RustyV

Conversation Conqueror
Game Developer
Dec 30, 2017
7,412
38,116
891
I know this is kinda silly and hopefully you can get where I'm coming from here, but I find myself getting genuinely emotionally attached... I know she's not a real person, I'm not an idiot, it's just so easy to get lost in the fiction of that world.
Umm you just described every Star Trek and Dr.Who fan.
 

RustyV

Conversation Conqueror
Game Developer
Dec 30, 2017
7,412
38,116
891
Just my two cents here...

The fact that there's a few of you that prefer DMD over Melody, and the other few prefer Melody over DMD,
just shows how great both games are, and how different they are from each other due to the arguments given for both (and not just because of the obvious fetish that doesn't exist in Melody).
It just shows that MrDots and the people working with him are versatile with the games that they want to create.

I mean it would be a lot worse if we all liked one of MrDots' games, but we all agreed that the other one was terrible, wouldn't it?

MrDots and co. have created two games that are so far apart from each other in terms of the story, it already makes me wonder what the next game will be like. ;)

I personally think the writing and the overall character designs are better in Melody, but that makes perfect sense since it's the second game they made and they've had the experience of making DMD leading into creating Melody.

In saying that, there's just something about DMD and the two leads that instantly draw me back into their world with each release.
DMD is kind of like a classic cult film.
Like Holy Grail or The Life of Brian or Rocky Horror.
Fans see the nuances in the films that non-fans will never understand.
The same is true for DMD and Melody fans.
13f.gif
 

RustyV

Conversation Conqueror
Game Developer
Dec 30, 2017
7,412
38,116
891
Really? They are both games about a predatory sexual deviant grooming young girls (that are only not underage because the marketing requires them not to be) over which he has a position of responsibility and authority, in one case being her father!

I am happy to suspend my moral outrage because it is just a game, everyone is entitled to a bit of fantasy, and I do find it quite hot, but I am certainly not going to claim that the MC in either game is likeable. In fact, none of the characters are likeable. In addition to the MCs, D and Melody are completely vacuous, and Elena is coniving. (I admit I quite liked the bookish girl in Melody whose name I have forgotten.) But for me, that's probably a good thing, since I would feel bad about the entire sexually disfunctional clusterfuck they get into if I actually liked them.
It is just fantasy. You can like the fiction without endorsing the characters or engaging in their life styles.
I liked the Netflix Punisher series even though the lead character has no compulsion about killing. I even like the main character, does that mean I would go on a rampage and kill people who pissed me off?
No of course not. Ammo is way too expensive and I don't have the free time.
Seriously it's like over $200 for just a thousand rounds of reman 9mm.
 

Rambo1221

Member
Jul 15, 2019
141
15
92
I'm not sure if I just have an old version of chapter 3 but it ends after Elena comes to visit. Is there a new version or chapter?
 

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
76,831
39,607
1,519
is there going be future daughter swapping? i hope so. i get olivia and grahm gets daughter
yes but its not forced so up to players decisions.

I'm not sure if I just have an old version of chapter 3 but it ends after Elena comes to visit. Is there a new version or chapter?
this version ends on elena's visiting after d and f have "exercised".


as for ages: d doesn't look 19 years old.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rambo1221

Rambo1221

Member
Jul 15, 2019
141
15
92
Anyone have a save where Elena has to do something for Adam (not on the Elena path so it isn't just photos) or near it? And is there a save where the Father gets a big pay out from quitting? Thanks people!
 

LouWill

Member
Feb 3, 2018
104
414
117
They're not real people. If the game tells me they're over 18 and it's even remotely plausible based on the character models, I'll go along with that. It's all just in-game fantasy. If I'm told "here's young looking but legal girls that want your cock" I'm down. If I'm told "here are minors that want your cock" I'll pass. That simple, yo.
I totally understand that point of view. That's why I played the game in the first place. At the same time, it's not over anyone's head that if the legal age was for these games were lower, then the girls' ages would be lower. I know appearances can be subjective, but this the equivalent of a dev creating a really old female model, and saying that she's 22 years old. I don't know about you guys but for me, there's definitely cognitive dissonance at play here. The daughter is 3 feet shorter than the dad, with a face that can pass for an 8 year old. We're supposed to be distracted from that because she's well proportioned, but then you look at Elena, and it's painfully obvious. I'm not gona berate anyone for enjoying this game, and you can always argue that at the end of the day, it's just a game. For me though, I'll stick to the games where the 18 year old actually looks close enough to be 18.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alleykatt

RustyV

Conversation Conqueror
Game Developer
Dec 30, 2017
7,412
38,116
891
as for ages: d doesn't look 19 years old.
It's not so much D who does not look like the standard (short) 18 year old girl, but her friends. That was one of Patreron's issues with the game.
If you compare Elena in DMD to Sofie in Melody you can see how the Mr.Dots team has improved their rendering of petite young ladies.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
For me personally I would not have been opposed to Elena and Jennifer being "reworked" for Chapter2 or Chapter 3 but that could have upset fans and would have felt forced. And this game is for all of us not just the preferences of a few.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Looper9
Sep 23, 2017
17
29
95
For me though, I'll stick to the games where the 18 year old actually looks close enough to be 18.
And you sir have clearly not seen a lot of 18-19 years old. I'm a teacher(in training but still a teacher)and I have seen plenty of girls who I would swear they were 13-14 years because they looked so tiny and childish and they tell me they are actually 19,just yesterday I was talking with some students about college entrance and this girl that is tops a meter tall comes and begin to talk about what she did when she made papers for college.
Do they look younger than 18 sure, but a lot of real people also do, not trying to make you change your mind about playing the game, but the idea that all people just suddenly grow adult characteristics as soon as they hit the age is totally untrue, people take plenty of time to actually look like adults
 

fried

Almost
Donor
Respected User
Former Staff
Nov 11, 2017
2,312
6,133
624
Don't make me link back to all the discussions about how the characters here all have plausible analogues in real life of legal age!

I'm warnin' ya!

Really, this subtopic practically needs a sticky or FAQ entry of some sort...
 
  • Like
Reactions: RustyV
Apr 22, 2019
115
68
28
In my opinion height as a visual thing, does not define age, I tend to visually accept a characters age by looking at her face, there's a porn star that goes by the name of odette, look at her and you understand what I mean.
 
3.80 star(s) 339 Votes