JAvatar

Member
Mar 9, 2018
207
252
239
Yeah, umm... buddy that's not patronage at this point, people who pay him are supporting him for the game, shit that he's releasing like artwork, wallpapers, etc. are just extras, and if he doesn't release anything game related, he's basically running a scam with extra steps, lobesod has a point here
Other than that is literally what patronage is. The patron(s) support the artist's lifestyle who then produces things. All the artwork and wallpapers ARE part of the game, part of the project.
 

hoshimota

Active Member
Sep 18, 2023
729
1,852
171
Then write your own story.

We established from act 1 that Morgana wants to subjugate or kill all of humanity, the humans that know about the Fey want to kill ALL the Fey period, and with extreme themes of mind control on the MC's part. What do you think was going to happen story wise besides a war?

This is Arc's game, Arc's story, and the groundwork for the war has been there from the earliest versions.
That's true. But if Arc doesn't want to make a game other people actually like and want to play, then I guess Arc can pay their own fuckin bills lol???
 

JAvatar

Member
Mar 9, 2018
207
252
239
That's true. But if Arc doesn't want to make a game other people actually like and want to play, then I guess Arc can pay their own fuckin bills lol???
As people love to point out, he has over a thousand supporters still, so they obviously DO want to play his game.

THAT'S HOW PATRONAGE WORKS! If you believe in the artist, you support them. If you don't, then you don't. No one is holding a gun to your head and saying "Donate to him NOW!"
 

lobesod

Member
Mar 14, 2018
251
250
247
Im not saying the people who support him are stupid, they do it in some kind of believe, but why pay for something you dont get. Instead send the money to me and once a month ill have a nice BIG gardenparty with free BBQ and beer, for all players of the game, but you have to pay the ticket to my place by yourself (Ishoej, south of Copenhagen in Denmark) :love:
 

goloro1122

Active Member
Nov 22, 2023
673
416
196
Yes. That's the benefit of patronage. If you don't like it, don't support it! If you're here as a non-supporter just bitching about things you have no money in, then quit your damn bitching and ignore the thread.
Hold on, benefit of patronage? Benefit to who exactly? It's like you're a YouTuber and you tell your subs to donate and there’s a big project coming and basically never delivering on that promise.
Wake up man, I said it and I'll say it again, if he doesn't release anything of value soon then he's scamming people out of their money, period, what patronage is, is that you support the creator to give you what you originally supported him for, meaning that you support ARC for that game he promised, all that extra shit he's releasing is just supplementary material, and a way to manipulate people to continue donating, making them think he's actually working while he's clearly not
 

Jake James

Member
Game Developer
Dec 12, 2021
121
265
130
I hate checking up on threads like this and seeing that it's been A WHOLE YEAR since the last release with no meaningful updates despite having a growing social media account. Seriously, why are people throwing money into an incinerator? Let's really break it down a bit.

To keep things simple, let's look at the ~500 $5 subs. That's ~2500 dollars a month from just that tier.
When was the last release? 1/28/25
As a 5$ subscriber, what have you received since then? 4 Wallpapers. No, I'm not kidding.
How much did you pay for these wallpapers spread out through a year? $55.
How much did they earn from $5 subs alone in that time? $27,000

There was also a Fan Art competition. Which is another scam. The prize pool was $500. Oh, that sounds pretty g- TOTAL. It was only $300 for first place. Brother, in many cases, a single detailed commission is $200. They basically got a ton of art commissioned for free, and had them all compete to get slightly above the normal pay rate. Which of course means the winner was probably a pretty nice piece, and means he essentially got a discount on that as well. Imagine if you didn't win or you got third which was only $50. That's way under cost for a good commision.

There was also an 'Anniversary' post which was just a bunch of fluffy language. There was no anniversary update for the game. Not even a new build just fixing bugs. No update to the game at all.

Anyone defending this is trolling. No one subscribes to someone for $5 a month for 4 wallpapers a year. You don't have to update the game constantly, but a year between updates is crazy when you look at the post history. I personally think the anniversary one is the saddest. A celebration of a game that isn't being worked on with 70+ likes on the post and a ton of supportive comments as well.
 

