Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,152
35,760
1,054
The talk earlier about the Sage/Cammy threesome got me thinking a little bit. Sage is the only Main Girl to have had a threesome—two, in fact. Maya and Josy obviously have too, but that's built-in to their path so it doesn't really count.

Anyway, I was wondering, who are some Side Girls who could realistically have a threesome with a Main Girl and MC? "Realistically" being relative obviously, but Sage's threesomes were handled pretty well, weren't out of character.

Bella is probably restricted to the milf teachers, primarily Cathy. They're friends, and there's no underlying dislike between them, like with Jade towards Bella. She doesn't know Nora, but I think they'd get along pretty well. Very well... :sneaky:
Actually, I almost forgot about Bianca. After the little getaway, they're all closer now. It wouldn't be impossible.

Sage could probably rope in any of the HOTs, except Ashley, Elena and maybe Heather. She could also get Jade :BootyTime: Kidding, but I fucking wish...
Perhaps she could be convinced to bury the hatchet and share with Zoey :HideThePain:

Solo Maya might be interested in Melanie, after learning she was also in a throuple. According to the talk on Halloween, she seems to like Cammy, Ashley, and Elena as well. Then there’s always Quinn... nice little hatefuck, hehe ;) Doubt it though.

Jill doesn't really associate with any Side Girls other than Bianca, an obvious candidate, and Cathy, who is hungry for some college dick. Maybe Sally, after playing DnG with her? Sally doesn't seem like the threesome type though.

Josy admitted she finds Lily hot, and Lily certainly finds her hot too. She's pretty friendly with Heather, but that might be a no-go because of Tommy. Actually, maybe Heather would join in as another way to get his attention lmao. Josy might be okay with most of the HOTs tbh.
There's always Becky... nah :ROFLMAO:

Thoughts?
 

Phoenix Lord

Newbie
Feb 18, 2018
28
29
79
The talk earlier about the Sage/Cammy threesome got me thinking a little bit. Sage is the only Main Girl to have had a threesome—two, in fact. Maya and Josy obviously have too, but that's built-in to their path so it doesn't really count.

Anyway, I was wondering, who are some Side Girls who could realistically have a threesome with a Main Girl and MC? "Realistically" being relative obviously, but Sage's threesomes were handled pretty well, weren't out of character.

Bella is probably restricted to the milf teachers, primarily Cathy. They're friends, and there's no underlying dislike between them, like with Jade towards Bella. She doesn't know Nora, but I think they'd get along pretty well. Very well... :sneaky:
Actually, I almost forgot about Bianca. After the little getaway, they're all closer now. It wouldn't be impossible.

Sage could probably rope in any of the HOTs, except Ashley, Elena and maybe Heather. She could also get Jade :BootyTime: Kidding, but I fucking wish...
Perhaps she could be convinced to bury the hatchet and share with Zoey :HideThePain:

Solo Maya might be interested in Melanie, after learning she was also in a throuple. According to the talk on Halloween, she seems to like Cammy, Ashley, and Elena as well. Then there’s always Quinn... nice little hatefuck, hehe ;) Doubt it though.

Jill doesn't really associate with any Side Girls other than Bianca, an obvious candidate, and Cathy, who is hungry for some college dick. Maybe Sally, after playing DnG with her? Sally doesn't seem like the threesome type though.

Josy admitted she finds Lily hot, and Lily certainly finds her hot too. She's pretty friendly with Heather, but that might be a no-go because of Tommy. Actually, maybe Heather would join in as another way to get his attention lmao. Josy might be okay with most of the HOTs tbh.
There's always Becky... nah :ROFLMAO:

Thoughts?
I think Jill will have threesomes with the other main girls (Sage and Bella to be more precise).
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,152
35,760
1,054
I think Jill will have threesomes with the other main girls (Sage and Bella to be more precise).
With all the setup in place, that goes without saying. Same with Maya and Josy both being into Sage, Sage liking Maya a lot, Sage making out with Josy. But Side Girls are a different story, they're more varied and aren't as close to the Main Girls, well not all of them anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaiserST

maxthruster

Member
Oct 4, 2025
440
1,094
143
Sage could probably rope in any of the HOTs, except Ashley, Elena and maybe Heather. She could also get Jade :BootyTime: Kidding, but I fucking wish...
Perhaps she could be convinced to bury the hatchet and share with Zoey :HideThePain:
Hear me out, competitive threesome with Zoey. Tremolo keeps being nice to his ex while insisting that it's nothing, Sage is sure they're either fucking or ready to fuck but she can't prove it, finally she just throws up her hands and decides to prove she is the better choice by force. Ultimate act of staking her claim to the intruder.

Also, it'd be hot as fuck.
 

Phoenix Lord

Newbie
Feb 18, 2018
28
29
79
With all the setup in place, that goes without saying. Same with Maya and Josy both being into Sage, Sage liking Maya a lot, Sage making out with Josy. But Side Girls are a different story, they're more varied and aren't as close to the Main Girls, well not all of them anyway.
In Jill's specific case, it seems she needs to be close to the person to want to have sex, and as you said, she's only close to Bianca, but I think Bianca is a trap.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,152
35,760
1,054
Hear me out, competitive threesome with Zoey. Tremolo keeps being nice to his ex while insisting that it's nothing, Sage is sure they're either fucking or ready to fuck but she can't prove it, finally she just throws up her hands and decides to prove she is the better choice by force. Ultimate act of staking her claim to the intruder.

Also, it'd be hot as fuck.
They could give Sarah and Melanie a run for their money :BootyTime:
In Jill's specific case, it seems she needs to be close to the person to want to have sex, and as you said, she's only close to Bianca, but I think Bianca is a trap.
Bianca is most likely a trap if you cheat on Jill with her, but this about a threesome that the girls could realistically agree to. Jill is slowly coming more out of her turtle shell, they've kissed before, and Bianca told her about how common threesomes are in college. Not an impossibility.
 

maxthruster

Member
Oct 4, 2025
440
1,094
143
In Jill's specific case, it seems she needs to be close to the person to want to have sex, and as you said, she's only close to Bianca, but I think Bianca is a trap.
This is why I don't think a threesome with Jill is likely at all. She really needs the romance and the intimacy, and while threesomes don't inherently lack those traits this game does not really treat them in such a way. Like, JM yeah, they have to be because it's a throuple, but that relationship is also a paper bridge in a rainstorm and collapsing in on itself fast.

No other threesomes in the game are treated as truly romantic and loving acts from all sides. The closest we got to that is arguably the fucking John Boy scene. The game largely treats them as "haha woah cool sex thing, two chicks" because that's the frat bro stereotype, and this game is built on stereotypes. I don't see Jill managing to break that stereotype unless it's something extremely specific.

As mentioned, the only person she's truly close enough to consider this with, without it being some route-ending bait with Bianca, is Bella. However, I think it would have to end up being a very tight window to walk to make sense: Bella obviously has to have approved of Tremolo in the first place, but they can't have fooled around at all. Otherwise, lingering feelings of guilt and desire will make her refuse for fear of ruining Jill's happiness.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,152
35,760
1,054
As mentioned, the only person she's truly close enough to consider this with, without it being some route-ending bait with Bianca, is Bella. However, I think it would have to end up being a very tight window to walk to make sense: Bella obviously has to have approved of Tremolo in the first place, but they can't have fooled around at all. Otherwise, lingering feelings of guilt and desire will make her refuse for fear of ruining Jill's happiness.
But fooling around in the past is what these moments are built on, lingering feelings.
ep11_main2_party_end106.jpg ep11_main2_party_end92.jpg
That intimacy Jill needs will be missing on Bella's path if they never made it all the way to the Bianca dinner, and Bella has no real interest in MC if she's been ignored on Jill's path, or doesn't harbor anymore feelings without the Episode 7 lewd.
 

Roger-a-Dale

Well-Known Member
May 9, 2024
1,969
2,869
332
The talk earlier about the Sage/Cammy threesome got me thinking a little bit. Sage is the only Main Girl to have had a threesome—two, in fact. Maya and Josy obviously have too, but that's built-in to their path so it doesn't really count.

Anyway, I was wondering, who are some Side Girls who could realistically have a threesome with a Main Girl and MC? "Realistically" being relative obviously, but Sage's threesomes were handled pretty well, weren't out of character.

Thoughts?
Damn it, Spock! You know I can't resist this kind of stuff.
Bella is probably restricted to the milf teachers, primarily Cathy. They're friends, and there's no underlying dislike between them, like with Jade towards Bella. She doesn't know Nora, but I think they'd get along pretty well. Very well... :sneaky:
Actually, I almost forgot about Bianca. After the little getaway, they're all closer now. It wouldn't be impossible.
Cathy would be likeliest if it wasn't for the whole panties found in the car thing. You have to reject Cathy to have Bella. If you can get around that I could totally see it happen. And it would be fucking hot.

I have mentioned that I anticipate a fight between Jade and Bella on Bella's path. Bella is keeping her relationship with MC secret, Jade notices that secretive behaviour, jumps to the wrong conclusion that Bella is having an affair with Stephen and so cougar fight. But after the misunderstanding is cleared... make-up-threesome. Think of how Sage and Jill bonded over their hatred of Tybalt. This is the previous generation version.

Bianca I could see as a foursome with Jill. That cabin. So many trips. So many memories.

And of course there's Miranda and Viv. If Lynette didn't want her cougar friends to have a foursome with her son, she shouldn't have given birth to a stud.
Sage could probably rope in any of the HOTs, except Ashley, Elena and maybe Heather. She could also get Jade :BootyTime: Kidding, but I fucking wish...
Perhaps she could be convinced to bury the hatchet and share with Zoey :HideThePain:
Heather/Sage threesome is one of the few ways I could see a Heather scene happen. It's not entirely without consequence, but having Sage tell Tommy not to be cock-blocking clam-jamming little bitch-cunt is bound to carry some weight.

Sage/Riona comfort threesome would be a vibe.

Sage and Zoey probably will have a confrontation even if MC chooses Sage, but if Chick-Zoey were to meekly admit defeat Sage can be a good sport about it aaaaand... make-up-threesome.

Sage making the entire sisterhood bend over for MC because she is Mama HOT around here would be fucking... hot.

Pink Pharmaceuticals Super-Viagra: "You'll fill all the holes. Even the ones in plot."
Solo Maya might be interested in Melanie, after learning she was also in a throuple. According to the talk on Halloween, she seems to like Cammy, Ashley, and Elena as well. Then there’s always Quinn... nice little hatefuck, hehe ;) Doubt it though.
Quinn. Make-up-threesome. It just works, okay.

Riona/Maya comfort/forgiveness threesome would also be a vibe. Josy making it a foursome would be good too. Or leave MC out of it and make it a lesbian threesome... Damn! Where do these nosebleeds come from?
Jill doesn't really associate with any Side Girls other than Bianca, an obvious candidate, and Cathy, who is hungry for some college dick. Maybe Sally, after playing DnG with her? Sally doesn't seem like the threesome type though.
A Jill threesome would have to be with a more experienced girl. Or at least with a genuinely confident one. Sally's defence mechanism would just make her say something shitty and ruin the moment. If Jill got more experienced and confident, she could lead Sally, but I don't think that would happen on MC's first year. Unless they were drunk of course.

A Jill/Zoey threesome might happen similarly to how a Sage/Zoey threesome might happen.

Jill/Bianca I could see happen. Actually I'm fairly confident it will, but it'll probably be difficult to navigate because if MC is just a cheating douche... game over.

Other Jill/SG I don't really see happen, but Jill might join a foursome.
Josy admitted she finds Lily hot, and Lily certainly finds her hot too. She's pretty friendly with Heather, but that might be a no-go because of Tommy. Actually, maybe Heather would join in as another way to get his attention lmao. Josy might be okay with most of the HOTs tbh.
There's always Becky... nah :ROFLMAO:
Others path. Josy and Maya do every girl MC has done after he goes back to Zoey. Imagine it.
 

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,152
35,760
1,054
Cathy would be likeliest if it wasn't for the whole panties found in the car thing. You have to reject Cathy to have Bella. If you can get around that I could totally see it happen. And it would be fucking hot.
As long as we're successful on Swyper, we could get the car blowjob but end things to stay on Bella's path, then Cathy should be up for restarting our little tryst for a threesome.
But after the misunderstanding is cleared... make-up-threesome. Think of how Sage and Jill bonded over their hatred of Tybalt. This is the previous generation version.
Tyballs is the great uniter lmao :KEK:
Bianca I could see as a foursome with Jill. That cabin. So many trips. So many memories.
I can see that happening if they're all pretty drunk, and convince Jill with love and affection. A new level of their relationships.
A Jill/Zoey threesome might happen similarly to how a Sage/Zoey threesome might happen.
Jill doesn't seem as bothered by Zoey as Sage is, or as suspicious. Not to say this couldn't happen, but with all the passion Sage has, anything with Zoey seems more likely to happen with her.
 

