- Jul 29, 2017
- 539
- 1,140
If your assumption was true, there would be a lot more similar complaints towards other characters. That's what I'm basing my conclusion on the fact that you don't get anything like that for the other Pink Rose girls. While Madame might not be outright ugly, in my book she's off-putting, especially among a cast of good looking women.It tells me that most people don't like her, that's it. Which is something I already agreed with in my original post. Anything else without sufficient evidence like examples would simply be projecting. Sorta like I did in my original post only I've read people share sentiment about MR taking away from development time in other areas of the game. I personally haven't seen people mention her having an ugly face or saggy body. But even if that were the case, that doesn't make it the definitive reason like you're implying.
It's also kind of interesting you would mention projecting, as I don't have a problem of recognizing a woman is beautiful even if I'm not attracted to her myself. Someone who might be a bit of an egregious example is Angelina Jolie, whom I'm not personally fond of.
I was kind of referring to the fact that players are quick to lap-up Quinn's tragic backstory and latch onto any excuse for her behavior. I mean, there's nothing wrong with liking the character model, or even her personality. But having a shitty childhood is not an excuse for acting badly towards others. I'm willing to bet a majority of criminals have the same background, but I doubt those who defend Quinn would apply the same logic to those cases.I would agree that the plot and character development isn't exactly peak fiction. You could even argue that it's poorly done. That has nothing to do with people's enjoyment or excitement of said development. People can enjoy objectively shitty pieces of fiction. Bad development or not, people are excited for the plot/character development. The reasons why are irrelevant.
It's relatable up to a certain point, but if everyone in the cast shares the same general background it's effectiveness is seriously diminished, to the point of becoming a cliche and a foregone conclusion. At this point I would be surprised if a character in the game doesn't have a 'tragic childhood™'.I think the reason this is utilized so often is simply because it's so much more relatable. Out of all the folks I know, I can only pinpoint one guy in that lot who was ever truly confused by it, because he had the pair of loving parents as a child, and things were relatively good for him. The revelation of just how many of his friends don't have that kind of a childhood is one he's had some difficulty grasping.
And in some cases it's not realistic. Yes I'm talking about Quinn again, where it's used as a ploy to get us to sympathize with her and excuse her otherwise shitty behavior. In my personal experience, people who suffer a bad childhood would more likely avoid doing the same to others rather than intentionally perpetuate their damage.