Most loot shooters don't have the enemy stealing everything in your backpack though. Most loot shooters don't have permanent visual impairment (ie a flashbang in COD will flash your screen white for maximum 5 seconds). Most loot shooters don't have arm and leg fatigue, making it hard to flee and hard to aim. Most loot shooters don't have guns made of components, that each of their own impact on gun performance; ie Borderlands has different parts that can be put on a gun during RNG item generation, but they don't affect performance. Most loot shooters have reliable head-shot mechanics. Also most loot shooters don't have you lose everything you collect on death.Many loot shooters don't have a melee attack without getting a weapon first. It's part of game design. You don't always need it.
AcKtUaLly, it's a 4th person turn-based strategy RPG
Wat? You do aim down sights, reloading speed is highly weapon part specific and armor values are a thing.
You're funny. Shout-out to your virus killing virus scanner.
It's a porn shooter. I don't really have to explain why it's maybe good idea to have a nice looking, high quality female protagonist for the porn. She looks waay better than most AAA 3rd person shooter protagonists and that's important (at least for me).
You are trying to justify your own personal preferences by comparing individual mechanics to other (mostly AAA) games and how they are done differently. That's not usefull at all imo. First, each mechanic has to fit into the rest from a design perspecitve as that makes the difference between good and bad. Secondly, comparison as a justification will lead nowhere. In the most extreme sense you could always argue that the game is missing every feature any big game every did.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
So, really, this game does need a melee attack. The argument you need a gun to do it, doesn't work, because even for games like Halo, you can smash people with a gun with no ammo in it and the enemy can't steal your guns until you are dead.
=====
4th person isn't a thing. You are thinking of 2nd person
=====
Most basic gun you start with, you don't aim down the sights. Maybe if you get an aftermarket x4 scope, you aim down the sights, but with your starter gun, you don't ADS. And if the enemy keeps killing you, and raping you, you never have the money to get that scope, so, sorry, but you don't ADS.
=====
When the enemy starts out with max grade weapons and armor, and you start with a shit weapon and no armor, that feels incredibly unfair. Especially when played on the easiest difficulty setting. It would be like playing 7 Days to Die, and trying to kill an Irradiated Wight with a Pipe Shotgun. Good luck on surviving that.
=====
It is not a porn shooter. A porn shooter, has way more than 3 animation sets. Wild Life is closer to being a Porn Shooter, even back in 2019 when they had a tiny team. It is a well known fact that the porn is tacked on, and is not a priority. So it is window dressing, nothing more. Its like a plain chocolate cake filled with cherries, with a tiny splotch of whip cream on it. You can't call that a dark forest cake, with so little whip cream on it. At best it is a cherry chocolate cake with a minor side helping of whip cream.
=====
She looks too tall, bony and way too little fitness for someone engaging in combat roles. She looks anorexic, but hey if you find that attractive, you do you.
=====
If the game had a good gameplay design, I wouldn't need to make comparisons. No one compares Halo's combat to Call of Duty's combat, because both of them have good gameplay design, and the mechanics from one game wouldn't work in the other. But when your gameplay design is shit, with convulted mechanics that detract from gameplay and make the experience overall worse, without adding anything, comparisons have to be made to get it back to a good gameplay design. Not everyone makes a good gameplay designer, which is why most people hire one to do the gameplay design work. Its not an attack on the developer; they are really great at artistic stuff, making it look visually stunning (for the most part). Gameplay design however is not their forte and they really need to hire someone to do it.
=====
As for the spoiler list, all of that stuff can make a game good. Its why so many games have things like it in their games. But you shouldn't add things in willy nilly without first considering if the game would benefit from them.