- May 15, 2021
- 1,482
- 3,264
Perhaps. While I don't see Elsa being an altruistic person, we don't really know. She has material wealth, yes, but we don't know if she actually cares for it, or if her fancy stuff was simply provided for her.Perhaps she wants to feel like she's giving something back to the world and doing something good even as she rather obsessively strives for success and status. She might just like to be needed and to be the most important presence in someone's life. Of course, she also seems to have uses for Ed that will help her in her own rise to power as well so her motives certainly aren't entirely pure even in her own mind.
As for being needed, I can see that more easily. She is too polite to say it (maybe even to herself), but she looks down on Edward and I could see her enjoy being the most important person in someone's life who she considers to be beneath her.
As a fellow cynical misanthrope, I hesitate to label her "unhealthy" but I can see how one might. But we simply don't know enough about her to declare her unhappy. Remember, we only see Edward's perspective and Elsa deliberately keeps him away from her personal life. Aside from a brief exchange at the police station, we've never seen her have a personal, non-transactional interaction. She could have a whole different life outside of work. I base this assumption on myself - work me and family and friends me are two very different peopleAnother possibility is that she really needs to have a human punching bag to lash out at occasionally. [...] Elsa doesn't seem like a particularly happy and healthy person to me. Her world is narrow. [...] She has a few friends, but she's admitted that it's more a sense of loyalty than shared interests that continue to tie her to them.
I agree with the observation, but not with the conclusion. Alice strikes me as nouveau riche; she is ostentatious about money. Her showiness and exuberance feel like cover for an empty life. Elsa, on the other hand, exudes old money vibes. Despite being just as privileged, her approach to wealth is more private and subdued. Even her clothes are understated. She could very well be enjoying her wealth to the fullest but in private, with people she is actually close to. That seems a lot healthier than what Alice is doing.It wouldn't surprise me to learn that Elsa and Alice actually come from similarly privileged backgrounds, but Alice seems to enjoy her life of privilege much, much more.
We only see Elsa through Edward's twisted psyche. She is cold to him, yes, but I don't think we can deduce her romantic side (or lack thereof) from that.There are a number of boxes she wouldn't check for me -- most notably, I doubt she'd be a very supportive or loving person in a relationship, and those are two very important personality traits for me.
These I agree with completely.And I can imagine she might turn off a whole host of men for various reasons. Insecure guys wouldn't like feeling inferior next to her. Proud fellows might find her insulting and disrespectful. Proper gents might be scandalized by her bluntness.
I think her mix of intelligence, confidence and demeanour oozes sexuality, but not sexual availability. That just increases her desirability for me, but I admit it would be a turn-off for someShe doesn't exactly ooze sexual availability either which might turn off the Brians and Neils of the world.