Puppet Master

Active Member
Aug 21, 2018
968
1,817
If Brenda is going to be "completed," there are some other basic scenes she needs:

Sauna scene
Yoga in the gym
Shower scene in the gym
Shower scene in her room
Visit her in her room after she's just gotten out of the shower
Play with her in the pool (maybe a topless scene like Lacey's)
Spy on her at the pool (sitting by the pool & maybe tanning topless)
Visit her at night in her lingerie
Search for Brenda's modeling photos (or content related sexts)

Yes, there's a lot that could still be done with her (ie. a blowjob scene as your maid), but these are the basic scenes and events that we've come to expect for every girl.
Have I missed any? Let me know.

Some scenes and events (sauna, shower in the gym, modeling pics, etc.) may be skipped, but if she doesn't have the basics, I fail to see how she could be considered completed.

Edit: Don't think that I'm insisting this should be added to the next update. The Creator will get to it whenever he wants. I just mean that Brenda won't be finished until she gets these scenes.

Edit2: I forgot to mention how great it is that Brenda is getting content!
 
Last edited:

DuckSwim

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2018
1,525
9,634
If Brenda is going to be "completed," there are some other basic scenes she needs:

Sauna scene
Yoga in the gym
Shower scene in the gym
Shower scene in her room
Visit her in her room after she's just gotten out of the shower
Play with her in the pool (maybe a topless scene like Lacey's)
Spy on her at the pool (sitting by the pool & maybe tanning topless)
Visit her at night in her lingerie
Search for Brenda's modeling photos (or content related sexts)

Yes, there's a lot that could still be done with her (ie. a blowjob scene as your maid), but these are the basic scenes and events that we've come to expect for every girl.
Have I missed any? Let me know.

Some scenes and events (sauna, shower in the gym, modeling pics, etc.) may be skipped, but if she doesn't have the basics, I fail to see how she could be considered completed.

Edit: Don't think that I'm insisting this should be added to the next update. The Creator will get to it whenever he wants. I just mean that Brenda won't be finished until she gets these scenes.

Edit2: I forgot to mention how great it is that Brenda is getting content!
Brenda will get what the (3 days old) Patreon post announcing it says she'll get.
So what you write here is player created expectations / not going to happen.

So she will, as announced, get content anno 2023 that is unique to her, instead of a copy of some other girl's old content. She'll be a lot happier for it.

And it is a good thing girls do not all do the same, because it'll kill the game (same for all takes years)

She will be completed once the announced content is done, which is by the next release, version 4.0.
 
Last edited:

Puppet Master

Active Member
Aug 21, 2018
968
1,817
Brenda will get what the (3 days old) Patreon post announcing it says she'll get.
So what you write here is player created expectations / not going to happen.

So she will, as announced, get content anno 2023 that is unique to her, instead of a copy of some other girl's old content. She'll be a lot happier for it.

And it is a good thing girls do not all do the same, because it'll kill the game (same for all takes years)

She will be completed once the announced content is done, which is by the next release, version 4.0.
As I said in my edit, I'm not calling for the creator to do anything he doesn't want to do.

However, the things in my list are what the other girls get, and Brenda should get as well.
You can say a girl is "completed" because she's not going to be worked on any more, but until those boxes are checked, there's room for growth.

As to your objections: the options each girl has aren't just a copy of each other girl's other options. Take playing in the pool, it's different for each girl, but that's the joy of the game. The little differences create variety which is what makes the game good.
I know you can sit with Brenda on the lounger, but she could be like Desire and have the lounger option as well as being able to play in the pool.

While I don't want "all girls doing the same," because I value the little differences in each scene. However, if every girl had a copy of the topless yoga poses to give them a yoga option, I have no idea how this would kill the game. Though perhaps I misinterpret your meaning here. Can you give an example?

I can see how filling in all of the blanks could take years, but the creator expects the game to take a long time to finish, and I don't mind waiting. If Brenda is "done for now" and might see more in future, that's all I want.

Anyhow, I hope I have courteously clarified my thoughts here. Know that I don't expect to influence the game, I just want to advance the discussion among the players.

Thank you for reading.
 

BDMick

Member
Nov 26, 2017
217
874
Here is a simple thing I would love to see in a future version of Holiday Island:

1689715231479.png

It would be great if the save file thumbnails were to show the game day (or even the time of day, additionally). E. g. in the upper right corner. Then you would not have to add that in the description yourself. I have hundreds of save files*. Most of them without that info in the description (my bad). It would make it so much easier to track which is which.

