Oh, and as a fan request:
I think Scarlet deserves a sweet, cute, cuddly (first time) sex event;
The women that have lived on the island are more 'open' about the traditions, so it makes sense they'll go:
"I want you to fuck me!"
But it might be more natural that the sweet and innocent Scarlet, might prefer a more calm, safe sexual experience?
No talking: No "I want you to be my first" or "Please be careful, it's my first time";
Just an evening full of gaming, where the cuddling grows into something more. No need for words.
Just having a good time and it kind of just happens.
Perhaps Scarlet's been hyped about a new RPG that's coming out, our Protagonist manages to get a copy, surprises her with it, and whilst playing the game she realizes that after all the abuse she endured, she finally found someone that makes her truly happy?
It would still fit in the BDSM theme, since Scarlet seems to be able to seperate her BDSM-side from her more compassionate, innocent side.