There was never a choice, except in a reeeeally early draft. But only a handful of people have read that one.
It's something I might want to add at a later date. Like, once the game is fully wrapped I could see adding it to the love path, and as a result getting a few extra scenes with Gabby. Originally I wanted a scene where you tell Gabby, and instead of going no-contact with you in Chapter Four: Part One, she meets up with you and hides out from Madison, and you can try to explain Madison's side of the story, or use it to drive a wedge between them.
But, due to the serialized nature of this thing, sometimes I have to make choices to streamline stuff. Otherwise I could sit around for months fine-tuning things and going down rabbit holes.