Oliver Wendell Homely

Active Member
May 9, 2020
663
2,415
I know you guys probably went over this multiple times but I can't read through 7.5k pages

with AL in mind I can't help myself but to have ominous thoughts about the ending of the game. I know it's far and a lot of shit will happen meanwhile but still... when the game starts with "I was happy back then. we didn't have much, we... erm... we had enough. we had each other. as for now? let me tell you what happened"

in my mind, MC is writing/thinking about this from a jail cell, probably being the scapegoat for quinn's drug circle or something similar.

can anyone convince me I'm wrong so I feel better about this? :D
There has indeed been much discussion on this. All I can say with any certainty is that DPC has directly said he does not want to repeat himself and that BaDIK is a very different game than AL was. It doesn't mean there won't be drama and perhaps even some very sad and shocking events in BaDIK, but I think for him to copy the same forumla--that is, having some impossible, gut wrenching tragedy happen--would be too M. Night Shyamalan and no one wants to be M. Night Shyamalan.

Having said that, you are right that there has already been a lot of foreshadowing of dramatic events (for Bella, in particular) and clearly Quinn is in danger and Riona thinks someone is following her, etc. etc., so this will almost certainly NOT be a sappy harem-fantasy fairy tale, that's for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nyrek

always86

Active Member
Mar 19, 2020
875
2,259
I dont think Chad is an antagonist since season 1... We barely know anything about Bella's husband, and I am pretty sure Vinny will be the one the overall antagonist as a drug kingpin with Nick being a mole (although for some reason I am not discarding Leon). Obviously on the Maya/Josy plot Maya's father the antagonist. Quinn is not obviously not a true antagonist for a bunch of reasons despite being a total bitch. I have a feeling Sage's father (I assume its the manbun dude on the Prep's party) will be an antagonist of sort but will end up a good guy. In fact, I think all fathers (Maya's, Quinn's, Sage's, the MC's) will all be somewhat redeemed.

My opinion Vinny is the one true fuck up in this story and eventually will step on Nick too (his only friend)
Nick is the obvious mole. It’s just a bit to obvious. I agree Leon is an interesting suspect, and is actually my choice presuming Nick is a red herring.

When I’m talking about antagonist’s I mean either motivating the plot or another characters actions. Quinn motivates the main plot and plays a part in the Maya and Josy story (along with Maya’s Dad). Chad motivates Sage’s choices, Tybalt, Jill and James, Bella. It’s Bella’s conflicted feelings that are the core of her story right now.

It’s possible that Man Bun is Sages Dad, but I think that is a mislead, I think Sages Dad Is Stephen Burke and Man Bun is Arieth‘s dad. Possible Man Bun is Sage’s dad and Jade’s ex-husband, but I’m 99% certain Sage is connected to the Burke’s.
 

Zirael Q

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2017
1,616
9,555
I hope it's the latter too, supplying a strip club sounds more fun than boring parties where you try to scam some rich kids that don't want to buy your stuff
no it can't be, it'd be too plain !! She must secretly be an undercover Martian collecting evidence for the world's most abduction worth person!! And it's Quinn, she'll be abducted and experimented on by aliens!! AND THAT'S WHAT SHE DESERVES!!!!
 

nyrek

Active Member
Apr 19, 2021
974
14,035
Having said that, you are right that there has already been a lot of foreshadowing of dramatic events (for Bella, in particular) and clearly Quinn is in danger and Riona thinks someone is following her, etc. etc., so this will almost certainly NOT be a sappy harem-fantasy fairy tale, that's for sure.
oh I didn't expect it to be such a thing but... after some of the events you've mentioned, especially the bella one that stuck cause it was commented on by the MC... I would hate to see a really dark ending after waiting for the story to unwind for several years.
I definitely expect lots of crap to happen but I'm trying to calm myself down with a ridiculous amount of optimism, thinking there won't be any severe consequences for the MC other than fights with alphas and perhaps a temporary suspension by the college board
 

Klopdwerg

Member
Sep 7, 2021
357
747
I dont think Chad is an antagonist since season 1... We barely know anything about Bella's husband, and I am pretty sure Vinny will be the one the overall antagonist as a drug kingpin with Nick being a mole (although for some reason I am not discarding Leon). Obviously on the Maya/Josy plot Maya's father the antagonist. Quinn is not obviously not a true antagonist for a bunch of reasons despite being a total bitch. I have a feeling Sage's father (I assume its the manbun dude on the Prep's party) will be an antagonist of sort but will end up a good guy. In fact, I think all fathers (Maya's, Quinn's, Sage's, the MC's) will all be somewhat redeemed.

