4.80 star(s) 5 Votes
Nov 21, 2023
67
79
You forgot Rosa but dont worry everyone does lol

S Tier - Alexa, Sarah, Lana, Amanda
A Tier - Alice, Silvia, Sharon and her friend aka Kiara
B Tier - Sofia, Emma, Martha, Rosa

Some notes
-Sofia (if wasnt for her lips she would be A)
-Rosa (she needs sex scenes because everyone forgets about her)
Rosa is hard to remember thought I didn't like her design
 
Nov 21, 2023
67
79
  • Like
Reactions: Demion99 and 8TB
Nov 21, 2023
67
79
You forgot Rosa but dont worry everyone does lol

S Tier - Alexa, Sarah, Lana, Amanda
A Tier - Alice, Silvia, Sharon and her friend aka Kiara, unnamed blonde girl who saw Silvia and Alice in the bathroom
B Tier - Sofia, Emma, Martha, Rosa

Some notes
-Sofia (if wasnt for her lips she would be A)
-Rosa (she needs sex scenes because everyone forgets about her)
-Unnamed blonde girl needs to get a name and a story I love her design
1- Unnamed girl was decent and I think she is not going to be around anymore
2- Also Martha is really hot (when I read chapter 1 I really wants Martha and her nephew's scene and never got it )
3- Amanda lost that charisma of her for me (don't know why )
4- Aside from this your list is good too
5- Extra ( don't want more of peter in next chapters of MT )
 

_OBLIVION_

Active Member
Oct 3, 2021
829
1,219
1- Unnamed girl was decent and I think she is not going to be around anymore
2- Also Martha is really hot (when I read chapter 1 I really wants Martha and her nephew's scene and never got it )
3- Amanda lost that charisma of her for me (don't know why )
4- Aside from this your list is good too
5- Extra ( don't want more of peter in next chapters of MT )
1. I really hope you are wrong about unnamed blonde girl, would be a waste not using her, shes hot af
2. Martha and her husband nephew scenario could still happen
3. Alexa took over Amanda shine so I get your point there
4. Cool you like it
5. I think Uncle Peter earned his place after that sex session he delivered to Sarah (one of the best Daval sex scenes imo) now his target is Silvia so we are going to keep seeing him.
 
Last edited:
Nov 21, 2023
67
79
1. I really hope you are wrong about unnamed blonde girl, would be a waste not using her, shes hot af
2. Martha and her nephew scenario could still happen
3. Alexa took over Amanda shine so I get your point there
4. Cool you like it
5. I think Uncle Peter earned his place after that sex session he delivered to Sarah (one of the best Daval sex scenes imo) now his target is Silvia so we are going to keep seeing him.
Which one of yours is favourite comic ID , SN , MT
mines depend on chapters
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demion99

8TB

Member
Dec 24, 2023
208
883
List is pretty good

Well your list is preety good (Lana is mommy fr)
What about ranking of your favourite chapters mine is ID7 and some others
It's a tie between Chapter Three and Chapter Seven. Three could probably edge out if I were compelled to make a choice between the two, because nothing can match the splendor of their first time having sex. Lana's dress, her make up, her jewelry, her body, the angles of their sexual positions, just... UGH!!!! But Seven is pretty epic. A chapter of non-stop sex. And I favor shower-sex in both media, and in my own life, so that was a great touch. Okay, here's my list (I'm excluding this current chapter since it hasn't been completed):

Immoral Desires

1. Chapter Three/Seven
2. Chapter Five
3. Chapter Nine
4. Chapter Eight
5. Chapter Six
6. Chapter Two
7. Chapter One
8. Chapter Four

VIP Madness Together

1. Chapter Four
2. Chapter Six
3. Chapter Five
4. Chapter Three
5. Chapter Two
5. Chapter One

Haven't read SN consistently to make a list.
 
Nov 21, 2023
67
79
1. I really hope you are wrong about unnamed blonde girl, would be a waste not using her, shes hot af
2. Martha and her nephew scenario could still happen
3. Alexa took over Amanda shine so I get your point there
4. Cool you like it
5. I think Uncle Peter earned his place after that sex session he delivered to Sarah (one of the best Daval sex scenes imo) now his target is Silvia so we are going to keep seeing him.
I don't like uncle peter chaotic personality (I also didn't hate him tho ) just wanted more of aron and David's mother ( hope she will get introduced )
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demion99
Nov 21, 2023
67
79
It's a tie between Chapter Three and Chapter Seven. Three could probably edge out if I were compelled to make a choice between the two, because nothing can match the splendor of their first time having sex. Lana's dress, her make up, her jewelry, her body, the angles of their sexual positions, just... UGH!!!! But Seven is pretty epic. A chapter of non-stop sex. And I favor shower-sex in both media, and in my own life, so that I was a great touch. Okay, here's my list (I'm excluding this current chapter since it hasn't been completed):

1. Chapter Three/Seven
2. Chapter Five
3. Chapter Nine
4. Chapter Eight
5. Chapter Six
6. Chapter Two
7. Chapter One
8. Chapter Four

VIP Madness Together

1. Chapter Four
2. Chapter Six
3. Chapter Five
4. Chapter Three
5. Chapter Two
5. Chapter One

Haven't read SN consistently to make a list.
Mines almost same for ID ( but for me chapter 4 > 1,2 rest is fax
And for SN (ch6 > ch11 = ch 12 > ch5 => ch4 => ch9 > rest are mid not bad tho)
Fax for Vip madness together
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8TB and Demion99

Mekalam

Newbie
Jun 28, 2024
40
99
It's a tie between Chapter Three and Chapter Seven. Three could probably edge out if I were compelled to make a choice between the two, because nothing can match the splendor of their first time having sex. Lana's dress, her make up, her jewelry, her body, the angles of their sexual positions, just... UGH!!!! But Seven is pretty epic. A chapter of non-stop sex. And I favor shower-sex in both media, and in my own life, so that was a great touch. Okay, here's my list (I'm excluding this current chapter since it hasn't been completed):

Immoral Desires

1. Chapter Three/Seven
2. Chapter Five
3. Chapter Nine
4. Chapter Eight
5. Chapter Six
6. Chapter Two
7. Chapter One
8. Chapter Four

VIP Madness Together

1. Chapter Four
2. Chapter Six
3. Chapter Five
4. Chapter Three
5. Chapter Two
5. Chapter One

Haven't read SN consistently to make a list.
It's a tie between Chapter Three and Chapter Seven. Three could probably edge out if I were compelled to make a choice between the two, because nothing can match the splendor of their first time having sex. Lana's dress, her make up, her jewelry, her body, the angles of their sexual positions, just... UGH!!!! But Seven is pretty epic. A chapter of non-stop sex. And I favor shower-sex in both media, and in my own life, so that was a great touch. Okay, here's my list (I'm excluding this current chapter since it hasn't been completed):

Immoral Desires

1. Chapter Three/Seven
2. Chapter Five
3. Chapter Nine
4. Chapter Eight
5. Chapter Six
6. Chapter Two
7. Chapter One
8. Chapter Four

VIP Madness Together

1. Chapter Four
2. Chapter Six
3. Chapter Five
4. Chapter Three
5. Chapter Two
5. Chapter One

Haven't read SN consistently to make a list.
Your VIP ones i mine too i think people love and prefers to see uncle peter's chapters than david's one..so uncle must stay in this work
 

8TB

Member
Dec 24, 2023
208
883
Mines almost same for ID ( but for me chapter 4 > 1,2 rest is fax
And for SN (ch6 > ch11 = ch 12 > ch5 => ch4 => ch9 > rest are mid not bad tho)
Fax for Vip madness together
It's not that the sex scenes in Chapter Four aren't good, as the first scene where they have sex on top of the stairs is an extension of Chapter Three, but it's still my impression to this day that chapter excluding the scene I just mentioned may have been an attempt to ingratiate Daniel's becoming a cuckold with the audience. First it was with his getting turned on watching his mother get it on with his Dad, which by this point of the series, Daniel wouldn't even indulge, and his mentioning how the neighbors want a shot at her. Even though the art is good, the dialogue is gawd awful, which is the reason I rank it so low on my list.

What fax means?
"Fax" is shorthand for "facts." It's a colloquial interjection which suggests agreement.

Your VIP ones i mine too i think people love and prefers to see uncle peter's chapters than david's one..so uncle must stay in this work
To be fair, I started with Chapter Four. I've admitted that had I started the series with the first chapter, I may have joined in the backlash that was uncle Peter's inclusion. Maybe not as much, since I do like the Uncle-Niece pairing in incest. For example, Trophy Mom by Y3DF had a fairly vanilla mother-son pairing until its fourth chapter (ironic, hun?) where NTR was introduced with the mother's eldest son. Even though it was still incest, I still dislike that chapter. So, I understand well those who dislike Peter and his inclusion into Madness Together. But for me, given that adult incestuous pairings are rather rare in incest works, it was nice to see a niece who already has a family of her own get it on with her uncle. If I have one criticism of their encounter, it would be that he berates her in Chapter Six. I didn't like that part much.
 
Last edited:
4.80 star(s) 5 Votes