Why add Zoey to the game and not make her a romantic interest? This is the dumbest decision you could make.
1) Introduced way too late.
2) Nothing wrong with making her a side girl.
3) She destroys the entire point of the game
up to that point.
4) Too much focus for 0 content.
5) Not playing the role of the Old Flame properly, and instead is
just there. Makes the MC cry on first meeting.
So, Zoey is a criminal because she wants the protagonist for herself. She has self-respect, and she doesn't want to be a second or third girl. How dare she? I'm forced to repeat what has been said in this thread about 1,000 times, but you still don't understand. This game will never be a harem.
She's a horrible function within the story. Her character is fine.
How dare she literally break up a relationship. I guess you'd think differently if MC was married, or engaged? It's the same concept. She breaks up relationships because she wants one. How is that self-respectful? "Hey old friend and lover I took completely for granted in the past!"
Due to the nature of Crossroads and the content from the previous chapters, she has no regard for your past with other girls. Only her own.
I don't really care if this game does or doesn't become a harem.
The only thing I agree with you on is that the paths where the MC leaves LI and returns to Zoey are bad paths. But I don't think DPC made a mistake when they decided to create them. The game needs to have "bad" paths. Do you want all the endings to be good, where the MC is a friend to everyone, and the only difference is which girl they choose? That's up to you, but I don't want a game where I'm guaranteed to win regardless of the decisions I make.
He did. There are ways to bring back the Old Flame trope. Make her a seductress. Make her nefarious, or the opposite. Make it a mutual experience. Or a rekindling with a fizzle; that would give Zoey something to do which is core to her. For one, have them go on some kind of a redemption arc. Instead, she just sits around being friendly, because we need to shoe horn her in here. She's not even a student. Then there's having a panic attack. If Zoey is so mature and a complete character as she appears in the Interlude, she'd be understanding of MC and his happiness. Instead, she asks him to ruin his own and another, all for her selfish desires. "Oh, I made a mistake!" Yes, you did, and this crap don't fly in a story about a slice of life college experience. She just
shows up and demands a take back. It's like 99% of the experience goes down the tubes. Childish.
Now about the "other" path:
1) Zoey returns in episode 9. At this point, the MC has not yet established strong connections with the SGs.
Are we playing some other game here?
Is not DPC lauded as some great storyteller?
While it's true you don't have to do many things for many of the MGs (helping Bella paint her fence, practicing Jill's music so you can save her at her recital, etc.), this is the equivalent of not playing the game. The assumption being you said
no to everything optional.
For a story about relationships and romance, it's quite odd to not...choose romantic experiences. It's like you have to be "playing video games wrong" or something.
If, after episode 9, where Zoey receives significant development, the player decides that Zoey is now their top priority and they do not want to engage in drama, they may choose not to continue with the paths of Lily, Riona, Nicole, and others. This prevents the drama of broken relationships, as there are no existing relationships in the "others" path at the beginning of episode 10.
You mean on the Others path? No kidding. See: breaking up the MGs.
Quite sure there's plenty of drama on Others path before Zoey, so yes, Zoey is destroying whatever SG girl the MC is with (Nicole, Lily, Quinn, Riona, Jade, etc.)
2) If the player continued the SG's path and returned to Zoey, he would get drama, but honestly, I don't think he did anything wrong. Lily, Quinn, Riona, and others had enough time to tell the MC that they wanted a real relationship. They didn't, but Zoey did. They can only blame themselves.
"It's not Zoey's fault. It's everyone else's!"
That's a strange question. All the canonical lines will go their own way, the degree of involvement of the player in them will depend on the route he is on, as it always has been. Example: You can't participate fully in the drug storyline if you're on Jill's route. But the plot continues anyway.
Quite a bit of difference between canon plots with MGs, and optional romanced girls stories, so I don't see your point.
It's funny that you constantly criticize Zoey for destroying relationships, but I've never seen you criticize Josy or Bianca for doing the same (even though they're also backstabbing their friends).
Methinks you should read about my
Searing Hatred of Josy.
Josy blows up her own relationship because wah. Zoey blows up everyone's.
But please, try to attack my character more. I hear that's an effective argument method.
This is your best argument. Why couldn't DPC just make a game with 5 LIs and 6 endings that's 10 episodes long? I'm sure everyone would have enjoyed it.
I apologize in advance if the translator has translated something incorrectly. Unfortunately, I am too lazy to learn english.
No, you're just a Zoey fanboy. You know she's forced into the story for melodrama. A whole Interlude for 2 variables. Pure
$$$$$ grab. She's a horrible person for what she did, and wants, and )for whatever reason) you can choose to make her a DIK, even worse. It's not just what she does, it's a) how (too late, too uncaring), b) when (worse with DIK), c) and in what capacity (playing catch up, not being fully aware of her feelings, not thinking of MCs feelings), d) destroying everything (the Crossroads choice. d is more of a DPC issue, since he has no clue WTF he's doing, and just playing it by feeling.)
If she was only an option on the Others path, that would be different.
The funny thing: DPC's probably going to allow you to break up with Zoey for some other Other girl. Some
new girl he'll make as an option. It's more melodramatic nonsense. Whereas Crossroads forced you down a path, Zoey just resets all that. Because of hamfisted melodrama...but with a bomb.