Joe Steel

Engaged Member
Jan 10, 2018
2,611
3,621
416
It is endlessly amusing to me to see people moan about Crush because he makes more money from his Patreon account than the moaners think he should. It is even more amusing when pointing out the fact that 80% of the last 20 reviews of his game were unfavorable means that one is accused of being an "absolutely dedicated [defender] who will go to bat for him!"

I doubt that there is a person on this forum that doesn't think that Crush deserves criticism for his inconsistent development decisions and abysmal development pace. The only actual controversy here is whether or not he makes too much money on Patreon.
 

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
It is endlessly amusing to me to see people moan about Crush because he makes more money from his Patreon account than the moaners think he should. It is even more amusing when pointing out the fact that 80% of the last 20 reviews of his game were unfavorable means that one is accused of being an "absolutely dedicated [defender] who will go to bat for him!"

I doubt that there is a person on this forum that doesn't think that Crush deserves criticism for his inconsistent development decisions and abysmal development pace. The only actual controversy here is whether or not he makes too much money on Patreon.
That did not answer my question--I guess you can't or won't--but I am pleased that you are amused. I suppose if you had a real answer, you would say it plainly, instead of trying to guess at what other people are thinking or feeling, but maybe you never say anything plainly. I mean, you could just ask if you really wanted to know. I don't hide things. Still, maybe you enjoy expressing contempt for others, but have a difficult time finding an outlet.

And no, I don't believe that people deserve more money than Crush for trying and failing to adhere to a decent schedule in game development. That guess was wrong on your part, but maybe being wrong does not bother you much. Instead, I will always consistently praise Crush for knowing how to keep a Patreon audience enthralled. They seem to like what he does, and I won't blame him for having that skill. The fact that certain others both lack that skill and cannot develop on schedule means that Crush has at least one significant skill that they lack.

Still, do you want to defend other creators? Some others might need it if you do. I will say that trying to find positives in Crush's situation has potential parallels in the situation of others. Maybe there is a positive explanation for them as well.
 
Last edited:

Joe Steel

Engaged Member
Jan 10, 2018
2,611
3,621
416
That did not answer my question--I guess you can't or won't--but I am pleased that you are amused. I suppose if you had a real answer, you would say it plainly, instead of trying to guess at what other people are thinking or feeling, but maybe you never say anything plainly. I mean, you could just ask if you really wanted to know. I don't hide things. Still, maybe you enjoy expressing contempt for others, but have a difficult time finding an outlet.

And no, I don't believe that people deserve more money than Crush for trying and failing to adhere to a decent schedule in game development. That guess was wrong on your part, but maybe being wrong does not bother you much. Instead, I will always consistently praise Crush for knowing how to keep a Patreon audience enthralled. They seem to like what he does, and I won't blame him for having that skill. The fact that certain others both lack that skill and cannot develop on schedule means that Crush has at least one significant skill that they lack.

Still, do you want to defend other creators? Some others might need it if you do. I will say that trying to find positives in Crush's situation has potential parallels in the situation of others. Maybe there is a positive explanation for them as well.
Your question was "However, why not defend them?" It begs the question, of course of whether or not I do "defend them." I cannot answer that because I don't know what "defend them" even means. I do point out logical fallacies and made-up data wherever I encounter it, so if I am defending Crush here I defend all developers I follow everywhere.

I have no idea what "if you had a real answer, you would say it plainly" even means. Maybe you should work on "saying plainly" what your question is, if you really wanted to know.

I don't know why you bring up your lack of belief that "people deserve more money than Crush for trying and failing to adhere to a decent schedule in game development." I don't even understand what that means, despite your claim that that was my guess. I didn't guess anything. I simply noted some facts. You keep saying that I "guess things" and then guess that "maybe {I} enjoy expressing contempt for others, but have a difficult time finding an outlet!" :ROFLMAO:You will find, if you actually read my posts, that what I express "contempt for" is arguments without merit. Like the one I quoted in the line above.
 

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
Your question was "However, why not defend them?" It begs the question, of course of whether or not I do "defend them." I cannot answer that because I don't know what "defend them" even means. I do point out logical fallacies and made-up data wherever I encounter it, so if I am defending Crush here I defend all developers I follow everywhere.

I have no idea what "if you had a real answer, you would say it plainly" even means. Maybe you should work on "saying plainly" what your question is, if you really wanted to know.

I don't know why you bring up your lack of belief that "people deserve more money than Crush for trying and failing to adhere to a decent schedule in game development." I don't even understand what that means, despite your claim that that was my guess. I didn't guess anything. I simply noted some facts. You keep saying that I "guess things" and then guess that "maybe {I} enjoy expressing contempt for others, but have a difficult time finding an outlet!" :ROFLMAO:You will find, if you actually read my posts, that what I express "contempt for" is arguments without merit. Like the one I quoted in the line above.
So you didn't understand my posts. That is too bad. And you are referring to your speculations as facts, which might just explain why you can't understand others' posts. How can such assertions have merit? I therefore don't believe what you just said. With all that going on, I see no reason why you appear to feel a sense of entitlement **ooo there's that word again** to express contempt for others.
 
Last edited:

lordrango

Newbie
Aug 29, 2018
91
321
119
It is endlessly amusing to me to see people moan about Crush because he makes more money from his Patreon account than the moaners think he should. It is even more amusing when pointing out the fact that 80% of the last 20 reviews of his game were unfavorable means that one is accused of being an "absolutely dedicated [defender] who will go to bat for him!"

I doubt that there is a person on this forum that doesn't think that Crush deserves criticism for his inconsistent development decisions and abysmal development pace. The only actual controversy here is whether or not he makes too much money on Patreon.
I would say this is not in any way correct representation of what's happening.

I don't care how much money he's making. It could be 1$ or 5,000$, that's irrelevant. All the people who give him money are, presumably, adults who do it of their own volition. What I do care about is that new people should be aware of the status of development. If there's another game on this scope, I sure wish other people would raise enough ruckus to make me pay attention to it. If after that I still want to contribute money, well, that's my choice. I've been warned aplenty.

Considering your other points, regarding reviews - well just the fact that the majority of recent reviews are negative, if it is indeed true what was reported, that he's going around trying to take down negative reviews, and even encouraging his fans to do it, that's very dishonest practice, regardless of how successful it is. I sincerely hope that's not true, because it is utterly despicable if it is.
 

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
Hey we've seen that someone besides Crush can report something now. Since our boy can't provide a coherent rejection of what others are saying, he decided to report spam.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrZack

Joe Steel

Engaged Member
Jan 10, 2018
2,611
3,621
416
Hey we've seen that someone besides Crush can report something now. Since our boy can't provide a coherent rejection of what others are saying, he decided to report spam.
Who is your boy, what did he report, and to whom? And why do we care what your boy reports?
 

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
Who is your boy, what did he report, and to whom? And why do we care what your boy reports?
You seem to be very much concerned about this. Maybe you have more info than I do. I hadn't seen a peep from you since something deleted your hilarious post earlier (at least someone appreciates your talents--if philosophy can ever truly go beyond rationalism, something beyond the rational must be used). But let's answer questions!

I don't know who our boy is, but I think he must be a boy.

He reported posts that were certainly off-topic. Other off-topic posts remain, but I would like to remind everyone that moderators are unpaid as far as I know. Yet, can anything ever truly be off-topic when it is the topic of fascination for the most frequent viewers of this thread? Whoever is reporting, is asking people to work without pay, shameful!

You seem to care a lot. Maybe you know why? I don't know why you care, but others seemed to care about what Crush reports. I wanted to point out that Crush is not the only one who reports. I checked. The account that claims to be Crushstation has not been here since Thursday.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: D4n0w4r
Apr 3, 2019
341
1,073
284
My post was deleted, yet that didn't improve the game. :unsure:

Proving the point of my then deleted post.

I won't argue against deleting those posts, they don't add that much to the thread.

But with that said, the metric for what counts as "off topic" (as that's the reason for deletion) is a bit skewed. Surely "off topic" is more supposed to cover situations where instead of talking about the game and the context surrounding it, people are talking about sports or politics or whatever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrZack

TheMathmos

Newbie
Jun 25, 2018
95
154
140
As with the deleted reviews, and my deleted post regarding said deleted reviews, what's off topic seems really one-sided. Some classy reporting going on (y)

This thread, the Malice and the Machine one, any topic about Star Citizen, there's something magical each and every time I come to visit. Sunk losses is a hell of a drug.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrZack

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
I'm fairly sure that there are more deleted posts than surviving posts in the thread. This and lateness seem to be the most memorable and currently fascinating aspects of the game.

