Malicre

Well-Known Member
Oct 23, 2018
1,294
2,229
Hehe, I understand that! But that's why I said I agree with almost nothing else, because for me, Amy & Liz are clearly the two best girls of the game!
My great tier is still really good, those are my favorite girls in the game, Amy is just on another level and if this wasn't a harem game she would of been the one i would of chosen that's why she's in my GODLIKE tier.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Mick

Malicre

Well-Known Member
Oct 23, 2018
1,294
2,229
Agreed, but outside of that tier I don't agree with you on much.
Yeah a lot of people won't like my tier list because i don't like the asian duo and the reason for is simple just because those are the only two the game forces on you. You can decline every other female (i double checked) except for those two and it irked me pretty bad.
 

Dr. Mick

Formerly 'Mickademous'
Nov 21, 2017
218
431
Just played threw all 4 parts and here is my tier list and yes Amy is absolutely the best girl, no doubt about it.
View attachment 3918929
Sure is nice that we have this forum to share our opinions on this great VN.
This is certainly an interesting ranking, and will most likely make for a lot of discussion.
I'd be curious about what criteria you used to come to your result.

I would make about eighteen changes if I were doing the same ranking, and it's intriguing to see how people's opinions differ.
It's fun to compare what we like, and don't, about the different characters in this title.
 

txe320

Active Member
Dec 4, 2023
944
2,241
Yeah a lot of people won't like my tier list because i don't like the asian duo and the reason for is simple just because those are the only two the game forces on you. You can decline every other female (i double checked) except for those two and it irked me pretty bad.
Actually, no, they're seven of them you can't decline; Nana, Aunt Liz, Aunt Amy, Cat, Jamila, Shizuka and Asami.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoonBox and Malicre

Malicre

Well-Known Member
Oct 23, 2018
1,294
2,229
Actually, no, they're seven of them you can't decline; Nana, Aunt Liz, Aunt Amy, Cat, Jamila, Shizuka and Asami.
Really? All of those had a "start path options". I obviously didn't play threw the game choosing the non path routes for those girls because they are good characters but i didn't know that they automatically opened even past the first "open path" options.
 

txe320

Active Member
Dec 4, 2023
944
2,241
Really? All of those had a "start path options". I obviously didn't play threw the game choosing the non path routes for those girls because they are good characters but i didn't know that they automatically opened even past the first "open path" options.
That does nothing, the option to reject them was abandoned very, very early in game, they are the 7 main LIs and you can't say no to them, no matter what.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malicre

Adhdclassic

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2024
1,435
2,048
Just played threw all 4 parts and here is my tier list and yes Amy is absolutely the best girl, no doubt about it.

View attachment 3918929
I would replace Catherine, Sophia, and Mila to great. Elizabeth and Molly to godlike. Svetlana, Paveena, Isabella, Lina and Brandi which is not on your list to garbage. O'reilly Twins and Minnie to good. Petunia fuck out of her category. :ROFLMAO: I will agree Amy stay right where she is. Grandma is so sweet I would put her in the eternal category.
 
  • Like
  • Red Heart
Reactions: MoonBox and Malicre

Malicre

Well-Known Member
Oct 23, 2018
1,294
2,229
I'd be curious about what criteria you used to come to your result.
For me older women, milfs and/or badass girls (aka fiona) are always better then the younger ones but that's just my preference obviously and the reason why i rate Amy so high is because that's the kind of women i would actually try to date in real life (career driven, sophisticated, dark past, hot, older, curvy, it hits all my checkboxes).

I actually didn't like cat all that much early on because of the hardcore jealousy issues but she got better and while i usually don't like the younger ones, you really can't have liz without her and while she didn't make it to the same tier as grandma, liz and them she's still a good character just not one of my favorites.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Adhdclassic
3.80 star(s) 293 Votes