c3p0

Conversation Conqueror
Respected User
Nov 20, 2017
7,020
16,382
Haven't used one of these in a while...

Hard to say, we don't know how many more scenes he is planning to add.
Soupe with fairy flavour.
If that isn't enough you can then season it more with crushed dry fairy wing powder.;)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TheDevian

ZenoMod

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2022
1,372
1,691
That brings me to another point, you can't have more than one copy of the game on your pc, at least on the same profile, as they will try to use the same folder in AppData, and the persistent file will not like the older one.

This Ren'Py feature is utterly annoying. More than a feature, I would call it "a bug by design".

It creates more problems than it solves. That transparently overwriting the persisten file is demential. It should at least prompt for confirmation.

Even better, there should be a native way to keep persistent files separate for different releases.

How could the Ren'Py developers not foresee that many players would like to be able to have more releases of a game on the same computer?
 
Jul 16, 2024
79
179
This Ren'Py feature is utterly annoying. More than a feature, I would call it "a bug by design".
There are ways around it, but it requires the developer to deal with it.

For example, using the slotname callback ( ), which was added a couple of years ago, and mixing that with a regexp when listing saves or slots. The other options are more complex, but revolve around swapping the config.save_directory value.

But it does require the developer to implement it, because anything more complex than a basic 'save' option requires a lot more work.

As it applies to Harem Hotel beta releases, it's not really worth Runey's time/effort. If someone wrote a workable solution, and stuck it up for everyone to use, then maybe it'd find its way into testing patterns for games, but there's little point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZenoMod

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
15,420
36,490
This Ren'Py feature is utterly annoying. More than a feature, I would call it "a bug by design".

It creates more problems than it solves. That transparently overwriting the persisten file is demential. It should at least prompt for confirmation.

Even better, there should be a native way to keep persistent files separate for different releases.

How could the Ren'Py developers not foresee that many players would like to be able to have more releases of a game on the same computer?
If they would remove the AppData folder crap, it would not be a problem, but then players might have to learn to not delete their saves, and I guess that is too hard.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ZenoMod

ZenoMod

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2022
1,372
1,691
If they would remove the AppData folder crap, it would not be a problem, but then players might have to learn to not delete their saves, and I guess that is too hard.

LoL... People still lose their saves nonetheless the AppData automatic backup, so... :HideThePain:
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: TheDevian

markus T

Engaged Member
Jun 11, 2017
3,085
3,583
LoL... People still lose their saves nonetheless the AppData automatic backup, so... :HideThePain:
I'm sure it does happen every once in a awhile. For example....Some times I purge my renpy save folder in the apdata and sometimes I forget about a certain game and it ends up being deleted with the rest. lets face it....that folder gets pretty hefty after awhile lol. I started saving my actual saves now instead of relying on the backups.
But I will say that probably 95% of the ppl claiming that they lost their saves are lying and just want an easy mode save so that they don't have to put the work in their self.
 

Incendax

Newbie
Dec 20, 2019
69
111
95% of the ppl claiming that they lost their saves are lying and just want an easy mode save so that they don't have to put the work in their self.
What usually happens for me is I delete everything to save space, then wait a dozen updates before downloading again / signing back up to Patreon. But I've never asked for saves. I just Skip/Fastforward the whole thing again. It admittedly gets pretty painful for longer games like Superhuman, or games with lots of clickable choices. I should really just keep manual saves somewhere!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian

grey_shadow

Member
May 21, 2022
182
177
Without the appdata saves, you'd need to do more work for players upgrading to a new version - the in-folder saves work if you can patch or overwrite the previous install, but you'd need to teach players how to manually transfer saves, or how to clean out old files, whenever you have a new version that isn't easily patched. And even if it can be done as a simple overwrite, you'd have to make sure players copy the new version over the old one properly rather than just hitting "extract here" and creating a new folder for the new version.

The appdata saves do introduce some downsides in some circumstances, but they also lower the barrier to entry for most use cases.
 

BIGEVIL45

Newbie
Apr 7, 2025
17
12
What happen to the 'What If' side stories like Ashley's wedding? I cant find them anywhere. They used to be in the computer in our room.
These will never come back. I asked and was told that they were fan requested and Runey dislikes them.
I am also loving these "Don't ask about updates" gifs and pics. Keep them up
 
Last edited:

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
15,420
36,490
Without the appdata saves, you'd need to do more work for players upgrading to a new version - the in-folder saves work if you can patch or overwrite the previous install, but you'd need to teach players how to manually transfer saves, or how to clean out old files, whenever you have a new version that isn't easily patched. And even if it can be done as a simple overwrite, you'd have to make sure players copy the new version over the old one properly rather than just hitting "extract here" and creating a new folder for the new version.

The appdata saves do introduce some downsides in some circumstances, but they also lower the barrier to entry for most use cases.
Yes, they would have to be responsible people, and copy over the save folder and screenshots like a normal person does (or even an Android user). If the phone people can learn to do it, surely anyone on a PC can learn to move a file.

Besides, anyone who depends on the backup save folder, is just asking for trouble. Something happen to windows, like a crash, and they are gone. Do you have any idea, how many times I have had to reinstall windows in the last 7 years since this game started? Be smart, keep things safe, not in a system folder.

Also, system folders are for system files, not games. All game stuff should go in the games folders/drives, where they belong. Makes things a lot easier to back up and transfer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fauno36 and ZenoMod

grey_shadow

Member
May 21, 2022
182
177
Yes, they would have to be responsible people, and copy over the save folder and screenshots like a normal person does (or even an Android user). If the phone people can learn to do it, surely anyone on a PC can learn to move a file.

Besides, anyone who depends on the backup save folder, is just asking for trouble. Something happen to windows, like a crash, and they are gone. Do you have any idea, how many times I have had to reinstall windows in the last 7 years since this game started? Be smart, keep things safe, not in a system folder.

Also, system folders are for system files, not games. All game stuff should go in the games folders/drives, where they belong. Makes things a lot easier to back up and transfer.
In 30 years, I don't think I've had to reinstall Windows except when getting a new computer or a new version of Windows. In that time, I've had 5 versions of Windows across 6 computers. Maybe don't do things that break Windows?

If you follow Microsoft's advice on what to store where, then game saves should be stored in My Documents somewhere, with game configuration settings stored in appdata - Windows isn't designed to have separate system and data drives, nor to encapsulate all the files for a given program in one location - instead, it assumes that you'll install the game's read-only files into Program Files, and split user data between appdata and My Documents.

As for getting users to save their save files from the previous version when they delete the install to free up space, remember where they put them, and move them into the new version when they install it, sure, you can tell them to do it, but there are a lot more people who want to just "extract all here" and then play the latest version of the game than there are who want to have multiple versions of the game playable independently.
 
4.70 star(s) 483 Votes