help.
* Josy: maybe her "bi-ness" swings more to the female side again? Otherwise I can't think of anything right now.
* Sage: Too busy with her diss, will be gone after this year.
* Isabella: Obviously her husband will return. Still don't think that he is dead or wandering around the locked room as a mummy.
* Jill: Jealousy variable. She could make our life hell if she's p.o. with us. Could she even be this game's Leah? Other than that, her parents may have a problem with the class difference.

- I won't get into politics as per forum rules, but FU, Tybalt Burke. Or rather, nobody FsU, Tybalt.

- Maya and Neil should go on this world's version of The Amazing Race as the second coming of Team BuBGAS (Bubbly Blonde / Great American Superdad), Mallory and Gary Ervin. (TAR 17 and 18, Mallory additionally on 24 as replacement candidate for the first two legs) Even though Josy is bubblier and had dad the rosary rattler.

- You gotta enjoy the little things in life. Tommy behaved like a HUGE DIK, and was a shitty father, so his room is getting treated last. :D

- Sometimes it's good to play catchup because you locked yourself out of scenes. I finally understood why Elena was consoling the crying Ashley during the ANO Party.

- Did anybody find out the significance of Karen Rebecca's hearing aid? Why spend two renders on closeups? Or did she stuff something else in there?

- So Sally is hyper due to pill abuse. That slap was justified though.

- If it's true what the WT is saying that you get girls for free if you haven't used the "restaurant" but have to pay for the same scene if you did then I find that a little bit illogical.

- Chad's fan theory held, although Troy was a surprise, at least for me.

- WAY TMI, Wendy! Seriously, nobody cares.

That's what was on top of my head, I didn't fully understand some of the stuff that were going on in the ending montage as it was pretty cryptic again (Maya's involvement with the HOTs as a full member, Karen Rebecca as mentioned, Sage's plan, Tommy's overnight guest (looks like that wasn't Heather) and some other stuff) - bring on the Season Finale!
Mate. Put some respect on her name.
Its Karen Rebecca Johnson.
 

Deleted member 15555

Harem Lover
Donor
Apr 25, 2017
3,482
11,927
Shes just hypocritical. Calling them whores yet willing to so some of the same things for free tuition.
Actually, she heard rumors but did not believe them at all or did think that was "part" of the free tuition, I think Maya is kinda gullible in that aspect and is not hypocritical at all because when she heard what that free tuition may entail she doesn't join the Hots.
 

goldenrule91

Member
Feb 26, 2021
223
1,192
Thoughts on Bella's locked room being a nursery anyone?
That'd be sad af, my guess is it's something to do with BDSM or some shit, but then again I think Jill is surprised the door is locked so it might be something more mundane...

We debated that back over on page 4371.

Mc looks under the door gap and sees a pair of military looking boots. We think its a mannequin
Any more good page references for this thread honored elder? I went back to 5k and have been reading onwards from there to see debates and theories and shit that are still relevant.
 

drakken

Active Member
Nov 13, 2017
862
1,092
Actually, she heard rumors but did not believe them at all or did think that was "part" of the free tuition, I think Maya is kinda gullible in that aspect and is not hypocritical at all because when she heard what that free tuition may entail she doesn't join the Hots.
She continued tho, even knowing what was on the list. Doing some of the same things she called them whores for doing.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes