I always wanted MC to join Kat in atleast half of the scenes. Then it would have been number 1 VN for me. But MC only watched her. Also when MC was having sex with other girls Kat did not joined except may be couple of scene.
If VN had mixture of solo and couple adventures, then it would have been top tier. That I hope this VN will achieve, MC should not only watch but participate in 75% of scenes and rest of the scenes could be solo with others.
Can I reply to you here instead? Seems fair since we're discussing this game. I agree with you and I'm usually very picky with how sharing is portrayed. Can't bring myself to enjoy a passive MC, whether he likes being cucked or not. This game nails it because the MC is quite the opposite - he's always assertive, enthusiastic to share Kat - they both are, and for the same reason, they love the kink and have fun playing with the effect Kat has on other guys. There's no "secret cuck fetish" trope or any hint that Kat enjoys it for any other reason than to rebel, with the MC, against convention. You're "co-conspirators" every step of the way, and that perfect complicity is something very few sharing games ever achieve. For that reason alone, I don't mind the fact that, in 75% of the scenes, the MC doesn't join. Truth is that even on the sharing path, you have plenty of sex with Kat and it's especially intense in the few scenes that happen after a sharing event.
It's no small detail that the MC never masturbates while watching, either. There's no transference of libido from fucking Kat to voyeurism, which is another trope I really don't like in games that follow the common cuckold narrative. Even if, by definition, the MC is a cuckold while watching Kat fuck other guys, in practice, if you factor in the context, their relationship, the way scenes are written, it often feels more like they're cucking Kat's "lovers" instead. Kat makes those guys want her, badly, and then leaves them saying it was good, gives them hope that maybe they'll meet again under similar circumstances - but makes it clear that she'll never leave her husband. I love that twist. There's no "score" for the guys, always the "home team" that wins - and that's another reason why I enjoy the sharing path so much in this game. You have no rival in Kat's life. Even her boss, who was portrayed as a famously successful womanizer that had fucked every female at the office, except Kat, and left them wanting more - when you finish the scene, he feels like the dog who was given a bone to chew and then got it taken back, that's enough, good boy. It's perfect "reverse-cuckoldry" and quite unique to this game, unfortunately (if it isn't, I'd dearly welcome recommendations)!