Roger-a-Dale

Well-Known Member
May 9, 2024
1,969
2,869
332
As long as we're successful on Swyper, we could get the car blowjob but end things to stay on Bella's path, then Cathy should be up for restarting our little tryst for a threesome.
Can that be done? I thought the blowjob only happened if you agreed to continue with Cathy and because she couldn't keep her panties on Bella found evidence.

I could see Cathy being okay with the rejection after finding out about MC and Bella. Possibly after forcing Jade and Bella apart when they fight...

Okay, mental image: You reject Cathy to stay in Bella's path, but you've charmed her properly on Swyper. You didn't go on a picnic with Jill so you could have the bar scene with Nora. You showed the Jade video to the DIKs. Then Bella and Jade run into each other at the MILF bar and the fight breaks out. Cathy and Nora force them apart, but all four get thrown out. Or Cathy and Nora just decide to leave with them so Bella and Jade don't continue the fight outside. Words are said. Bella calls MC. What happens next?
Tyballs is the great uniter lmao :KEK:
I was thinking more that they'd bond over their hatred of Stephen, but considering Jade only adopted Tybalt because she thought Stephen wanted a son... Everyone really does hate him... Just like he deserves.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: KaiserST

Blue Milk

Active Member
Apr 27, 2021
510
1,024
204
Anyway, I was wondering, who are some Side Girls who could realistically have a threesome with a Main Girl and MC?
None.

Sage is probably done with them even if you did the Cami threesome because I think they'll move into something more serious now after that.

Jill probably isn't doing it with anyone other than Bella because I think it would mean more for her than with Bianca as she seems too casual a thing for Jill's character.

Bella doesn't really have any SG options, imo, and I don't see her doing anything with Bianca because it's bad enough she got with the guy that Jill liked, it would be pouring salt on the wound to then also do something with him and Jill's other friend.

And I don't think we'll see Maya & Josy be with anyone other than each other because if there is going to be any sort of breakup on a specific path, them going from something serious with a girl to then just some random, throwaway threesome with another girl just feels like something they wouldn't want to do.

Also, we're seeing a lot of these SGs move into more serious territory, so even the reverse of being with a SG and whether a MG could join from that relationship angle I don't think seems likely at this point either.

Can that be done? I thought the blowjob only happened if you agreed to continue with Cathy and because she couldn't keep her panties on Bella found evidence.
No, it can't. Because if you got the BJ from Cathy then you've nuked your chances with Bella, and yes, you got the BJ because you said you want to continue with Cathy. It's all because Cathy leaves her panties in Bella's car and you can't stop Bella from finding them. So there's zero chance of a Bella/Cathy threesome.
 
Last edited:

Better Cock Spock

Half Vulcan, Half Simp
Donor
Jul 29, 2017
13,152
35,760
1,054
Can that be done? I thought the blowjob only happened if you agreed to continue with Cathy and because she couldn't keep her panties on Bella found evidence.
No, I was saying that the option to get the blowjob needs to be turned down, but by merely having that option means a threesome with Cathy could happen in the future. That way there's already a foundation, and won't come out of nowhere.
None.

Sage is probably done with them even if you did the Cami threesome because I think they'll move into something more serious now after that.

Jill probably isn't doing it with anyone other than Bella because I think it would mean more for her than with Bianca as she seems too casual a thing for Jill's character.

Bella doesn't really have any SG options, imo, and I don't see her doing anything with Bianca because it's bad enough she got with the guy that Jill liked, it would be pouring salt on the wound to then also do somwthing with him and Jill's other friend.

And I don't think we'll see Maya & Josy be with anyone other than each other because if there is going to be any sort of breakup on a specific path, them going from something serious with a girl to then just some random, throwaway threesome with aanother girl just feels like something they wouldn't want to do.

Also, we're seeing a lot of these SGs move into more serious territory, so even the reverse of being with a SG and whether a MG could join from that relationship angle I don't think seems likely at this point either.
Hmmm, the reverse? Being with a SG and snagging a threesome with a MG? Sage would probably be the only option, except with Lily lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaiserST
4.70 star(s) 1,727 Votes