JAvatar

Member
Mar 9, 2018
207
252
239
Hold on, benefit of patronage? Benefit to who exactly? It's like you're a YouTuber and you tell your subs to donate and there’s a big project coming and basically never delivering on that promise.
Wake up man, I said it and I'll say it again, if he doesn't release anything of value soon then he's scamming people out of their money, period, what patronage is, is that you support the creator to give you what you originally supported him for, meaning that you support ARC for that game he promised, all that extra shit he's releasing is just supplementary material, and a way to manipulate people to continue donating, making them think he's actually working while he's clearly not
Per Merriam-Webster
Patronage - Noun
1) Advowson(noun - the right in English law of presenting a nominee to a benefice)
2) The support or influence of a patron(THIS IS THE BIG ONE)
3) Kindness done with an air of superiority
4) Business or Activity provided by Patrons

Patron - Noun
1) Synonyms of Patron
-a: a person chosen, named, or honored as a special guardian, protector, or supporter
-b: a wealthy or influential supporter of an artist or writer(THIS IS THE BIG ONE)
-c: a social or financial sponsor of a social function (THIS IS THE BIG ONE TOO)
2) one that uses wealth or influence to help an individual, an institution, or a cause(THE FINAL BIG ONE)
3) one who buys the goods or uses the services offered especially by an establishment
4) the holder of the right of presentation to an English ecclesiastical benefice

So, by definition, ALL crowdfunding is patronage. YOU DECIDE IF THEIR PROJECT IS WORTH SUPPORTING. That is it. It is not a scam. It takes time to make things. And as a patron in the B, C, and 2 definitions of a patron, you can decide to withdraw your patronage (as in definition 2 of Patronage) if you no longer support the artist. Now, I get it. In today's hustle economy where if you can't produce you are a drain on society(which is of course a HUGE FUCKING LIE spread by the wealthy to accumulate and hoard more wealth), the idea of ACTUAL patronage feels alien. But, and this is the secret, the only contract that he signed is with Subscribestar (now). Meaning, if they aren't penalizing him, he's keeping his end of the bargain, and therefore is NOT scamming anyone.

If you think that's all it is, put your money where your mouth is. Make a game. Go do it. If it's that simple and all he is doing is scamming people, go prove me wrong. I'll wait.
 

JAvatar

Member
Mar 9, 2018
207
252
239
I hate checking up on threads like this and seeing that it's been A WHOLE YEAR since the last release with no meaningful updates despite having a growing social media account. Seriously, why are people throwing money into an incinerator? Let's really break it down a bit.

To keep things simple, let's look at the ~500 $5 subs. That's ~2500 dollars a month from just that tier.
When was the last release? 1/28/25
As a 5$ subscriber, what have you received since then? 4 Wallpapers. No, I'm not kidding.
How much did you pay for these wallpapers spread out through a year? $55.
How much did they earn from $5 subs alone in that time? $27,000

There was also a Fan Art competition. Which is another scam. The prize pool was $500. Oh, that sounds pretty g- TOTAL. It was only $300 for first place. Brother, in many cases, a single detailed commission is $200. They basically got a ton of art commissioned for free, and had them all compete to get slightly above the normal pay rate. Which of course means the winner was probably a pretty nice piece, and means he essentially got a discount on that as well. Imagine if you didn't win or you got third which was only $50. That's way under cost for a good commision.

There was also an 'Anniversary' post which was just a bunch of fluffy language. There was no anniversary update for the game. Not even a new build just fixing bugs. No update to the game at all.

Anyone defending this is trolling. No one subscribes to someone for $5 a month for 4 wallpapers a year. You don't have to update the game constantly, but a year between updates is crazy when you look at the post history. I personally think the anniversary one is the saddest. A celebration of a game that isn't being worked on with 70+ likes on the post and a ton of supportive comments as well.
WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH The thing I'm DONATING MONEY TO doesn't produce what I want.
 

Jake James

Member
Game Developer
Dec 12, 2021
121
265
130
Per Merriam-Webster
Patronage - Noun
1) Advowson(noun - the right in English law of presenting a nominee to a benefice)
2) The support or influence of a patron(THIS IS THE BIG ONE)
3) Kindness done with an air of superiority
4) Business or Activity provided by Patrons

Patron - Noun
1) Synonyms of Patron
-a: a person chosen, named, or honored as a special guardian, protector, or supporter
-b: a wealthy or influential supporter of an artist or writer(THIS IS THE BIG ONE)
-c: a social or financial sponsor of a social function (THIS IS THE BIG ONE TOO)
2) one that uses wealth or influence to help an individual, an institution, or a cause(THE FINAL BIG ONE)
3) one who buys the goods or uses the services offered especially by an establishment
4) the holder of the right of presentation to an English ecclesiastical benefice

So, by definition, ALL crowdfunding is patronage. YOU DECIDE IF THEIR PROJECT IS WORTH SUPPORTING. That is it. It is not a scam. It takes time to make things. And as a patron in the B, C, and 2 definitions of a patron, you can decide to withdraw your patronage (as in definition 2 of Patronage) if you no longer support the artist. Now, I get it. In today's hustle economy where if you can't produce you are a drain on society(which is of course a HUGE FUCKING LIE spread by the wealthy to accumulate and hoard more wealth), the idea of ACTUAL patronage feels alien. But, and this is the secret, the only contract that he signed is with Subscribestar (now). Meaning, if they aren't penalizing him, he's keeping his end of the bargain, and therefore is NOT scamming anyone.