My opinion Vinny is the one true fuck up in this story and eventually will step on Nick too (his only friend)
I think Vinny will be more involved in the upcoming episodes.
Lily is asking for a new and reliable dealer and approaches Quinn. What if her former dealer was Vinny? That would leave a grudge towards Quinn. Especially since she is asking for all the Pink Rose girls.
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
People actually think this is CSI:Miami or Sherlock or something, lol. All theories like that include Quinn overdosing, dying or getting jailed for "some reason" :Kappa:. Chances of Lily being undercover is as likely as likely as Jill deepthroating MC's dick. Cop Lily theory is completely baseless and a stupid theory.

She's been working for a long time at The Pink Rose.
Enrolls to B&R as a reject.
DIKs constantly ask her to join HOTs, she says okay okay, cool and does it.
All the girls of The Pink Rose are close to each other, they know everything about each other(maybe Madame doesn't hang out with them but idk).
In Sandy/Nicole scene, Sandy asks if Nicole has anything to smoke, Nicole says no, she's out. If you are able to solve the equation of "what is 2+2?", you know they are not talking about cigarettes.
Meanwhile Lily hears that Quinn is in drug trade from Mona being blabbermouth.
As the girls in The Pink Rose are out of weed, Lily's looking to buy some for all the girls.
Guessing Quinn is not selling them overpriced, she asks to buy. It's that simple. What's the actual base for that theory? (I know it's not necessary here, you can say anything you believe in your dreamland and pretend it's real here, that's the norm but eh)
If you are delusional enough to seriously believe Lily is actually an undercover cop, Magnar's girl and KRJ is an undercover cop too. Hell, KRJ is actually a fed. She even has an ear device for communicating with DEA feds!!!1!11!!
Lily undercover cop is unlikely, but she is spying for someone, that much you can see.

My guess is that she is spying for Sage and Rusty on the respective VP's, Tommy and Quinn. I think that Rusty and Sage sense that the VP's are not quite running smoothly.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: shazba

akki37

Member
Jan 21, 2020
105
109
I don't know if this is discussed here but i have theory about heather. If MC told her about tommy, then she will ask to have sex with MC. Then this choice will determine MC's positive or negative relationship with tommy.
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
Someone going to die. I predict Tommy. Hello Vice President MC.
I don't think Tommy will die. But I assume that one or more DIK's will go. :unsure:

I can't give any exact clues. It's more of a feeling. Tommy and Rusty have become more and more distant from the other DIK's towards the end of EP7. :rolleyes:

I'm assuming that the MC will be the new president and he will have to pick a new VP.:D

Wishful thinking. My MC will split the power of the DIK VP between Josy and Maya. That would be something.:cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: HogRocket
Sep 9, 2021
433
626
I haven't commented at all about all the discussions about characters' being related (or not) in BaDIK, so rather than reply to any individual post, I thought I'd leave a standalone post. I may be misunderstanding some of the complaints, but I've been seeing some posts that seem to say that having all these relatives on campus is unrealistic.

I think if we have melodramatic "discoveries" that MC is related to Jill or Josy or some other variation of "long lost relative," it would be a cheap plot trick and quite disappointing. I mean, I love reading dalli_x's wild theorizing as much as the next guy, but I'd be pretty dismayed if pretty much any of his theories turns out to be true.

On the other hand, having a lot of family members at the same college in and of itself is totally normal and even expected, given that B&R is supposed to be a US school that is "the poor man's college," to quote Steve from the convenience store. I went to a pretty small public university in the US because it was affordable and close to home, as did my brother, and most of my friends who had siblings were all there with their siblings. Most of the staff and faculty who had college-age kids had their kids at that school. So there's nothing out of the ordinary in that at all.

