The Duty path is safer for Lirah, but I didn't like that in this path the MC acts as if he was taking revenge on her, I would like to see a variation, without hate or revenge.
The freedom path is stupid, but in this path the MC shows that he cares about Lirah, he has the option to degrade her, or be affectionate with her, but in the end Lirah will basically be another Asani.
As I commented before, she either becomes an Asani or becomes a Talia, I didn't like either path.
- In the Duty path, the MC will use her, just like he uses Talia.
- On the Freedom path, she will receive the same treatment as Asani, he will visit her a few times, to see how she is, and to spend the night with her.
I have saves for both, I don't know which I prefer, she doesn't seem important enough for it to affect the story, and I don't see a path where she would join the harem, I think it's impossible, firstly, she wouldn't want to be stuck at home, secondly, she is a guard and not a slave, the queen could not give her to us, as she did with Emilia.
I agree with most of what you said, tho in the freedom route there's already been a suggestion made to her that she live with the MC, because the MC is well aware of how completely fucked enslaved, and even dead/eaten she eventually will be, otherwise, living with no family to support and protect her.
Asani, OtOH, is a lucky bird who eventually might still get taken down, anyway, and she is probably only able to make do as she has, by the fact that she's living in the exact ass-end of nowhere.
Remember that Lirah almost got raped almost immediately. Eventually, odds say she will be (probably quite a lot), and quite possibly kidnapped and enslaved:, because she's very, very small and very, very pretty. Like MC says: it's not it's not a matter of "if"; it's a matter of WHEN.
Asani also has a really different attitude than Lirah, as she's a borderline raider and lirah really doesn't have that kind of aggro mentality. Lirah's actually a pretty soft girl, with a lot of principles, just very determined. Asani's got nothing like that occupying her attention, so she just acts pragmatically, and survives.
No I think MC's offer (in the freedom scavenger route) that Lirah live under his roof will eventually be taken, after several probsbly vrery bad things happen to her. The only other good option I see is that she hooks up with a scavenger group and makes good on that. Otherwise, her survival on her own is unlikely, despite her guard training.
In the duty/apology/humiliation route, it's entirely possible she might just stay in the temple as a guard, and get used every time MC rolls through, like with Talia, but she's really beaten when last we see her on that route, fully submitting alongside Talia, so she might change her mind on things even more. She might REQUEST leaving to go live with MC, which the queen might possibly agree to, because Mernieth might find it amusing that Lirah had completely submitted to the MC after going so far out of her way to oppose him that she had insulted the queen, in the process.