Looking at other games, there are often posts from players who either need help or are reporting a bug, but that doesn't happen much here. This and the vast number of other contrasts with other games are what keep me interested. Plus, what other thread has such tragicomic conflict? If it was just another slowly developed game, and many of those exist, the conversation wouldn't be so fascinating to me. I'm not sure what else there is to say about the game that is strictly on-topic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrZack

MrZack

Member
Feb 24, 2020
153
367
195
I won't argue against deleting those posts, they don't add that much to the thread.

But with that said, the metric for what counts as "off topic" (as that's the reason for deletion) is a bit skewed. Surely "off topic" is more supposed to cover situations where instead of talking about the game and the context surrounding it, people are talking about sports or politics or whatever.
My deleted one was about how deleting reviews won't make the game better and that the developer should focus on the game itself instead of the critics, after all if dev made a good game he wouldn't need to worry about hiding bad reviews.

How is that "off topic"?
 
  • Like
Reactions: afc2112 and rbx4

Joe Steel

Engaged Member
Jan 10, 2018
2,611
3,621
416
You seem to be very much concerned about this.
:ROFLMAO: I am not concerned at all. I was asking what your opaque post was about. Clearly, you either cannot or will not answer the question.

He reported posts that were certainly off-topic. Other off-topic posts remain, but I would like to remind everyone that moderators are unpaid as far as I know. Yet, can anything ever truly be off-topic when it is the topic of fascination for the most frequent viewers of this thread? Whoever is reporting, is asking people to work without pay, shameful!
If your boy is reporting posts that are off-topic and it bothers you, you should probably take that up with your boy. I neither report posts nor moan when a moderator deletes my posts. I've moderated discussion boards and know how thankless it is. I appreciate moderators even when they delete my posts or reviews.

You seem to care a lot. Maybe you know why? I don't know why you care, but others seemed to care about what Crush reports. I wanted to point out that Crush is not the only one who reports. I checked. The account that claims to be Crushstation has not been here since Thursday.
I don't care much at all, let alone "a lot." Every one of these exchanges between us happens because you vaguely attack one of my posts and it's off topic. Maybe you should consider that it is the contents of your posts that causes them to be deleted, not some nefarious action by your boy whose identity and actions you are completely ignorant of. Take responsibility for your own posts rather than trying to shift the blame for their deletion onto some imaginary foe.

Of course, this exchange is as off-topic as the deleted ones, so read this while you can! ;)
 

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
:ROFLMAO: I am not concerned at all. I was asking what your opaque post was about. Clearly, you either cannot or will not answer the question.

If your boy is reporting posts that are off-topic and it bothers you, you should probably take that up with your boy. I neither report posts nor moan when a moderator deletes my posts. I've moderated discussion boards and know how thankless it is. I appreciate moderators even when they delete my posts or reviews.

I don't care much at all, let alone "a lot." Every one of these exchanges between us happens because you vaguely attack one of my posts and it's off topic. Maybe you should consider that it is the contents of your posts that causes them to be deleted, not some nefarious action by your boy whose identity and actions you are completely ignorant of. Take responsibility for your own posts rather than trying to shift the blame for their deletion onto some imaginary foe.

Of course, this exchange is as off-topic as the deleted ones, so read this while you can! ;)
I did answer the question, but as we have established, you cannot understand what people post. You have been waiting for over 24 hours to try to turn my words against me however. I was wondering how long it take you to make a fantasy world where you could. After all, people have been doing this exact same thing on the Internet and elsewhere for years now. Other people have ruined this approach for you, and it is an old hat now, sadly. Everything that you say is fully interchangeable with all the other Internet arguments where people try the exact same thing that you just tried. I was wondering whether you had a plan for this, but I guess the point is go to on forever just repeating what other people tell you, all in situations where they do not actually apply.

Still look under the part where I wrote this: "But let's answer questions!" I made it easy for you. For future reference: If you are looking for answers to questions, look for the phrase "answer questions" and keep reading. I am happy to instruct you on such matters, and I hope that you can do better in the future.

I am of course fully responsible for my own posts. I like posting this, and I was amused when our boy did what was obviously going to happen sooner or later. You seem to be wishing for grief, but our boy generated amusement instead. May he spend even more time doing this, which can only generate additional amusement and can only make this topic more fascinating!

But I have a question! You seemed to be previously concerned with how I spend my time, as if I thought that I could convince Crush to do something differently. That is of course not what I am trying to do. How can this be more important than other things that you may have to do? If you have other things to do that are more fascinating than this, then it is sad that you are pulled away from them for your apparent duties here.
 

