Before reading, please know that I rate this game 4.5 stars - it's at 5 because we round up here!
The Good
The animations are phenomenal. I used the 60fps video enhancement from
F4iunyl3x - found there. It really was great - and looking at the examples from 30-60fps, the 30fps animations still look great. This game really has top notch animations, which I put in very high regard.
The renders are fantastic - some of the girls (I'm talking about you, Sue and Alyssa) are absolutely stunning!
The story is interesting. I read that people find it a bit hard to follow/it doesn't make sense - however, it's an AVN - and, in my opinion, the story is just fine.
Finally, the voice acting. This was added in season 02, and I see it has a lot of mixed opinions. I, for one, think it is refreshing and great. For chapter 02, turn on auto mode, change your auto-text speed to something a little quicker, sit back, drink a Dr. Pepper, and ENJOY! It plays like a movie!
The soundtrack is great! So nice to have games with music.
The Bad
The animations become more prevalent the further you go through the game, so this isn't really a "bad" thing - however, I wish some of the early scenes were like the ones in season 02. However, if this is the standard going forward, then it will be awesome!
Honestly, it's hard to find bad things with this game. The grammar is good, the writing is good - I guess the only gripe on this topic that I can give is that sometimes the text seems jumbled and it's a bit hard to follow - you will likely understand if you play the game. However, a vast majority of the game is crystal clear, and this is only a very small problem.
The Ugly
There is none - nothing in this game is so awful that I thought it was ugly and needed to leave. The story seems like a classic AVN college story - however, it quickly moves away from the classic "me see landlady (in this case you aren't actually related!) me like landlady me make love" that seems so prevalent in so many games here.
TL;DR
Play the game! The animations are great, the renders are top-notch, and the writing is easy to follow. Enjoy the game, don't get hung up on the miniscule problems, and have fun!