Ren'Py Brothel King [v0.2] [Goldo]

4.60 star(s) 44 Votes

HeroinKIds

Newbie
May 7, 2019
73
120
Sorry, English is not my native language


I've seen some complain about bugs, and the patch didn't help them. There is one feature that I came across myself and found that there should not be a " ' " symbol in the name of the folder with the girl, this always causes an error

I hope this helps someone
 

phupdup

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2019
1,391
1,086
Yeah, that's generally a "bad idea" for a lot of things. Us Linux folk love our bash shells, and those "'" characters in folders and filenames cause us to jump through all sorts of hoops (eg \' to not have the parser do something stupid with it in a string). The stuff we see in the shell is exactly the sort of wrench thrown into the plumbing internally in software. You don't even want to know what sort of garbage happens in html files to "escape" them.

Sorry, English is not my native language


I've seen some complain about bugs, and the patch didn't help them. There is one feature that I came across myself and found that there should not be a " ' " symbol in the name of the folder with the girl, this always causes an error

I hope this helps someone
 

Jman9

Engaged Member
Jul 17, 2019
2,295
957
As far as I've seen, the Win version can handle apostrophes just fine. This is one of those things that makes developing stuff for multiple OSes a pain.
 

Gutsandguts

Active Member
Dec 9, 2017
643
748
On the topic of difficulty I'm playing on Hard and boy, it isn't fucking kidding is it? I had to reload quite a few times and branch out a new universe. The first two chapters were a freaking nightmare.

I'm not sure I'm a fan, yes yes I know playing on Hard is a choice I made but it feels a little too restrictive, I find myself making half my girls dip in to the Bride or the Maid just for free maintenance and security because otherwise it's just nuts and if you ever get one of those bad events where you get 200 dirt and possibly some injured girls, you are completely fucked if you weren't already doing really well.

I struggled for the first few chapters barely making it through each month but now on chapter 3 it feels like I can't lose, I've got 16k even though half my girls were tired. In a way I guess that feels kinda rewarding but yeah I had to reload some hilariously bad events a few times.
Quite a few cases of: "Alright lets end the day, hopefully some girls give customers some extra service hehehe"
"Oh no, oh no oh no, I'm never going to financially recover from this"


I think one thing that would help is giving the player more ways to personally earn money, some months I literally only survived through going to the sewers and finding 70-120 gold every now and then, it was that tight.

And while that was obviously an option it's entirely random so not exactly reliable and it can end with you having to deal with fights you aren't specced for and actually lose money.
Since MC apparently has a magic cock maybe you could offer to train other slavemasters girls for a bit of cash on the side? That would be super helpful.



As for Papa Freak maybe I was just lucky that I had a pretty decent girl ready but I found it easy enough to scrape up some cash for a garment that boosted refinement and some fancy ass grapes. I guess having upgraded the shop once or twice is fairly critical there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jman9

phupdup

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2019
1,391
1,086
I'm still figuring things out on my playthrough and am only slowly going through the code to see whether I can do for BK what I did for SoC.

While I know that there's those folk out there who love to micromanage and grind, I'm not one of them. If you are going to force people to grind, at least have a lot of content during the process. Hold up your hand if your are tired of seeing the same passages time and again on the random encounters, training events and nightly performances. That's a sign that there should be more focus on adding stories and/or speeding up the progression of the story arcs and girl development.

One solution is to have more NPC's that are something other than random characters. I can see two classes that can be introduced here to address the shortfalls with RNG in the shop and class system. The first is to stop forcing us to sell off assets when moving chapters. I liked the way Pytfall allows MC to head on down to the realtors to buy up and expand new buildings as they built up their empire. Free Cities has a Head Girl who can help train the girls and a bodyguard for protection. Why can't BK just let us keep running what we have by appointing people like this who can run the show? It already kind of does this with the farm as it is.

The other class might include people we meet along the way or even a family/war buddies/guild associates type system where we can bring in people we know or are related with to take over some of the management. Hell we could even have some of those randoms in the street that we can meet and interact with and then become buddies enough to hire in. All of these NPCs can have talents to work as trainers, gophers and brothel management. Then we could bring in a body builder, tea ceremony wonk and makeover expert to train up those attributes that are sorely lacking. On a related note, why are the bankers in this thing basically just glorified loan sharks and not real bankers? Why are we forced to pay ever increasing extortion to lower the security threat when we could have a real banking system?
 

Jman9

Engaged Member
Jul 17, 2019
2,295
957
If you are going to force people to grind, at least have a lot of content during the process. Hold up your hand if your are tired of seeing the same passages time and again on the random encounters, training events and nightly performances.
There's actually a considerable amount of text, covering a multitude of occasions and outcomes. If you think there's not enough variety, write your own additions and submit the result to Goldo. AFAIK, he's tried to get additional writers on board several times, and the only one who met him partway was Kite80.

As someone who once wrote ponygirl/catgirl/bunnygirl flavour blurbs, I can tell you it's not a lot of fun. And the few people in the community who like this are focused on the community dialogue project. We just don't have the manpower for this.

But even the deepest well will run dry if you always use the same girls in the same roles. So some of it is on you as a player, for not trying out other options.

That's a sign that there should be more focus on adding stories and/or speeding up the progression of the story arcs and girl development.
Goldo is adding new events and new story now with 0.2, after a long dry spell of playing around with game mechanics during 0.15. Again, if you think it's too slow, lend a hand. Honestly, that's probably going to end up more useful/impactful than any refactoring of the game's classes you might do.

I also disagree about girl advancement. I'm your exact opposite and love micromanagement and grinding. And a simbro game is ultimately a grinding game, no matter what embellishments you tack onto it. If I think that the vanilla game has ridiculously fast girl development (at least on normal difficulty) and you think the opposite, the conclusion is that the game is roughly balanced between play styles.

You can also play on a custom difficulty and speed up all stat gains and whatever else by up to five times. If that's not enough, then you're not really interested in a simbro game, and your opinion about these mechanics is irrelevant. There are enough slice-of-life games already.

The first is to stop forcing us to sell off assets when moving chapters.
That way lies the madness of Whore Master and 200-girl brothels. It was a conscious design decision to avoid multiple brothels. We got a long feedback post just yesterday, saying that there are too many bedrooms available right now. Which isn't really wrong.

Pytfall ... new buildings
The BK equivalent is furniture.

Free Cities has a Head Girl who can help train the girls and a bodyguard for protection. Why can't BK just let us keep running what we have by appointing people like this who can run the show?
BK also has a Head Girl type position, your trainer. I wouldn't mind some more advanced functionality added to this.

But... People have mused about adding more trainers or automating some part of training for a long while. The closest we got was one guy creating a rather empty framework for training and some kind of underground activities for his own planned mod. He then disappeared. I myself wrote master bedroom automation, which ended up a lot of work and a lot of bugginess, and I don't even know if anyone found it truly useful.

So what I'm going to say is that I'll believe it when I see it. Produce a proof-of-concept trainer mod and if people absolutely love it, I'm sure Goldo will consider adding it to the game. In the meanwhile, I want Goldo to do chapters 3 and 4, the Headhunter and more rivalry with Kosmo. And that's already a lot.

On a related note, why are the bankers in this thing basically just glorified loan sharks and not real bankers?

Why ... real banking system?
Two reasons.

Crunch: game balance. We already have the player earning too much gold as it is.

Fluff: BK is set in a pseudo-Renaissance setting. This was a time when bankers charged you for a deposit and letters of credit, not the other way around.

The unreleased last version of my mod (before I stopped developing it) has the Banker offer you a deposit where you can keep your cash safe from thieves and other mishaps, thus lowering brothel threat. She charges a fee, though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gorm13 and 246

docclox

Active Member
Game Developer
Aug 20, 2016
563
569
So, out of curiosity ... anyone know why recruiting girls from the city turned to signing a "temporary slave contract". I know it's old news by now, but I kind of liked it when I was manipulating them into giving away their freedom. This temporary business isn't nearly as much fun.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Yukihirou

Gutsandguts

Active Member
Dec 9, 2017
643
748
So, out of curiosity ... anyone know why recruiting girls from the city turned to signing a "temporary slave contract". I know it's old news by now, but I kind of liked it when I was manipulating them into giving away their freedom. This temporary business isn't nearly as much fun.
Wait, it's meant to be temporary? I thought that was just trickery?

I've got at least three girls that way and none have decided to leave or anything. I can dismiss them rather than sell them though, do they just leave if they get angry at you or something?

I feel like that's pretty fair considering the insane profits you could make from all that free real estate out there. Oh hey, yeah girl this is just "temporary" just a few months until you're trained up and on your feet...oh the shackles are just for show don't worry about it...
 

docclox

Active Member
Game Developer
Aug 20, 2016
563
569
I've got at least three girls that way and none have decided to leave or anything. I can dismiss them rather than sell them though, do they just leave if they get angry at you or something?
I think it's just that you can't sell them on.
 

__neronero

Member
Jan 23, 2021
276
380
So, out of curiosity ... anyone know why recruiting girls from the city turned to signing a "temporary slave contract". I know it's old news by now, but I kind of liked it when I was manipulating them into giving away their freedom. This temporary business isn't nearly as much fun.
It is indeed just that you can't sell them on for profit, you can only dismiss them. At some point the free-girl screen changed allowing you to get a peek at each girl's stats while talking to them.

This allowed you to search out only the high-ranked girls in order to recruit them and instantly sell them for profit. That was deemed to be too OP. (Not sure if I fully agree, it sounds like a fun path for the player to take to me, but it is what it is)

Long term the idea is that seducing free girls will not be the only option, but evil players may also choose to kidnap them. That alternate path would allow you to sell the girls after some time.
 

Leortha

Active Member
Jun 25, 2019
744
665
I think it's just that you can't sell them on.
That is it exactly. It was decided (by the main dev Goldo and some others on the BK forum) that the idea of enslaving the free girls and then selling them was a bit too much. Mostly because it was a but unbalanced to get girls for free and then be able to immediately sell them if I remember right. So it was changed to the "temporary" contract, with the primary aspect of it being temporary is that the girl is only a slave as long as the MC want her to be his slave. If the MC ever wants to get rid of her he has to give her back her freedom. He cannot sell her off to another slaver.
 

Jman9

Engaged Member
Jul 17, 2019
2,295
957
This allowed you to search out only the high-ranked girls in order to recruit them and instantly sell them for profit. That was deemed to be too OP. (Not sure if I fully agree, it sounds like a fun path for the player to take to me, but it is what it is)
You can still largely do that, since the clue that shows original girls is still there, and these are the best girls anyway.

I suppose the biggest argument in favour of indenture was still that free girls are, well, completely free, you know?

I also disagreed with this decision, but since Goldo was not swayed by my arguments, well, you know the drill...

...kidnap them.
I don't know about kidnapping. Strec's mod was pretty much a cheat as far as I recall, and my own attempt at kidnapping went through a lot of fiddling and when I once offered to try to make a mod of it, no one took an interest.
 

Kite80

Well-Known Member
Modder
May 30, 2017
1,049
1,038
I just started a new game at insane level, I'm still in chapter 1 and got 2 slaves, plus MC already has sex with a free girl. Every day I manage to earn a few coins, a lot less than on normal level but it's not impossible to avoid a game over. At least so far...
 

phlore101

Member
Jun 28, 2017
302
126
I'm playing on insane and am using the trait_king mod so that probably makes a big difference. While I have save scummed an awful lot at different stages, mostly with regards to security events, I generally haven't for the slave market and have just made do with whoever shows up. I got lucky early with one girl who had the genius trait so I managed to get past the old guys 75 stat request just fine.

It was around there that the game got really hard. The tax lady and a bad month made it so I had to sell one of my girls just to get through the last few days of the month. I had to stash some girls with great traits at the farm as I didn't want to pass them by. After getting past that I'm doing fine now. I'm at the end game now with Rank X girls and the game is back to what it used to be I guess. Money is still a problem I suppose as I'm getting taxed 200k+ a month. I can't afford to buy the top end weapons and whatnot yet but I think it's just because I'm too fussy with the quality of my girls and don't have enough to service everyone.

Now it's just a case of speeding through the week trying to find diamonds and waiting for furniture to be built and the slave market to be reset. Maybe I'll look at trying to get a lot of the achievements. That is a nice addition to the game as you run out of other stuff to strive for. Maybe trying to max out one girl??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jman9

Yukihirou

Well-Known Member
Feb 4, 2018
1,341
1,221
Oh come on again ? Letting MC be evil is ok but allowing him to kidnap and sell girls is not ok and masked behind being too OP ? MC can come witness an execution of innocents? and side with Feira feeding and picking on the poor souls of the slums but selling dumb hoes that fall for his charm is still not ok ?
 

Jman9

Engaged Member
Jul 17, 2019
2,295
957
before I would romance girls train them on the farm and sell them for profit. Now the farm is just extra storage.
(y) You can still buy cheap slaves and do it with them, but it's not quite the same.

I'm playing on insane and am using the trait_king mod...
You didn't have trouble with all the bugs in the old Trait King? Like the one where getting new traits disables your night event display, a missing key for an improvable negative trait, probably more?

...selling dumb hoes that fall for his charm is still not ok ?
Come over to the dark side Bonanza... :devilish: We have more ways to be evul.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Yukihirou

phlore101

Member
Jun 28, 2017
302
126
(y) You can still buy cheap slaves and do it with them, but it's not quite the same.


You didn't have trouble with all the bugs in the old Trait King? Like the one where getting new traits disables your night event display, a missing key for an improvable negative trait, probably more?


Come over to the dark side Bonanza... :devilish: We have more ways to be evul.
I haven't noticed anything yet. I have had a couple of outright crashes of the game with no traceback but it hasn't occurred often enough for me to worry about. I did play bonanza for quite a while during 0.15 but I'll probably just keep doing this current run for a little bit longer than go and play something else. Unless there are major changes there isn't really any point in me starting a new game. I really should go and play some of the games in my steam pile of shame that just keeps building and building.
 

Jman9

Engaged Member
Jul 17, 2019
2,295
957
I haven't noticed anything yet.
Interesting. You didn't use 'Marked' girls much, then?

I did play bonanza for quite a while ... than go and play something else.
Unless there are major changes there isn't really any point in me starting a new game.
There are some changes, but they never got released. I want to say that if you liked Bonanza, try my other mod, but that one is also kind of in a coma ATM. :cry:
 
4.60 star(s) 44 Votes