If you think that's all it is, put your money where your mouth is. Make a game. Go do it. If it's that simple and all he is doing is scamming people, go prove me wrong. I'll wait.
You're being completely intellectually dishonest. Do you really, truly think that he owes people that subscribe literally nothing? By that logic, he could stop development on the game, never post again, and collect money from people who forgot they subscribed. Would that not be a scam? There is an implicit expectation that you become a patron (or whatever the site decides to call it) to support the project that person is working on, not to support them financially for fun. As soon as they stop working on that project, they should let people know so they can make a decision to continue supporting them or not.

I subscribed to the CEMU project's Patreon for ~5 years, intending to help them develop the Wii U emulator. I checked back on the project maybe a few times per year. If I had found out they abandoned the project for months or a year while I was still subscribed, I would have felt completely used and disrespected. That's how everyone should feel. Thankfully, they didn't, and my money happily went towards a project which is still in active development to this day. If you don't feel the same, then just like that last guy said, please, give us your money instead because you clearly don't understand the value of it.
 

JAvatar

Member
Mar 9, 2018
207
252
239
You're being completely intellectually dishonest. Do you really, truly think that he owes people that subscribe literally nothing? By that logic, he could stop development on the game, never post again, and collect money from people who forgot they subscribed. Would that not be a scam? There is an implicit expectation that you become a patron (or whatever the site decides to call it) to support the project that person is working on, not to support them financially for fun. As soon as they stop working on that project, they should let people know so they can make a decision to continue supporting them or not.

I subscribed to the CEMU project's Patreon for ~5 years, intending to help them develop the Wii U emulator. I checked back on the project maybe a few times per year. If I had found out they abandoned the project for months or a year while I was still subscribed, I would have felt completely used and disrespected. That's how everyone should feel. Thankfully, they didn't, and my money happily went towards a project which is still in active development to this day. If you don't feel the same, then just like that last guy said, please, give us your money instead because you clearly don't understand the value of it.
Do you honestly think if he wasn't engaging on discord and providing what he does, if he went total silence, people would actually donate? Or that the platform wouldn't kick him for it because he DOES have a contract with them?

And again, all crowdfunding sites are patron based, and YES. The idea is you support the artist so they don't need to worry about things like rent, food, insurance, gas, etc. That is the entire model of patronage. You believe in their project so you support their livelihood. And if you don't, you stop donating. It's really that simple.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: lobesod

Jake James

Member
Game Developer
Dec 12, 2021
121
265
130
Do you honestly think if he wasn't engaging on discord and providing what he does, if he went total silence, people would actually donate? Or that the platform wouldn't kick him for it because he DOES have a contract with them?

And again, all crowdfunding sites are patron based, and YES. The idea is you support the artist so they don't need to worry about things like rent, food, insurance, gas, etc. That is the entire model of patronage. You believe in their project so you support their livelihood. And if you don't, you stop donating. It's really that simple.
Okay thank you, you do agree with me you just don't understand. If he stopped development (which he has, just unofficially) then no one would stay subscribed. He is scamming people then by your definition and admission.
 

JAvatar

Member
Mar 9, 2018
207
252
239
Okay thank you, you do agree with me you just don't understand. If he stopped development (which he has, just unofficially) then no one would stay subscribed. He is scamming people then by your definition and admission.
Except, of course, the fact he is on his discord, and has produced things. You admitted as such. Therefore, of the two, you're the intellectually dishonest one.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: lobesod

lobesod

Member
Mar 14, 2018
251
250
247
ARC is a ONE BIG FRAUD and you potato Javatar is his Donald Trump spreading FAKE news about what we have got the last year.
This is what we have got:

Didnt you see anything - thats right, we have got Z E R O - he may have done some thing on his different platformes but update on game Z E R O.
So people stop feeding the troll (the potato) and do as i have done: put him on ignore - tuttelue potato :poop:
 

goloro1122

Active Member
Nov 22, 2023
673
416
196
ARC is a ONE BIG FRAUD and you potato Javatar is his Donald Trump spreading FAKE news about what we have got the last year.
This is what we have got:

Didnt you see anything - thats right, we have got Z E R O - he may have done some thing on his different platformes but update on game Z E R O.
So people stop feeding the troll (the potato) and do as i have done: put him on ignore - tuttelue potato :poop:
Yeah, and to be honest with you, he's acting like an airhead, and literally just dodging the point of the argument.
Well, I'm tired of his crap, I put him on ignore too, I hope you have a great day mate
 
4.30 star(s) 255 Votes