- Sep 20, 2018
- 3,505
- 14,417
Tybalt may hate the MC (though I'd say that's probably only true if the MC deliberately antagonized him), but he's not the one calling the shots here. This is about asking Tybalt's parents to help Maya (and Josy, if Sage mentioned their relationship). It's not even clear if Tybalt will even learn about this meeting, since he doesn't live here and I doubt Sage invited him.Jill defends MC until the very end, Tybalt takes advantage of this and blackmails her, at the end Jill explodes and humiliates Tybalt publicly
Tybalt probably can't take direct revenge on Jill, but he can on MC and has no reason not to, Jill no longer has any hold on him
I don't think that Burke is so much influenced by his son, but for sure in that house Tybalt is the one who hates MC the most, and he hates him in every situation
Even if Tybalt hates the MC with a burning passion, that just means their son has a grudge with one of Maya's friends. Given that their daughter will also defend the guy, I don't think even Tybalt's bitterest antipathy will really matter all that much - at least for the task at hand. Tybalt may well seek revenge in other ways, but he would have done that regardless of asking Maya for help.
(This, BTW, is why I still say the MC's fuck-storm at the end of Episode 8 is unwarranted if you never fooled around with Jade. Tybalt as blood enemy barely rates a single fuck, much less six.)
Jade's problem isn't losing the MC per se, it's that she's once again being sidelined by "another woman." Jade started this affair to feel sexy after her husband all but dismissed her, and now even her boytoy is doing the same!A women with power... and immature, in that case. What was she expecting from a relationship with a 19 years old student that agrees to fuck a married teacher? So magic is MC´s cock that she can´t live now without him? Or is she in love with the MC? That relationship is only a matter of lust for both of them, and she should know that.
Yes, a woman with power can be immature too, so she could react that way. But when Jade sees the MC troubled because his problems with Maya and Josy, she cares about him, opens to him and makes him confidences about his marriage, bond with him... She´s not pictured in the story like just a whimsical cougar.
It's in no way a logical response, but the affair was never about logic to begin with.
I agree the game should never have let Maya & Josy reject the MC if he was going to remain friends with them. Sadly, that ship has long since sailed.Staying friends with M/J after the Relationship or Just Friends choice makes sense, but after the Rejected choice? Don't you think that would be kinda awkward? Or that the MC would just want to forget about those two and move on with his life? I feel like it's the single biggest flaw in the story, it's just not something that I find to be believable.
Even on the Just Friends path DPC has structured it awkwardly. The only way that any of your "friends" will come to help after the mansion is trashed is if they are sleeping with you. That just makes the MC look like a simp to two spoiled girls, and on the rejected path it looks even worse. It just seems to me to be a really odd way of portraying a friendship.
And yes I remember the argument that doing anything else would require DPC to create more paths, and that would be almost impossible, but there are countless games on this forum that can do just that. It makes DPC's claim that choices matter in this game seem a bit hollow.
I do wonder why M&J don't offer to help the MC clean on all the paths. The scene is already free of sex, so it would have been easy to adapt to the friendship route (just make the dialog a bit more intimate on the M/J path), and as you say, it would show the girls see him as a friend, too. (Obviously you'd still decline their offer if Bella will help instead.)
It's not a major problem, but it does feel like a missed opportunity.
I'm pretty sure we will eventually get solo paths for them, it's just going to take a while because their relationship has to fall apart first. My guess is that Season 3 is when the MC's chosen relationship will either fail or at least be severely tested and only survive based on our actions. DPC probably plans to handle the M/J couple relationship at the same time. That way a newly single MC will have the opportunity to choose Maya or Josy solo when they pick up the pieces (likely in Season 4). I'm not sure if that would work if you're already in a relationship with both, though.Except for their sex scenes I've seen very little removal of M/J, the only scene I can think of is the lunch in ep6.
Also, the trouble is that we can't just swallow it and move on. That scene in ep4 still looms over the rest of the game, I would hope that if he had the chance to rewrite that DPC would do a better job.
Also, I wonder why he included that choice with Derek in ep5. At this point I don't think the MC will ever get a chance to have a solo relationship with Maya or Josy, unless it's from within their relationship.
Last edited: