Well... Josy wasn't a virgin so she was interested in at least one other guy enough to be fucked by him...
Was it Tommy?
Jojo wasnt virgin. Jill said yes to many dates and we saw she can say no if she isnt interested like Rusty.
since Maya stay at that party where the boy ask "do you mind" and give her his stuff to have dance with another girl. my brain say: Maya was there, because she wanted dance with boys. she had and has interest in boys. she think she is lesbian, because her first relationship and deep connection is with Jojo. there is no boy who was as close to her as Jojo. and Jojo is a girl. Maya dont think any boy can be as good as Jojo, only girls.
It's heavily implied in game that Josy has experience, she basically coaches Maya on being with a man, has absolutely no hesitation with Tremolo, given how they treat Jill's first time, more would've been made of it if it was her first time
But you're right in the sense that it isn't black and white so it's up to the player's interpretation
Josy's experience seems quite overrated to me, sure she knows more about heterosexual sex than Maya, but even Jill knows more than Maya, at least she knows that penetration can take place naturally without the need for lubricants.
and if Josy has actually had experiences she must have missed something if she thinks it's a problem for a man to consider it an oddity that the woman orgasms before him....
but i wasn't talking about that anyway, i was talking that there's nothing to tell us that Maya, but also Josy and Jill, have ever had any real interest in another guy outside of MC. the date with Rusty seems to me to be hard to argue that it stems from Jill's interest (in fact from the flashback it seems quite the opposite). there's no reference to a past history, to a primary school sweetheart... nothing
so the fact that we don't know about it for Maya seems to me to be really insignificant, if DPC doesn't talk about it when it would be realistic for it to have happened why should he do so for Maya?
that this is really not credible is another issue.