Suicide Going out getting drunk and driving recklessness I Dunno if you've ever been through a bad break up but I don't think I drove under 80 miles an hour for a month. Depressions a bitch even if you wouldn't kill yourself doesn't mean you wouldn't put yourself in harms way on purpose.but I don't understand exactly how Lana would have died in a way related to this theoretical relationship
a suicide? if it was because of the moral condemnation of her family then Jill could hardly have "forgiven" her family, if instead it was because of the way Bella kept or ended this relationship, in the same way Jill could hardly have ever become best friends with the woman who led her sister to unhappiness and then to death
we are constantly reading Bella's thoughts, and for someone who is responsible for the death of a girl (and her best friend's sister), it seems to me that the only guilt she feels is towards her husband.
apart from the fact that they might have known each other I see very little to support this theory.
Maya + Josy
Chad + Troy
Lana + Bella
when you don't know who the other one is and why no one talks about it, it's always a homosexual relationship
Also, I think your forgetting Jills an angel Just because you couldn't forgive something doesn't mean she can't and as I said. Even if this isn't the case her sister is Most likely dead, but she doesn't seem to have bad blood with her parents who are at fault for this NO MATTER what did happen to her sister because her parents kicked her out and made her fend for herself which she obviously did poorly.
And what does support it IS A The fact that Bella indeed did flirt with a student before which is why Jill gets upset by her asking if it's happening AGAIN and all. B Bella is a family friend so likeliness of a runaway daughter running to her is likely.
What doesn't support it I'll admit is the most cryptic line Bella has ever said in the game to this day.
Bella "I've become what I hate." "I'm an adulteress."
This to me seem's like maybe she was cheated on or her parents maybe had issues with it. The fact I'd like to focus on is.
Jill gets upset no matter what when you and Bella are together MC could ignore Jill from start of game to finish and she still gets upset when she see's MC with Bella meaning she's upset with Bella not MC.
Jill see's MC and Bella Flirting and askes if it's happening AGAIN meaning it's happened before. With whom is of little issue but it could be why James is not in the picture right now and for three years prior.
I'll also admit Jill looked to be about 12 in her flashback which would leave about 2 years unaccounted for between James leaving Bella. She would a had to be around 14 or 15 when that scene took place for this. Or Lana's relationship would have to last a pretty long time before whatever happened happened.
Either way it's just a theory.
Last edited: