When i notice a game has no choice i just stop and the never bother with it again
- Thread starter Crazygamer43
- Start date
- Jan 5, 2020
- 798
- 1,120
I think she's lesbian, or she is "that one chick whom you have so much in common but feel you can't bang for unknown reasons".If we can't romance Elsa, I'm going on a hunger strike.
The whole "kinetic visual novel" comes, surprise surprise, from a japanese thing... there is (was) a company that made choiceless VNs that was called kinetiku or whatever... so I guess it stuck, like how people use "NTR" when they could use less confusing terms in english, but there you go.
Anyways, the "kinetic" tag refers just to a VN where there are no choices, it's effectively akin to reading a sort of manga/comicbook, but in VN format. It's got nothing to do with "forced LIs" specifically, because everything is "forced", you get a story and you can't change any outcome.
As for Corporate Culture... it has choices and they affect some outcomes... sure there aren't many (yet), but there's enough (more than zero) for it to not be considered a "kinetic" AVN.
- Sep 12, 2018
- 9,290
- 37,991
as i have said above - in respect to those two tags/genres (VN and KN) a third tag/genre probably would help to describe some games in-between (such corporate culture tends to be obviously) - there are choices (doesnt matter how many of them), yet there are (en)forced LIs one cant really avoid "due to the story reasons".
for me, that would be a red flag while choosing games to play...
yet it is what it is, so we can even enjoy "VN"s being more "kinetic" than any proper KN (guilty pleasure, probably the best example).
gonna stop, before i/we venture too far into the OT territory
Hmm I'm having a hard time with your logic here... the only proper LI right now (Lucy) is not forced. I'm assuming you're refering to Alice? But she's not a LI yet, so I dunno what you're talking about... =/
- Apr 25, 2020
- 4,926
- 13,604
He doesn't like the fact that the MC is interested in Alice without player input. Same thing I guess if you start a game with a MC already having a GF or wife
But... that's the whole premise of the game... without that it's not corporate culture, it's just random girlfriend simulator #27853...
- Sep 12, 2018
- 9,290
- 37,991
then make it "kinetic novel" - and everyone is happy.But... that's the whole premise of the game... without that it's not corporate culture, it's just random girlfriend simulator #27853...
what would be the point otherwise?
though seems as you are lacking resources to get it - even after people draw it for you
But it's NOT a kinetic novel... are you damaged or something?? It's got choices... it's not a KN.then make it "kinetic novel" - and everyone is happy.
what would be the point otherwise?
though seems as you are lacking resources to get it - even after people draw it for you
Just because you have a weirdass hang-up about the premise of the story it doesn't mean the game should get different tags... wtf
Also, how much you wanna bet that there'll be an option to not pursue Alice later on? Like it's painfully obvious... so there's no forced LIs now and there's very probably not gonna be any... but aaaaanyways.
Why are you so dead set against saying Alice is a forced LI? If you remove Alice from the game, what is left?
Because she's not... yet, at least. She's not even a main character right now, she's more of a plot device. To be a LI you'd need to be able to get into a relationship with her and you can't.
You guys are the ones dead set on calling her a "forced LI"... for some reason... but you're wrong, she's neither "forced" or a "LI" at this point, just let it go. IF she becomes a forced LI later on, then I'll agree with all of you, but we're nowhere there yet, so it's a big IF at this point.
Explain how the unavoidable scene in the cafe where MC throws his face into a door is optional. He wants her to be a LI and the player is forced to watch a dumb thing play out.
I agree with Jacowboy the only thing forced about her is the plot. Just because she is the "plot" doesn't mean we will get in a romantic relationship with her , unless the dev decides to take away choices so we cant screw up a date or something. As I believe Elsa will still be a LI later. Nothing is set in stone yet, yes there are story elements that are forced but because the story is forced doesn't mean we won't be able to go in the opposite direction later. Now if we get in a romantic relationship with her without any say in the matter then yeah id consider it forced
- Apr 25, 2022
- 1,750
- 5,733
The distinction (at least for me) is when there's a clear reciprocal romantic attraction between the two characters. Eddie's crush on Alice is completely one sided and there is not indication as of yet that Alice has any romantic interest towards him.
So when people say "she's not an LI yet" it's because the characters have not started romancing each other yet. As of right now, Alice is just a plot device. She's Eddie's carrot on a stick. She will probably (very likely) become romanceable at some point in the future, but that hasn't happened yet. And when that moment happens, you will almost certainly get a chance (or several chances) to avoid her path, just the same as with Lucy. Hence why she's not a "forced LI". In other words, A future or prospective LI is not the same as "forced" LI.
Edit: I'd also add that given this VN's style, the process of turning her down may not be as direct as other VNs. It might be a matter of how much self-respect Eddie has when it comes time to make a decision about Alice and that might frame the dynamic of their relationship should Eddie chose to romance Alice. Ex: Whether he lets her keep his coat.
Last edited:
Well, do you also want me to explain how the unavoidable scenes with the MC and Elsa when they have any discussions are optional? Damn these devs and their
- Oct 16, 2022
- 572
- 1,081
she is kinda forced, his obsession is the entire reason for the story. thats just the way it is.
It does seem more 'forced' than usual because its not a stretch to say the game is a "stalker simulator". its a person that is not a part of his life, and everything is manipulated in every interaction.
I sincerely hope there's at least an option for a 'dark' ending where it ends badly...
It does seem more 'forced' than usual because its not a stretch to say the game is a "stalker simulator". its a person that is not a part of his life, and everything is manipulated in every interaction.
I sincerely hope there's at least an option for a 'dark' ending where it ends badly...
So what you're saying is she's a plot device?
Also, I was gonna go into how that's not exactly what the story is actually about... but eh, what's even the point...
I have a feeling all of you folks claiming "forced LI" are also NTR rage-quitters...
- Oct 16, 2022
- 572
- 1,081
his entire motivation to actually behave like a normal human and do his job is HER. how is that not the basic story plot?So what you're saying is she's a plot device?
Also, I was gonna go into how that's not exactly what the story is actually about... but eh, what's even the point...
I have a feeling all of you folks claiming "forced LI" are also NTR rage-quitters...
- Apr 25, 2022
- 1,750
- 5,733
I think you're agreeing with him on that point but making it sound like an argument
As for the "forced LI" thing, Alice is not romanceable yet, as was mentioned earlier. Eddie's interest in her is unreciprocated. He's just a dude with a crush using Alice as a motivation for improvement. At this point of the story, Alice and Eddie are friends at best, but nothing more. It remains to be seen if there even will be a "something more" (though it's highly likely).
A forced LI would be the MC being in an existing relationship with one of the LIs or entering into a romantic relationship with an LI without player input. Since Alice is neither Eddie's girlfriend nor is she even in a romantic engagement with Eddie at all, she doesn't qualify as a "Forced LI".
Last edited: