Want my honest answer (so not me playing devil's advocate)?
I think the reasons that "dream scene" is there are 2:
- Story reason, it shouldn't have been there, because atm Summer is the only "normal" LI, but something is about to happen (cue in the animated scene at the end of the update, something that need the MC not present on the scene.
- At the same time the update wasn't big, they give the players 3 alternatives, 2 lead to a sex scene the 3rd doesn't... they would have upset a lot of the supporters
So players get some sexy time on screen no matter the choice taken, but allows to keep story progression going.
Yeah but that just sucks lol
Its obvious that the dev needed summer alone in her room on all paths but the way he chose to arrive at that destination was just fucked up.
Its not even about sex, but its simply very stupid and an asshole move to NOT sleep in her room with her when youre on her path imo.
She sobered up while they walked 3 (!) hours back, she was the whole time very frightened and was close to begging the mc to stay in her room with her, no matter if sex was involved it would have been the right thing to do to appease her mind and calm her down.
Instead the mc is like: "Nah, we need sleep, cya tomorrow, im in my room." like .. what?! This would even be a terrible excuse if they indeed had something important the next day in the morning (like a work appointment or whatever) but they are at a FUCKING FESTIVAL yeez. Who cant sleep in a room with a girl on a festival because he "needs sleep".
The housing situation is very odd in general lol
So in the end it feels super artifical, out of place, out of character and just heartless, insensitive and dumb at the same time. Fucking killjoy. The MC can get killed with all the other bitches for all i care, i was kinda annoyed that he left summer alone in the house in the morning already to talk with the backstabbing bitch outside and than he just keeps being fucked in the head. Summer should have let her parents pick her up lol