TonyMurray

Engaged Member
Apr 8, 2024
2,193
3,705
I'm talking for the people here that goes to the review sections of the games and give 5 stars to games that are absolute garbage because the don't have the slightest critical sense, or people who don't understand that making a game has different rules than making a visual novel, a comic book or a movie.
Just to note, rating a game/thread here is a subjective thing, not objective. That means people can rate a game 5 stars because they enjoy it a lot. It doesn't have to be objectively perfect, that's not what a rating system is for. Five stars says someone really liks the game, even if it might have flaws (or maybe they don't see/care about the flaws, because there is enough for them to overlook them). There's nothing wrong with that at all.

Your comment above just says that you have issue with people giving 5 stars to a game that you personally don't like ("that are absolute garbage") - but that just means that they have a different opinion to yours, and they (and you) are allowed those opinions.
 

Dessolos

Devoted Member
Jul 25, 2017
11,916
15,342
Just to note, rating a game/thread here is a subjective thing, not objective. That means people can rate a game 5 stars because they enjoy it a lot. It doesn't have to be objectively perfect, that's not what a rating system is for. Five stars says someone really liks the game, even if it might have flaws (or maybe they don't see/care about the flaws, because there is enough for them to overlook them). There's nothing wrong with that at all.

Your comment above just says that you have issue with people giving 5 stars to a game that you personally don't like ("that are absolute garbage") - but that just means that they have a different opinion to yours, and they (and you) are allowed those opinions.
This is 100% true ive played games on here that I think are garbage but the enjoyment factor was high enough for me to give it a 4 or 5 star easily. That and a game doesn't need to be subjective good for it to be enjoyable or to like it. Hell about 1/2 or so of my top 10 are probably worst games then some lower than it but I enjoyed and liked them more.

Well, NO, it's NOT.
lmfao thanks for the laugh but it 100% is not everyone likes or thinks the same writing is good or bad. Hell alot of games I like some would say are badly written but I don't agree as I just cant see it personally. So to me that's their subjective opinion of it being bad and mine that I like it. So yeah I don't see how writing isn't subjective.
 

Radnos Salazar

Active Member
Dec 4, 2023
919
1,551
I'm talking for the people here that goes to the review sections of the games and give 5 stars to games that are absolute garbage because the don't have the slightest critical sense, or people who don't understand that making a game has different rules than making a visual novel, a comic book or a movie.
Here you go, calling anyone who does not see the game through your lens of analyzing a game "Not having critical sense". Everyone who plays the game does not see it the way you do, ofcourse you have the right to express how you feel about the game good or bad no one is stopping you. But telling everyone who do not agree with the way you see a game, not having critical sense to judge a game is just plain stupid they might just enjoy it more than you do, everyone will have different opinions you cannot state your view as objective reality it is still subjective, no matter how many PHDs you have in reviewing porn games lol.
 

Amedore

Member
Jul 6, 2018
413
865
Here you go, calling anyone who does not see the game through your lens of analyzing a game "Not having critical sense". Everyone who plays the game does not see it the way you do, ofcourse you have the right to express how you feel about the game good or bad no one is stopping you. But telling everyone who do not agree with the way you see a game, not having critical sense to judge a game is just plain stupid they might just enjoy it more than you do, everyone will have different opinions you cannot state your view as objective reality it is still subjective, no matter how many PHDs you have in reviewing porn games lol.
The general level of erotic games is sub par. That's a fact. Someone with a bit of critical sense can butcher easily 95% of the games of this site in terms of plotholes and characters.

I'm not talking about honest fap material, like 'Project Miriam', 'Her desire', 'Champions of liberty institute, NauthyLyanna and similar ones. I'm talking about ambitious (I would better say pretentious) games that supposedly are trying to tell an interesting story and create relatable characters, like this one, BaDIK, Summer's Gone, A Wife and Mother, Intertwined or The Bite Revenant. Those are the games that come to my mind right now.

Those games have a lot of reviews of 5 stars, but all of them have huge plotholes, Lis that are only attractive because their 3D model are attractive, not because of their personality and traits, stupid antagonist, cliché scenes, unattractive MC to play as, etc. And devs that are creating a role-playing game with a player that controls a MC and takes decisions for him, but that don't know even the basics to create one of those games; they think that are the same rules as if they were creating a comic or a movie. They don't know the difference between 'player' and 'viewer'. That's a fact. So, yes, most of the people doesn't actually ask for quality. I suppose most of them just want good 3D models with big tits and a 'skip' button for skipping most of the text between lewd scene and lewd scene.
 

TonyMurray

Engaged Member
Apr 8, 2024
2,193
3,705
The general level of erotic games is sub par. That's a fact. Someone with a bit of critical sense can butcher easily 95% of the games of this site in terms of plotholes and characters.

I'm not talking about honest fap material, like 'Project Miriam', 'Her desire', 'Champions of liberty institute, NauthyLyanna and similar ones. I'm talking about ambitious (I would better say pretentious) games that supposedly are trying to tell an interesting story and create relatable characters, like this one, BaDIK, Summer's Gone, A Wife and Mother, Intertwined or The Bite Revenant. Those are the games that come to my mind right now.

Those games have a lot of reviews of 5 stars, but all of them have huge plotholes, Lis that are only attractive because their 3D model are attractive, not because of their personality and traits, stupid antagonist, cliché scenes, unattractive MC to play as, etc. And devs that are creating a role-playing game with a player that controls a MC and takes decisions for him, but that don't know even the basics to create one of those games; they think that are the same rules as if they were creating a comic or a movie. They don't know the difference between 'player' and 'viewer'. That's a fact. So, yes, most of the people doesn't actually ask for quality. I suppose most of them just want good 3D models with big tits and a 'skip' button for skipping most of the text between lewd scene and lewd scene.
Yeah, so what? People are free to like what they want, for the reasons they want. You're free to have negative opinions of what other people like. It doesn't make those people wrong, or you right. Just let people enjoy the games they enjoy playing, and let them rate them highly if they enjoy them.

It's a rarity these days, it appears, but another thing we could do, is go back to using the game threads to discuss the games themselves...
 

Acsuka

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2023
1,357
2,341
I had a question, if you choose 1 of this hotties over another right from the start. Does it change the story by any chance? Or the story remains the same, just changes in scenes?
The main plot of the story is always the same... Scenes and locations change, which girl you like and chase like a hungry wolf... ;)
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,688
22,587
I had a question, if you choose 1 of this hotties over another right from the start. Does it change the story by any chance? Or the story remains the same, just changes in scenes?
I don't know if I understand the question correctly.... Basically you have no way to recover the relationship with either of the 2 girls in the running, there are a series of key monents where you have to respond in a certain way and if you don't you are out, with no chance of recovery. The big difference is just to clarify that you want to get serious or to remain an open couple with either or both of them
 

Acsuka

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2023
1,357
2,341
A harem ending seems unlikely to me, but not impossible, so I would tell you either a final choice or a negative ending
But it's not impossible... Remember the scene in front of MC's room when they divided the days as to who visits MC when... :LOL:
 

Retrofire

Member
Jul 4, 2019
164
561
For the record, I was replying to an open post in an open forum that is not only for fanboys of the games, as far as I know.

I'm not talking for the devs, that probably will never read this. I'm talking for the people here that goes to the review sections of the games and give 5 stars to games that are absolute garbage because the don't have the slightest critical sense, or people who don't understand that making a game has different rules than making a visual novel, a comic book or a movie.

If you make a game in which you create an MC, you give the player the ability to control his decisions and destiny, that is, a ROLE GAME, it is logical to expect (and wish) that the players suspend their sense of reality for a while and feel immersed in the game, that is, play it as a ROLE GAME. That is the goal. But according to what you say, the devs of this game have decided that they don't like players to feel immersed in the game and try to make them feel disconnected and see the game as mere spectators. And that's stupid. If they just want to tell a story, they should have done a Visual Novel without choices, not a game in which "The player's choices will determine both how the game ends, and whom he finishes it with." The problem is, they don't know how to tell a story, nod do a game.
This seems almost personal to you. Are you okay?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Walter Victor

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,688
22,587
But it's not impossible... Remember the scene in front of MC's room when they divided the days as to who visits MC when... :LOL:
The 2 girls do not exactly look overjoyed at the occasion. Surely it's not impossible, it's an avn, but it's not the natural conclusion for either of them; if there is, it will be fan service essentially
 

Acsuka

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2023
1,357
2,341
The 2 girls do not exactly look overjoyed at the occasion. Surely it's not impossible, it's an avn, but it's not the natural conclusion for either of them; if there is, it will be fan service essentially
I was just kidding too... But the scene was fun and it was really more about surprise and discomfort... It's really hard to say if a three way relationship would be viable in this story... I focus on one route and when game over i'll check out the other endings...
 

Dessolos

Devoted Member
Jul 25, 2017
11,916
15,342
Lis that are only attractive because their 3D model are attractive, not because of their personality and traits, stupid antagonist, cliché scenes, unattractive MC to play as, etc.
Maybe the average user do but not all of them do. I've only played 3 out 5 of the games you mentioned and I literally like them all and consider them 5 star games because of the characters.( which is more important than story to me) Not cause they are hot that doesn't matter to me at all. Tho I do admit sometimes I will have a bias because of looks but a very small amount of LI compared to the ones I like less than 5 out of all the ones I like. The only time looks play a part in my decision is when I don't know who I like more yet and I have to choose between LI A or LI B. But I 100% judge a character but their personality , character backstory , how much a dev makes me feel for a character basically everything that makes a character a character.

Hell this game all the characters I like is for the same reasons. Jaye is my favorite for her character and romance story. Yet I don't find her as attractive compared to alot of people. To me she is at the bottom of redheads I find hot to me but her character makes her great.
 

Ancandune

Newbie
Sep 3, 2022
31
26
A harem ending seems unlikely to me, but not impossible, so I would tell you either a final choice or a negative ending
I agree that a harem ending seems unlikely, but a throuple ending seems possible, either MC-Jaye-Tara or MC-Mallory-Amanda.

On the other hand, Jaye and Mallory are getting a little more comfortable with each other in my play though (open relationship with both). Not close, but at least friendly.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,688
22,587
I agree that a harem ending seems unlikely, but a throuple ending seems possible, either MC-Jaye-Tara or MC-Mallory-Amanda.

On the other hand, Jaye and Mallory are getting a little more comfortable with each other in my play though (open relationship with both). Not close, but at least friendly.
Jaye, Mallory and Mallory+Amanda I think are pretty much official endings. Tara, at the time was ruled out as a possible LI and has practically disappeared from the game, it seems to me too late to make sense of an ending together with Jaye. When I was talking about a harem I was referring to a harem with the 2 LIs, and despite some hints, the open relationship you mention, I still have little faith in it
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ancandune
4.60 star(s) 361 Votes