Its really not that hard man. You just need to start a relationship with both but choose Jaye when it comes to it, don't do anything else with Mallory and stay 100% loyal to Jaye but when you reach the lodge scene with Mallory, say that you still has feelings for her, then in the last scene with Jaye she will ask if you want to try a poly relationship if your Love/Trust is high enough.I'm using the guide but I can't get to the end with both.![]()