Limiting content, just because you choose to kick an character in a fast way, is always a bad move, it's like you want to punish players that don't like a character and want him gone as fast as posible. Many people that play this game and the original, didn't like Eric and wanted him gone as fast as posible. Now if you do that here, you get punished by limiting, future content, and that's not a good thing. Basically you are saying at those players that want him gone, fuck you, if you want to see all the future good content you need to play the game the way I the dev want. Because ther's no good points in kicking Eric fast, other than him not being there, if you will lose future content.
Also just because Max is able to find the turuth about Eric and kick him by himself, it won't make the girls fall for him, nor it will make them want to fuck him, he need to work with them for that to happen, and that would happen no matter if you kick Eric fast or slowly. The only thing that could make him different is if he kick him alone in the extended and in the fast he needs help, that way, the extended would make him reliable and the fast not much, but that won't traduce in the family member wanting to fuck him the moment he kick Eric out, atleast it shouldn't.