If anything about B&R is unrealistic, it's why a bunch of rich kids would be there at all (generally Ivy League and other elite schools are happy to accept even lousy students if they are willing and able to pay full tuition) and why there aren't any older than average students there. I am NOT saying I want to start seeing MILFs and DILFs among the student body, but the reality is that schools like B&R in the US are regularly where older people go if they didn't get a degree when they were younger. Now that I write this, maybe that's why DPC introduced Madame. She's going to pop up in one of MC's classes next semester. ;)
you said :
I think if we have melodramatic "discoveries" that MC is related to Jill or Josy or some other variation of "long lost relative," it would be a cheap plot trick and quite disappointing.
me :
-------- I don't think it's a cheap or disappointing but it will be a plot that will kill the plot, interest, character development. These kinds of plot are usually call spider web because they kill characters.
You :
On the other hand, having a lot of family members at the same college in and of itself is totally normal - - -
Me :
no it's not, family member in collage life, does fuck up collage life.

On serious note : mc don't have any family member on collage in my knowledge and it should stay this way.
 

D2M3

Member
Jan 20, 2018
345
909
I hope DPC scales down after launching Ep8 and Season 2 on Steam with Ep9 and does a few more shorter episodes with less dev time.

He can't keep scaling up and up and up for every episode, it's unsustainable as it is, time wise. There's a reason art and game studios hire more people as their games tend to get bigger, and since he is unwilling to do any of that, he needs to keep scale consistent.
 

shazba

Engaged Member
Aug 4, 2020
3,506
19,701
I hope DPC scales down after launching Ep8 and Season 2 on Steam with Ep9 and does a few more shorter episodes with less dev time.

He can't keep scaling up and up and up for every episode, it's unsustainable as it is, time wise. There's a reason art and game studios hire more people as their games tend to get bigger, and since he is unwilling to do any of that, he needs to keep scale consistent.
People keep saying that, but he has absolutely no incentive to do it. Anyway, we'll wait. We'll complain, but we'll wait (this game's already been going for almost three years anyway, what's another bunch of years gonna hurt?)
 

seniorboop

Active Member
Jun 5, 2021
675
1,964
I don't know if this is discussed here but i have theory about heather. If MC told her about tommy, then she will ask to have sex with MC. Then this choice will determine MC's positive or negative relationship with tommy.
I mean we're definitely fucking Heather. Episode 7 was pretty much the greenlight... But I honestly dont think Tommy cares about Heather in general and wouldnt see it as a big deal.

People keep saying that, but he has absolutely no incentive to do it. Anyway, we'll wait. We'll complain, but we'll wait (this game's already been going for almost three years anyway, what's another bunch of years gonna hurt?)
Exactly. If anything the Patreon funding model means he should drag out this cash cow for as long as reasonably possible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dalli_x

godkingxerxes

Engaged Member
Sep 27, 2020
2,148
5,940
It is very simple. The LI's and Girl's who did not fuck the MC can be relatives. Incest rule. (y)

Just an example, nothing more.

Now look at Isabella. As long as the MC doesn't hire Isabella to clean his room and has no other sexual interactions, it will hardly bother the player if she is his aunt, mother, cousin or child. (I exaggerated on purpose). But it would be a bit of a surprise if such a thing came out. :unsure:

Imagine such a situation with the girls and LI's you don't care about and ask yourself if it bothers you.:unsure:

The only real drama comes when the MC is a male whore and there is only one girl left as a sister. Derek will take care of her then. Linda is a wet dream of Derek. With that my tears.:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
So you're saying Bella can be an aunt if no sex but isn't an aunt if sex?

Do you understand the complexity of this? It's impossible for Pinkcakes to maintain that level of change in his story.

Theories are one thing, but what you're saying is is more like you're watching a TV show and halfway through an episode it be becomes another TV show.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tipsytopsy

HogRocket

Engaged Member
Jun 8, 2020
2,398
12,212
I don't think Tommy will die. But I assume that one or more DIK's will go. :unsure:

I can't give any exact clues. It's more of a feeling. Tommy and Rusty have become more and more distant from the other DIK's towards the end of EP7. :rolleyes:

I'm assuming that the MC will be the new president and he will have to pick a new VP.:D

Wishful thinking. My MC will split the power of the DIK VP between Josy and Maya. That would be something.:cool:
Tommy is also becoming more and more uncontrollable and irrational. I agree, I don't see him dying, but I see something major happening to him.
Rusty has all but made the MC the VP already and the other guys look to him as a leader (hey, it's me - of course he's the best :cool::LOL:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: dalli_x
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes