LOL, I decided to load a previous save, because apparently I missed a scene with Arya, which she mentioned as if it happened. But the game just restarts itself back to day one, I lost every single item and progression, even though the save is clearly there. I just started playing this game btw.
Edit: After testing, I see that none of my 2 pages of saves load at all. They all restart the game back to day 1 without any progression, even if I load them from the Main Menu.
* The only way to keep playing the game and saving, is by using QUICKSAVES. These actually keep progress and load as any regular save should. I hope this helps anyone that's having the same problem. I tried editing a regular save's name to a quicksave, but it doesn't work. So the better option is to restart and always save the game with the limited number of quicksaves.
Edit2: Well, even though quicksaves work, they are a mess and sometimes don't overwrite each other, so there's that too.