Beduin123

Well-Known Member
Mar 29, 2023
1,018
1,430
287
Really, how can anyone ever not love her?! :D
I can say that of the present harem members she is my least favourite. I mean I don't hate her or dislike her but I'm not a big fan of tzundere attitude and also her obsession with her tits is quite ridiculous. I met a lot of girls with small tits and none of them was so much ashamed of that. I actually prefer A-size and petite girls, so it is purely the Sarah's attitude and constant talks about her tits that takes the stars off her rating in my eyes
 

rta001

New Member
May 6, 2023
14
52
71
For me it's Misaki by far. I don't hate her in general, and in a finished VN I could even find myself liking her subplot, but every frame the MC spends with her is a frame he's not spending with the rest of the group, and with updates taking an increasingly long time having half a (long) update completely focused on Misaki was just painful.

I've played through multiple times now, usually once per update, and the only content I ever skip through is hers - and I'm not a skipper by nature, I love the journey. I guess I just feel like we really already have a better Misaki at home, in Lucy. You want to play with corruption and public play kinks, you've got her. And we also have a teacher/HM in our pocket too. She just comes across as super redundant, and very uninteresting to be taking up so much screentime in a game that's already overloaded with personality driven LI's.
 

danb35

Active Member
Jul 12, 2023
555
916
203
I guess I just feel like we really already have a better Misaki at home, in Lucy.
Yep, pretty much that. I don't dislike her the way I do Rachel, but I don't see that she really brings anything to the story once we get her off the subway. If she weren't competing for development/writing/rendering time with the other girls, I might not mind, but she is, and I'd rather see more of just about anyone else (maybe even Rachel; at least she's kind of interesting).

I can see Elizabeth and, to a lesser extent, Hannah, as uninteresting, but they get a (temporary) pass from me just because we haven't seen much of them yet, and both seem (to me, anyway) to have potential.
 
Last edited:

Cosy Creator

Active Member
Game Developer
Dec 11, 2022
636
5,565
617
Lucy, and to some extent Victoria, have both definitely suffered from being the first girls to be introduced. The initial parts of their stories where handled much more quickly than the other girls, and then they've just kind of been in a holding pattern while the others occupy the spotlight. That will start changing for them in the coming updates, however, especially after the first time skip to the Christmas arc.
 

Cherubin25

Well-Known Member
Nov 7, 2020
1,597
3,079
387
Lucy, and to some extent Victoria, have both definitely suffered from being the first girls to be introduced. The initial parts of their stories where handled much more quickly than the other girls, and then they've just kind of been in a holding pattern while the others occupy the spotlight. That will start changing for them in the coming updates, however, especially after the first time skip to the Christmas arc.
That is nice to hear :) I was about to answer about the "least favorite LI"-topic and I was about to mention that especially Lucy was shoved aside a bit over time.


Regarding the least favorite LI - I dont think it is really fair to include LIs who did not really have much content yet. E.g. I would not really consider Rachel, even if she is annoying at the moment. Personally I like Cat a lot, she is hot, but she also is really interesting on an emotional level.

Least favorite LIs for me are probably Sarah and the Teacher. The Teacher mainly because she is a timid girl and IMO we already have Lucy for that. And I dont think she is that exciting currently, even tho she is hot.
And I dont like Sarah that much for her character. The Tsundere got old for me for quite some time, even tho she is cute when she is not in her tsundere-mode. I also dislike that she has problems with her small tits all the time, but mainly because I had a ex-girlfriend who was the same - she basically looked like a model, but was unhappy with her boobs and it got tiresome to tell her for months that they look great and I did not mind that they were small (especially since they still fit her frame... Which is the same for Sarah, big boobs would not look good on her, her body is great).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Taipan4ever

Exodus19

Newbie
Oct 2, 2019
39
69
142
That is nice to hear :) I was about to answer about the "least favorite LI"-topic and I was about to mention that especially Lucy was shoved aside a bit over time.


Regarding the least favorite LI - I dont think it is really fair to include LIs who did not really have much content yet. E.g. I would not really consider Rachel, even if she is annoying at the moment. Personally I like Cat a lot, she is hot, but she also is really interesting on an emotional level.

Least favorite LIs for me are probably Sarah and the Teacher. The Teacher mainly because she is a timid girl and IMO we already have Lucy for that. And I dont think she is that exciting currently, even tho she is hot.
And I dont like Sarah that much for her character. The Tsundere got old for me for quite some time, even tho she is cute when she is not in her tsundere-mode. I also dislike that she has problems with her small tits all the time, but mainly because I had a ex-girlfriend who was the same - she basically looked like a model, but was unhappy with her boobs and it got tiresome to tell her for months that they look great and I did not mind that they were small (especially since they still fit her frame... Which is the same for Sarah, big boobs would not look good on her, her body is great).
I agree about the teacher for now, but I don't hate her at all...there just hasn't been any movement really. As for Sarah I get why you are frustrated as I too hate the overly tsundere thing, but I cut her a huge amount of slack for being insecure. She has however many "beautiful" sisters that have teased and taunted her for her petite frame and build her whole life. A few weeks of MC reassuring her isn't going to make that go away at one. I think her progress is pretty realistic and I do like her a lot. Random real-life thing I learned while dating a woman from Australia once; she had small breasts and was insecure about it she even told me that porn in Australia gets banned if girls have small breasts because they consider you the P-word if you like it. WTF??
 

