He does in fact say I haven't been with her for many years (which in my mind could be anywhere from 4-7 yrs otherwise you'd say over a decade right?) so he doesn't recall if she's a better rider then his wife. But it says many years doesn't allude to before puberty or allude to the ages of the sisters as MC was over 21 years of age before he even woe'd either of them. It does however Allude to him knowing his niece. There is nothing however alluding to him being stolen driving her sister away though i admit she is bitter about the situation according to niece. And if they are as you say not on speaking terms i don't see (MC) going to a city to visit his niece and sister-in-law who doesn't want to speak to him. Which leaves in my mind one option. She was living in same city where he could see his niece until her merchant husband moved them to the city.1. It is possible to speak to your niece without talking to your her mother. This is called "We are not on speaking terms"
You must be registered to see the links
2. IIRC there is in fact such dialog. when speaking to the daughter of the wife's sister the dialog indicates he has not seen her in many years. probably before puberty. (then he fucks her)
So we know that MC is at least 40 yrs old. But we don't know the ages of either the wife nor her sister. As we dont know what age they were when they were woe'd.
The wife during the conversation also doesn't say "You wouldn't fuck my sister right?" She says, "You know she's married now." Alluding to the fact even after the fact of marring his wife he may have still had a physical relationship with her sister. Though that is a very soft allude as your wife is very open to you enjoying the company of other woman in general.
(We also know that it was the sister-in-laws idea to move back dispite the husband wanting to stay because his job would be easier in whatever said city was. Additionally meaning it might not have been her choice to leave in the first place if she wants to go back.)
EDIT: Him being 40 and over relies heavily on the 2 daughters being biologically his and not his step daughters of course. Though as in my previous post Shani having MC's eyes without being his biological daughter is about as rare as winning the lottery in a population of thousands and her being Arabian decent.
a guestimation of age of wife would be 32+ judging from her daughters ages and as you say puberty
Last edited: