VN Ren'Py Abandoned E.X.P.E.L.L.E.D [v0.1.4] [HopeEsth]

3.30 star(s) 3 Votes

hopesth

Newbie
Game Developer
Apr 5, 2019
17
26
Opinions...
Note, I am just one man, other people will disagree with me and that's fine.
  • Another incest game... /yahn
  • Player named main character. Warning sign of a generic main character. So generic that the default name is MC LOLOLOL.
  • Writing early on, while mostly proper, feels amateur. Sentences feel very awkward to read at times. Feels like English might be a second language.
  • Some missing punctuation, a few misspellings and run on sentences.
  • Substitute mother character feels in character. Good job. Mom waking you up was an immersive scene. Make the other scenes feel like that.
  • Main character looks good. Little old for a high school student though.
  • Would a teenager who has been expelled from a school have this much confidence? To me this reads as unbelievable and ruins immersion. IS MC the high school quarterback? Why does he have so much confidence? Normally teenagers don't have this much confidence.
  • Wait MC has a ton of confidence, looks sexy, but is a virgin. Something doesn't add up right.
  • This teenager Violet has tits that are to big for her body. Not only are her tits to big her body is to thick. This is not a teenager.
  • What is the point of portraying youth in high school when you make everyone look old? Why not make this college where the body types would be more natural? Ohhh you want to play on innocence, but then you should make them look younger... You can't have it both ways IMO.
  • Personally I like to see all shapes and sizes, I want to see a teenager who is petite with small breasts, but I want to also see a thick voluptuous women. When you look around in life you don't see only one body size for women.
  • The MC's dick is exaggerated and huge. I'm not saying it has normal sized but when it's this big it looks dumb to me.
  • Adopted mom saying HUGE dick makes women happy. That makes me think the creator of this game hasn't actually talked to women in real life. That is a cliche that mostly is not true. Talk to dudes with a big dick or women... It's one thing to have big dicks, it's another to worship them in the dialogue.
  • Demo is super short.
I like high school games but this one doesn't read as believable for me. They don't act young, they don't look young, and it just doesn't feel immersive me to.

Ways to fix this?
  • I think the writing needs to be edited so sentences are easier to read and are error free.
  • Bodies can stay the same, though personally I would change them to look younger for being teenagers.
  • I think the character development needs to be fixed. MC and Violet don't read as believable characters.
  • Have a direction for the game. What is the point of playing, trying to graduate?
At this stage I guess I'm at a 2/5. It has potential but I don't feel like anything is immersive. Note this being a demo, it is the perfect time to fix mistakes before there is to much fix. With some fixes to make characters believable then this could easily jump into the 4/5.
I am really thankful for the feedback, I will work on a few things and this was the point of the Demo, so I can see the opinions and make a few changes before going for the game as it should be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zurrlock

Nelythia

Active Member
Donor
Oct 11, 2018
589
985
I was also wondering if you could tell us about planned tags for future content.
Creampies, pregnancy or other stuff, what will and will not be introduced during the development.
 

XJ347

Member
Sep 19, 2017
408
1,380
Damn was there ANYTHING you liked?:oops:
Yeah. The adopted mother waking up the main character made me feel like she was a mom. That scene shows SOOOO much potential. She looks good overall, and here a thicker character makes sense being in her late 30's early 40's. Saying that I still think the main character needs to be fleshed out in that scene. Why is he so fit but is a gamer? I personally would change the reason he stayed up so late was football practice. That football status would also explain why he has so much confidence.
 

Laziness

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2018
1,501
2,077
Decent start.
Also I like that the caretaker is an older sister and not just slotted into the 'mom' role.
 

PoEbalu

Well-Known Member
Apr 27, 2017
1,022
1,853
lost his parents
did he lost them at the fair ?they fell in to manhole while taking a walk never to be seen again ?
really,getting tired from this "lost his parents" crap,almost as much as with step-shit
 

Camel

Member
Jun 8, 2017
397
524
when i was 16 dated a 15 year old gal named Penny..and her tits were bigger than Violet's..so that is not unrealistic.
i remember back when i was 12 there was a girl in the grade below who grew giant breasts like out of nowhere... she must have been atleast a C and at only 10-11(none of the female teachers/staff at school stacked up to her atleast), she was a bit short too so until she gained some height like a year+ later she looked kinda funny when she came bouncing, she was fit back then too so it was like every little bit of fat she took in poured right into her chest and made her body to chest ratio look very disproportional.

i also remember flipping past the ricki lake show back in the 90s and seeing supposedly 13-15yo girls who looked like 25yo trailer trash. some even looked older than their moms that where with them

tl;dr... girls come in all shapes and sizes and some fill out very early on life and others later
 

Jeepster

Active Member
Apr 17, 2018
689
451
First i would like to take the time to say --- someone is going to make alots of girls happier ?? Huh... Nop comes with an E. But besides alot of weird sentences that you have to read over again. (needs alot of work) :cautious: Thank god different Actors!!! Kudos on that. and my SIS -- The Nipples!!! o_O:giggle:
 

patrickB

Active Member
Dec 23, 2017
934
1,318
Yeah. The adopted mother waking up the main character made me feel like she was a mom. That scene shows SOOOO much potential. She looks good overall, and here a thicker character makes sense being in her late 30's early 40's. Saying that I still think the main character needs to be fleshed out in that scene. Why is he so fit but is a gamer? I personally would change the reason he stayed up so late was football practice. That football status would also explain why he has so much confidence.
Nah, for that much confidence he must be a rugby player for sure :cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: XJ347

XJ347

Member
Sep 19, 2017
408
1,380
when i was 16 dated a 15 year old gal named Penny..and her tits were bigger than Violet's..so that is not unrealistic.
I will say this and then drop the subject.

A 15 year old with DD tits who isn't fat is SUPPER RARE. Is it possible? Yes. If you are implying that it is common for 15 year olds to have tits this big, then I am here to tell you that you are objectively wrong. Most people in the world on average don't have big tits. America being an exception but that is more due to obesity. So I think it's unrealistic to have every teenager have big breasts. Thing is I wouldn't complain if it was just one character, but every character has the same body.

I get that this is a style choice, but I am saying for me, that style choice makes me less interested in the game. Others will like the game more with that style, and the creator has to decide who he wants to please. There is no right or wrong choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CSNRC

danman87

Newbie
Mar 17, 2019
56
56
"is a game about the MC (Main Character) that lost his parents when he was younger and now is living with his 2 friends that are daughters from his mom's best friend. The older girl is Claire and is more strict and there is Violet the younger one which is more daring."

Sounds original. I'll pass.
 

UncleVT

Låt den rätta komma in
Moderator
Jul 2, 2017
9,438
102,053
No, it isn't super rare and yes, there are so much girls in the world with big tits and not fat. I think you reason is obnubilate by your tastes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rythan25

ThunderRob

Devoted Member
May 10, 2018
9,497
26,590
just be happy you are getting free games from a pirate site...her breasts are not abnormally large like many games..they are well within the range 18 year(which we have to assume is her age due to the game needing to be "legal" everywhere) olds would have..and being from Canada..in the humongous city of Toronto..i normally see large breasted 18-20 year olds walking around in tiny tops in the summer...and Canada is one of the lowest number of breast enhancement countries around..most of it is natural..and they are usually slim...they are of course not the majority..but they are common enough to not cause a ruckus among the serfs...i also lived in the U.S for 7 years..and the huge boobed gals i saw mostly were chubby..LOL...(Kentucky is made of gravy and bisquits..true story)
 

HorizonD

Well-Known Member
Apr 25, 2018
1,747
1,317
I was wondering when Adoptive Mom/Sis is looking if you are asleep, you have boxers on and next scene boxers have gone with that hard on... Boxers exploded? Did she strip you?
 

ThunderRob

Devoted Member
May 10, 2018
9,497
26,590
I was wondering when Adoptive Mom/Sis is looking if you are asleep, you have boxers on and next scene boxers have gone with that hard on... Boxers exploded? Did she strip you?
Quantum Realm boxers...they shrink when the need is there..look for a tiny speck on his peepee..those are his boxers :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: wrathofthedragon

jamdan

Forum Fanatic
Sep 28, 2018
4,366
23,440
Has some potential. One minor thing though, at the school MC says Mia is his roommate from class. That should be classmate or friend. "Mia is my classmate" or "Mia is my friend from class" .
 

Stickymicky

Newbie
Sep 30, 2017
59
281
Opinions...
Note, I am just one man, other people will disagree with me and that's fine.
  • Another incest game... /yahn
  • Player named main character. Warning sign of a generic main character. So generic that the default name is MC LOLOLOL.
  • Writing early on, while mostly proper, feels amateur. Sentences feel very awkward to read at times. Feels like English might be a second language.
  • Some missing punctuation, a few misspellings and run on sentences.
  • Substitute mother character feels in character. Good job. Mom waking you up was an immersive scene. Make the other scenes feel like that.
  • Main character looks good. Little old for a high school student though.
  • Would a teenager who has been expelled from a school have this much confidence? To me this reads as unbelievable and ruins immersion. IS MC the high school quarterback? Why does he have so much confidence? Normally teenagers don't have this much confidence.
  • Wait MC has a ton of confidence, looks sexy, but is a virgin. Something doesn't add up right.
  • This teenager Violet has tits that are to big for her body. Not only are her tits to big her body is to thick. This is not a teenager.
  • What is the point of portraying youth in high school when you make everyone look old? Why not make this college where the body types would be more natural? Ohhh you want to play on innocence, but then you should make them look younger... You can't have it both ways IMO.
  • Personally I like to see all shapes and sizes, I want to see a teenager who is petite with small breasts, but I want to also see a thick voluptuous women. When you look around in life you don't see only one body size for women.
  • The MC's dick is exaggerated and huge. I'm not saying it has normal sized but when it's this big it looks dumb to me.
  • Adopted mom saying HUGE dick makes women happy. That makes me think the creator of this game hasn't actually talked to women in real life. That is a cliche that mostly is not true. Talk to dudes with a big dick or women... It's one thing to have big dicks, it's another to worship them in the dialogue.
  • Demo is super short.
I like high school games but this one doesn't read as believable for me. They don't act young, they don't look young, and it just doesn't feel immersive me to.

Ways to fix this?
  • I think the writing needs to be edited so sentences are easier to read and are error free.
  • Bodies can stay the same, though personally I would change them to look younger for being teenagers.
  • I think the character development needs to be fixed. MC and Violet don't read as believable characters.
  • Have a direction for the game. What is the point of playing, trying to graduate?
At this stage I guess I'm at a 2/5. It has potential but I don't feel like anything is immersive. Note this being a demo, it is the perfect time to fix mistakes before there is to much fix. With some fixes to make characters believable then this could easily jump into the 4/5.
In all honesty i think the first thought behind the concept of this "Game" wasn't if the story would make sense but more "What is the minimal amount of effort i would have to put into this to get patreon subs"
 

Zurrlock

Member
May 13, 2018
335
223
I will say this and then drop the subject.

A 15 year old with DD tits who isn't fat is SUPPER RARE. Is it possible? Yes. If you are implying that it is common for 15 year olds to have tits this big, then I am here to tell you that you are objectively wrong. Most people in the world on average don't have big tits. America being an exception but that is more due to obesity. So I think it's unrealistic to have every teenager have big breasts. Thing is I wouldn't complain if it was just one character, but every character has the same body.

I get that this is a style choice, but I am saying for me, that style choice makes me less interested in the game. Others will like the game more with that style, and the creator has to decide who he wants to please. There is no right or wrong choice.
Had a girl in my class that was both, she was fat when puberty set in, grew huge tits, then the tits gave her confidence to slim up, turned into a huge-titted babe at 15, though her friend and mom was also big in the chest department. Her friend was always slim, but got B+ cups around the same time out of nowhere at 14, that just grew in what seemed a cup size a year. Third girl in the class didn't get a lot in the chest department, being a sporty tomboy, but got an ass more amazing in terms of proprotion to the rest of her than essentially any I've seen since outside of plastic surgery.

Yes I said third girl, because there was only three girls in my class, because I come from a pissant island (most mountainous island in the northern hemisphere compared to its size = it's a rock sticking out of the ocean) in northern norway, and there were seven students total in the class, five in the class after us (no girls), and just two students in that next class, one a girl (unsurprisingly, the school shut down a couple of years later). And that one girl two classes down had tits bigger than either one of the big-titted girls in my class, even when she was younger than them, and like the second girl she was always slim and practially elfin until she looked like a barbie girl.

That's northern Norway for you, just a few stragglers eking out an existence clinging to the side of a mountain, of course you'd have some damn good genes around then.

(Not denying it isn't super rare, just disputing the "only fat" and America specifically being an exception.)
 

voyeurkind

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2018
1,195
1,705
* When entering the name, it might be a god idea to specify that ten is the maximum number of characters

* The dialogue is a little stilted, but mostly fine.

* Maybe a little more furniture in the kitchen.

* Violet looks a little young.

* I like Violet

* The banter between the MC and Violet would work better if the English was better. It jut feels forced.

* It would be good to shift aro-und the models' poses more frequently.

Overall not terrible, but I'm not that excited about it either. The stilted English hurts it a lot, alo[ng with it's similarity to so many other games. I've seen much worse, but wee'll see how this plays out.
 
3.30 star(s) 3 Votes