The NTR feedback has been great, and again I do not plan on any. The one rape scene I have in here I have even wondered if I should keep it in, or change/remove it even before releasing it here. Thoughts?
Some people like it and some don't
If you want to write scenes that depict it then that's fine but don't force yourself to as it will just come across as lackluster and piss off both sides
Same can be said about rape as some would be fine with it though you get more into the semantics of what NTR is
however as a safe guard have the player be able to rescue the girl before anyone else sticks it in. Too many fantasies about rescuing damsels in distress I guess however it it sells why question what works. You could also simply set up Options for what fetishes people would like, see
Ravanger for an example, and use if statements to filter those out. Only thing is in follow up dialogue you have to take this into account else you get some whining about that happened and it just didn't show it. Attention to details helps improve the overall quality of the game in my opinion.
Navigation. OK. I was happy to see that I could build this type of navigation(again, I wanted to see what I could do with the Ren'py software). That being said, I am not sure I should have kept it this way (same goes for the simple currency system). I like telling stories and have wondered if I should take this into a more kinetic direction and simplify/nix the way navigation works and just focus on the story.
I didn't think the navigation was bad though it could be tweaked to make it more user friendly.
Some additional filler scenes and direction would help fill in the gaps.
Things like
You must be registered to see the links
so you can put in some idle chatter would help keep the scenes fresher longer. Have these be overridden by important guide events like go to the Guild on X day to pick up work, maybe go to the Tavern on Y for supplies, and other hint messages to let the player know there are things to do in town.
Of course you could cut that out in favor of a more straight and narrow path like before the Open World section comes up. Both Standard VN and Open World have their pros and cons.