Cherubin25

Well-Known Member
Nov 7, 2020
1,597
3,079
387
I agree about the teacher for now, but I don't hate her at all...there just hasn't been any movement really. As for Sarah I get why you are frustrated as I too hate the overly tsundere thing, but I cut her a huge amount of slack for being insecure. She has however many "beautiful" sisters that have teased and taunted her for her petite frame and build her whole life. A few weeks of MC reassuring her isn't going to make that go away at one. I think her progress is pretty realistic and I do like her a lot. Random real-life thing I learned while dating a woman from Australia once; she had small breasts and was insecure about it she even told me that porn in Australia gets banned if girls have small breasts because they consider you the P-word if you like it. WTF??
Oh, I also dont hate the teacher. In general, I dont hate any LI, just the least favorite. Overall I have positive feelings about all of them.

And yes, story-wise her insecurities will not be resolved with knowing MC for a few days. But I hope they will get better with the timeskip or ideally almost completely disappear (there are signs already that they begin to fade with her becoming more confident).
 

jadepaladin

Engaged Member
Mar 9, 2020
3,499
7,280
646
I like the teacher a lot. To me, her age and the teacher/student dynamic make her very different from Lucy (who I also like), and she's a (relatively) different body type too.
What about the teacher/student dynamic makes her different from Lucy?

If you mean her actual position as a teacher, it's not like she uses that power dynamic at all, if anything it's reversed and he's the one teaching her. In that sense, Misaki is still similar to Lucy.
 

Meiri

Well-Known Member
Nov 1, 2019
1,233
2,217
397
You know what, sure, I'll throw my hat in the ring for "least" favorite LI so far. (I use "least" in quotation marks because, like everyone else, I do like all the girls.)

I think that my least favorite right now is Hannah, but that's almost certainly just due to her being pretty new to the group. She hasn't had enough of a chance to establish herself, so it feels a bit unfair to consider her to be at the bottom. Otherwise, I'd have to go with Misaki. To echo others' criticisms, she's felt like a B-plot to everything else; she hasn't had any involvement with either the café or Founding Families. And, to be honest, I kind of think she has the weakest chemistry with the MC (excluding Rachel, obviously). The whole start of the relationship being founded on lies/secrecy and dubcon just left a bad taste in my mouth, personally — especially considering how transparent he is with everyone else. Even though their relationship has easily advanced beyond that by now, it felt like a bad start that's hard for me to come back from.

Anyway, regarding Lucy: I understand that she comes across as "default" in a sense, but I think she's had considerable growth! She's steadily come into her own since the start of the game; MC's confidence has really rubbed off on her, and having that support has allowed her to discover and pursue other interests like her baking. She's still very subdued and introverted, so it's been more subtle than some of the other girls' development, but it's definitely noticeable!
Well, I actually would put Hannah as the one that I am most excited to see her arc resolved, specially if it lets us fuck over Brian a bit.

Misaki I wasn't interested at first but since then she has grown on me to the point where I want to see her succeed and be more assertive, I think she will be a great ally.

I wouldn't say that there are anyone that I am not interested as all the girls have their own thing, maybe Vicky because her story seems done and perhaps at this point I don't find myself as invested in her as with the other girls.
 

JessieIsDying

New Member
Jun 29, 2025
3
4
12
I agree, Lucy's face is too wierd I don't like her at all personally wise either. Allison, Hannah and Vicky are the best one imo. But it's great to see many like different things in the end. The downside of kinetics however is that you have to play through content with ladies you don't care about.

But the game is really good so great work CozyC. :)
 

nonanonanon

Newbie
Apr 23, 2022
17
90
89
Well, I actually would put Hannah as the one that I am most excited to see her arc resolved, specially if it lets us fuck over Brian a bit.

Misaki I wasn't interested at first but since then she has grown on me to the point where I want to see her succeed and be more assertive, I think she will be a great ally.

I wouldn't say that there are anyone that I am not interested as all the girls have their own thing, maybe Vicky because her story seems done and perhaps at this point I don't find myself as invested in her as with the other girls.
Oh, don't get me wrong, I'm eager to see how Hannah's arc goes, too; it's just that she's still too closed-off at this point in the story for me to get a good read on her. I do still like her — she's just got some stiff competition.

I'm also interested in seeing Misaki improve, but her sections just feel very disconnected from everything else going on. Again, I don't dislike the character, and I certainly have liked her more as things have progressed.

Vicky absolutely seems like the easiest one to read so far, and may be the most comfortable one in their situation, but that's likely just her relatively carefree attitude/adaptability on display. I think her arc's far from done; the story just can't balance too many character arcs at once without getting overwhelming.
 

Karakes

Member
Jan 11, 2019
126
154
195
Lucy, and to some extent Victoria, have both definitely suffered from being the first girls to be introduced. The initial parts of their stories where handled much more quickly than the other girls, and then they've just kind of been in a holding pattern while the others occupy the spotlight. That will start changing for them in the coming updates, however, especially after the first time skip to the Christmas arc.
Victoria is still an instigator though. She moves things along. Hence why she's top tier for me. Lucy is just a background character that the plot happens to while she reacts.
 

S1nsational

Engaged Member
Mar 31, 2022
3,790
7,571
613
Not liking Lucy's looks is one thing, everyone has their own taste, but I think people are being too harsh when it comes to her personality and behavior.

You have to remember it hasn't been a very long time in world since MC rescued her. She spent her entire life until very recently being abused emotionally and physically. Personally I'm happy with the progress she's showing. She's getting more confident and showing an interest in things she enjoys.
 

Beduin123

Well-Known Member
Mar 29, 2023
1,018
1,430
287
Not liking Lucy's looks is one thing, everyone has their own taste, but I think people are being too harsh when it comes to her personality and behavior.

You have to remember it hasn't been a very long time in world since MC rescued her. She spent her entire life until very recently being abused emotionally and physically. Personally I'm happy with the progress she's showing. She's getting more confident and showing an interest in things she enjoys.
She can be just shy. A lot of people are quite reserved in their day to day interactions. Everybody has a different personality.
 
Last edited:
4.60 star(s) 271 Votes