TheDeviant

Member
Aug 7, 2017
150
359
223

Hey guys! I had a tough but productive week's writing. It's getting there! I expect the next episode will be ready to play sometime this month.
I'm finding that this stage of the story is pushing me outside my comfort zone as a writer. I'm not that emotional in real life, so I find it hard to hard to write about girly things like feelings and relationships. (I'd much rather write about guns and missions and safehouses.)
It's just a silly NSFW game, so I shouldn't have to care too much about that kind of thing, right? But I've learned that sexy scenes aren't actually that hot unless you dig into the emotional undertow of the scene, and try to capture some of the ways that sex changes how people tacitly interact.
For example, while writing the previous episode, I'd expected it would be enough to just strip the heroine down to a thong and stick her behind a bar. Topless girls are sexy, right?
But, in the end, the scene only started sparking when we started exploring her psychology and emotions about the experience, and how they developed through the night. Turns out that "topless girl" isn't what makes that scenario sexy, the truth is a lot more complex than that. I had to really push myself to capture some of it.
This time, I'm grappling with something similar; even though the plot developments are fairly straightforward, I'm having some challenges landing the emotional tone. (Which needs to be right at this stage, or it's going to be very hard to write the next big change in the story.)
But I made good progress this week! And I think it's a good sign when things are difficult, anyway. Byron said adversity is the first path to truth. I'm hopeful that having to operate outside my comfort zone is improving the game's writing somehow. Maybe it's even improving me as a person?

Okay, I'm going to rest my emotion circuits for the evening, and get back into the fight tomorrow. I'll report on progress again next week. Have a greta Sunday everybody! I love you all!
 

rbx4

Member
Jan 21, 2018
244
312
147
I always study Crush's posts, because I want to be successful like him too. In a perfect world I would be both productive and successful, but success should be able to increase what people do--and therefore success ought to lead to increased productivity. In contrast, one could say that high productivity ought to lead to success, but I must look elsewhere to study that possibility.

Studying this, it seems that there is emotion in his post. There is emphasis placed on points that should have impact. It is definitely relatable, and I wish there was something that could be done to help him overcome his struggles. The photo is nice. The grammar and spelling do not seem to be perfect, and therefore they are probably not necessities. Byron is quoted. Looks like Crush is in his comfort zone writing about guns, missions, and safe-houses, but he is also a good blog writer.
 

herrzimm1

Newbie
Jun 11, 2020
99
311
170
OMG! Did Crush actually admit that it has taken like 3-4 format variations, multiple start-reboot processes, countless hours of writing/reviewing/editing and countless hours of "conversations" with co-workers to just NOW understand that there is some kind of "emotional" element to the writing process in general?

That is like key Writing 101, no f*** that, that is something that is taught in basic grade-level class. Characters have emotions, writers express those emotions through text. And yeah, sometimes it is difficult to explore or express those emotions in an effective and entertaining method, they are still nothing 'new' to the process. To make it even more amazing to me is that there are actual word-types that convey emotional issues. Words like adverbs and adjectives come to mind to expression emotional states. Shame, blushing, meekly, or other words, can convey massive amounts of emotional issues for a character. Especially characters who are outside of their normal comfort level.

God, I'm going out of my mind right now with the amount of frustration that I am feeling from the latest post from Crush. And I don't even consider myself a "hobby-level writer". This "concern over emotions of character" crap just sounds like a massive stonewall of "future delay protection" being added now that the key issue of getting to Bangkok has been addressed. Now it is issues with new avatar features, issues with writing (that should have been clearly overcome after x-number of years working on this project), format changes, etc.etc. It just seems like every time that we get some kind of advancement in the story-line regarding location, we get 5-6 different reason why things will someone be "justified" in slowing down the amount of actual content.
 

Marlin Brandy

Member
Aug 18, 2018
353
764
275
reminder that the new rework was meant to speed up development. it'd be interesting to compare old FA's progress after its first year and how much further we're at with MFAGA

Edit:
There is an argument to be made that his current slow writing pace is the fault of none other than D4n0w4r :KEK:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Case closed, Watson!
 
Last edited:

D4n0w4r

Member
May 21, 2020
383
1,328
309
reminder that the new rework was meant to speed up development. it'd be interesting to compare old FA's progress after its first year and how much further we're at with MFAGA

Edit:
There is an argument to be made that his current slow writing pace is the fault of none other than D4n0w4r :KEK:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Case closed, Watson!
The road to hell truly is paved by good intentions. :illuminati:
 
3.50 star(s) 126 Votes