Josy with MC is completely honest
She was honest but not completly honest.
She did say she was in a relationship but didn't further volunteer that it was with a girl.
Josy was not required to tell MC that she had a girlfriend, if she hadn't been Maya taht wouldn't have changed anything
she always told him that she was engaged, MC is an affair, and MC knows it, in fact towards Josy he only says nonsense, he is afraid, there is little to do
Relationship not engaged.
She tells the MC on the first date that she has had a crush on him.
She also calls back the MC and says "It's goodbye (let's see each other again) not Farewell (end of path)"
She then calls him on the first nght at college and arranges a second date
At the second date when asked about if she heard from B&R she says "I'd be outside your dorm jumping for joy if it happened" and then she goes onto say "You're (MC) not here because she's just lonely"
She then asks if you want to stay the night - A yes means you will be having sexy times.
When she does get in it's the MC she phones to tell him and to arrange a meet-up once she arrives.
engaged was my translation error
let's say she had an official relationship.
the episodes you list are all prior to when he meets Maya again
Josy has no reason to be upset with MC and not knowing how Maya will react he is the only friendly person who is sure to find in BR
the story with MC is clearly over as soon as she arrives in Maya's room, they write to each other, they talk about each other but nobody talks about their relationship. it's over. when Josy talks about "we" she refers to the three of them, not to them 2
once they are all 3 in BR there is no moment when it is credible that MC has a chance to continue his story with one of the two girls.
Through a long series of improbable events (Out of a hundred new students Maya is one of the few with a spare bed for MC to stay in and it requires one of your few male friends to be her brother and talk her into accepting you thus creating the potential for complications when of the few students with a spare bed it is randomly assigned to the only one out of a bunch of rejects she has a history with) you run into an insoluble problem. Josy is going to dump her bags at her new dorm at some point and there she will run into Maya and faced with a long period of living together - having 'the chat' is going to be tough.
Even after the fall-out Josy is the one who reaches out to MC first and it's her you have the talk to pre-library decision.
Also, and here is where we stray away from forced dialogue into optional content, If you go the friends/Dad/luggage route she plainly tells you that you are at least as important to her.
That route also offers you time alone with Maya so the pursuit through 'divide and conquer' is clearly there.
here I agree with you, but we are talking about things that maybe will happen.
instead of MC finding himself out of both relationships it has already happened. at most the two girls, who are a couple, accept him, but is not an "equilateral triangle"
then it is all explained for reasons of simplicity of plot eh, but this is
why otherwise after the clarification "we are all cheaters" are the two girls officially a couple while MC has to beg for a friendship that does not exist?
Think you might be skipping over the lines
my "I really don't deserve another chance..."
my "...but I still want one."
js "I want another chance, too."
Although they don't clarify if this is friendship or more - The MC isn't begging and he/you makes the decision (whether they accept is based on past choices)
on the hypothesis that it might be easier to reconquer Josy of Maya I agree, but it's a different matter
Maya was still developing as you;d only known her days.
Josy............you had her won over and if you and Maya hadn't been sharing a dorm then she'd be your girl.
Maya was still developing
It seems clear to me that Maya is already talking about friendship, otherwise how could it be that after MC forgives them they can refuse him?
we do not choose to be friends, we are forced if we can not have anything else
to be the conclusion of a meeting that the girls had asked to apologize / explain, it seems to me an excellent result
I have the impression that if we directly propose to be friends with Maya we will not have much chance, perhaps the refusal is a better scenario
thanx for the explanation
