If I was going to pick one of them for personal preference it would Georgina.
I like a woman that's lived a bit and knows what she wants out of life. If it was just the sex side of things then Elena would be first. She's forward and I reckon would be up for experimenting a bit.
I follow the game because I do like the story behind it and the characters but the daughter is far too inexperienced and naive for my personal tastes. I've got a high sex drive and don't have the patience to be a teacher in that regard.
That's the generalising I mentioned though, not all of us here are here for the daughter. Granted that's the game so that's what we follow but if given the choice i'd take Georgina.
You also see sex in a very romantic way but some of us are a bit more, I guess primal would be the easiest way to say it.
I don't like how you view Elena as slutty and calling it a crutch. Some people just like sex, that isn't a weakness to be overcome, it's just how some people are.
Good points.
Must admit, between May and now, Elena has become more interesting. Not just because they've almost slept together (I'd might like you better if we slept together. - Romeo Void). But we know about her relationship with her father and we start to see the sexual control dynamics begin to be slowly played between her and MC. I'd like to see that continue. She also has other issues hinted at by the Riccardo sex scene. Does she walk from a relationship that is not sexually satisfying out of the gate? If so, why? Maybe sex is a joy and not a crutch - but there are some indications she has trouble with an intimate relationship. Sex is easy; being vulnerable and intimate without sex is hard. It would certainly be something that would add tension and drama to whatever F/Elena - F/D/Elena - D/Elena matchups are expected in the future.
I also like the more engaged Elena - "let me show D porn" - and hopefully, "D, let's take a shower together" (hinted at for Day 12). Elena has the possibility to move D along sexually faster than MC alone. Therefore, Elena is my new best friend.
As for Georgina, I totally agree, but hope that she can be developed better. I would not call the model industry the most sexually conservative industry. I could see, if Georgina did modeling work before the story began (which must be the case since she cites herself as knowledgeable enough to show D the ropes)... that Georgina has had sexual partners from the industry (other models, a photographer, etc). A shoot in the Bahamas, bunch of models relaxing after a long production day at beach locations, alcohol - Georgina could likely have those experiences along with the boyfriends at home attracted to her: the bassist from a local rock band; a local business owner who liked her after using her in a print ad.
I'd like to see both Elena and Georgina developed more so there is less comments like "this game is really great because of Daughter, but really wish I didn't have to deal with Georgina (or Elena)". I'd rather see: "I want to play all paths because they are all great in their own way."
