YouShallNotLol

Engaged Member
May 6, 2022
3,355
9,613
628
Perhaps I will be a single one, who don't recommend playing fan content. You may risk mixing information from different games.
I believe it will happen... more than one time.

Though, people who played Black Souls recommend playing New Project and N. P. C. Dreams (I don't have a link, sorry, and the game has bad translation as far as I know).
Takamakuran Mentioned. All their games are gems.
I recommend playing all of them in chronological order as follows:
MY]R -> A New Game -> Mercenary's Adventure
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Mr. Cofman

YouShallNotLol

Engaged Member
May 6, 2022
3,355
9,613
628
Do you need to play the First one to play this one?
Overarching lore/plot and several characters that appear in both games.
Like, BS2 is almost a direct sequel of BS1. It's like watching Star Wars Return Of The Jedi, skipping the other two films in the Trilogy.
 

Mr. Cofman

Active Member
Apr 16, 2024
592
895
170
Takamakuran Mentioned. All their games are gems.
I recommend playing all of them in chronological order as follows:
MY]R -> A New Game -> Mercenary's Adventure
Though they were made by the same developer, they are not connected to each other, right?
 

WalkInDaDust

Newbie
Sep 24, 2021
72
22
90
I know this question has been asked several times but is there any save with full npc in prison (including dlc 3) ?
 

maxdrell

Member
Jun 7, 2017
349
265
247
Do you need to play the First one to play this one?
Up to you really, compares to how deep down the rabbit hole you are aiming for. You can get a vast majority of the game by itself, but you will not notice the return cameo's and you won't get the history behind Red Hood (who is actually from an earlier game than BS1, the longest running character of the game creator and is the closest thing to the main heroine of BS2) and a certain faction in the game who played a much larger role in BS1 and may seemingly come out of left field without that context in the endings. Finally, the main villain from BS1 will be massively spoiled if you play this one first.
 
Last edited:

YouShallNotLol

Engaged Member
May 6, 2022
3,355
9,613
628
Though they were made by the same developer, they are not connected to each other, right?
Sorry for the late reply. While not being direct sequels like BS1 and BS2, Takamakuran games are definitely connected. And the connection is definitely deeper than just happening in the same universe.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Mr. Cofman

Sigurfried

New Member
Feb 2, 2024
10
8
13
So, what does getting one of Alice's Spore Forest CG lock you out of?

A guide to unlock all endings since playthrough 1 said to not talk to her when she's there.
 

Beyo

Active Member
Sep 6, 2017
988
917
237
So, what does getting one of Alice's Spore Forest CG lock you out of?

A guide to unlock all endings since playthrough 1 said to not talk to her when she's there.
It's not recommended if you're pathing toward certain events, because it counts toward a hidden mechanic referred to as "progression." It goes up by one anytime you beat bosses, enter certain areas, or do certain things. You can keep track of how much you progressed by looking at the torches in the library. You don't have to worry about this so much. This game encourages multiple playthroughs.
 

kingpatrick

Member
May 9, 2019
147
133
207
So, what does getting one of Alice's Spore Forest CG lock you out of?

A guide to unlock all endings since playthrough 1 said to not talk to her when she's there.
its because talking to her creates a single fog, and there things you have to do before 5 and 10. The walkthrough is careful the steps you take to get most of the NPCs routes while keeping them alive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sigurfried

Sigurfried

New Member
Feb 2, 2024
10
8
13
It's not recommended if you're pathing toward certain events, because it counts toward a hidden mechanic referred to as "progression." It goes up by one anytime you beat bosses, enter certain areas, or do certain things. You can keep track of how much you progressed by looking at the torches in the library. You don't have to worry about this so much. This game encourages multiple playthroughs.
So basically, it counts towards progression, and may lock you out of a LOT (like people getting killed and going mad) :LOL:

Got it, thanks to you both!
 

GlassFront

Newbie
Sep 9, 2018
47
93
118
So basically, it counts towards progression, and may lock you out of a LOT (like people getting killed and going mad) :LOL:

Got it, thanks to you both!
It'll only lock you out of 1 thing guaranteed, and that's the first cutscene you get with Holmes and the werewolf at the start, after beating the headhunting beast. That cutscene is also more important then you think, but for spoiler reasons, and it's not important until you're on your final, "real" cycle.

In all honesty, I'm not a fan of that guide. The idea of "doing everything perfect on your very first cycle" feels more like a challenge run thing, then it feels like "actual advice players should follow"
 
4.80 star(s) 107 Votes