*No. Not one full save file and none to share.
 

xapican

Devoted Member
May 11, 2020
10,627
16,132
I have hundreds of save files*. Most of them without that info in the description (my bad). It would make it so much easier to track which is which.
Bwahahahaha,:ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: That been said, by the guy who keep track of all statistics of the game :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
You confirm, the old phrase, "In the blacksmiths house, you use wooden kifes" :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
abrazo !
*But your idea is good to be fair! ;)
 

Gatorsuf

Newbie
May 28, 2017
24
9
it's 2 when counting from 0 like the companion mod does.
I'll PM the save, but honestly I wouldn't be surprised if I hadn't just gotten super unlucky and my game files got corrupted when installing, might just need to do a redownload and install.
Did you ever get the second Amy at the beach bar scene to trigger? I got the first one no problem, but the second does not seem to trigger no matter how many times I try to quick load before going to the bar. Tried the coke and the flirt alternating and no success.
 

Bantry

Forum Fanatic
Oct 24, 2017
5,420
13,511
Did you ever get the second Amy at the beach bar scene to trigger? I got the first one no problem, but the second does not seem to trigger no matter how many times I try to quick load before going to the bar. Tried the coke and the flirt alternating and no success.
You are of course leaving ample time between attempts, right? What I mean is a number of days have passed, like maybe even a week. Same with time of day. The beach bar opens at 14:00hrs and closes at 18:00hrs (may be wrong as I honestly don't remember) but the point is to try different times between opening and closing.
 

Oblivion9873

Active Member
Jun 18, 2020
697
958
Did you ever get the second Amy at the beach bar scene to trigger? I got the first one no problem, but the second does not seem to trigger no matter how many times I try to quick load before going to the bar. Tried the coke and the flirt alternating and no success.
eventually yeah, just had to keep trying. also if you want to reroll the rng, after quickloading, go to a different location then back to the beach before going to the bar. Also if it seems stubborn, legit just try and do it on a different day as well. It's a massive pain and the RNG values seem way too low but I got there eventually (after fresh installing the game)
 

MrD812

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2021
1,517
2,253
Here is a simple thing I would love to see in a future version of Holiday Island:

View attachment 2781514

It would be great if the save file thumbnails were to show the game day (or even the time of day, additionally). E. g. in the upper right corner. Then you would not have to add that in the description yourself. I have hundreds of save files*. Most of them without that info in the description (my bad). It would make it so much easier to track which is which.

*No. Not one full save file and none to share.
That is a Brilliant suggestion, seriously awesome!
Would be MOST Helpful.
To share the very least.

On another note: doing countless title-runs as a hobby, user or helping dev's.
Thumbnail drives are like a Best Friend!
Not just for saves but archiving particular versions for reflection/examples.

Helps much for perspective in assisting contrast for advisement and suggestions to content, users and dev's alike.
Those thumbnail drives save TONS of SSD space(no pun intended on 'thumbnails').
 
  • Like
Reactions: BDMick and xapican

maximusleroy

Member
Aug 26, 2016
164
809
Here is a simple thing I would love to see in a future version of Holiday Island:

View attachment 2781514
To add it to saves going forward you would just have to add to following, but there is no easy way to add it to already saved files.
Python:
init python:
    def jsoncallback(d):
        d["days"] = "Day " + str(gameday)

    config.save_json_callbacks.append(jsoncallback)
You would also have to slightly change screens.rpy
Python:
hbox ypos -124:
    if slot < 10:
        text "0[slot]" size 12 xpos 6 outlines [(1,"#43a0bf")]
    else:
        text "[slot]" size 12 xpos 6 outlines [(1,"#43a0bf")]
    text FileJson(slot, "days", empty="", missing="") size 12 xpos 210 xanchor 1.0 outlines [(1,"#43a0bf")]
 

darkhound1

Well-Known Member
Game Developer
Aug 8, 2017
1,842
8,642
To add it to saves going forward you would just have to add to following, but there is no easy way to add it to already saved files.
Python:
init python:
    def jsoncallback(d):
        d["days"] = "Day " + str(gameday)

    config.save_json_callbacks.append(jsoncallback)
You would also have to slightly change screens.rpy
Python:
hbox ypos -124:
    if slot < 10:
        text "0[slot]" size 12 xpos 6 outlines [(1,"#43a0bf")]
    else:
        text "[slot]" size 12 xpos 6 outlines [(1,"#43a0bf")]
    text FileJson(slot, "days", empty="", missing="") size 12 xpos 210 xanchor 1.0 outlines [(1,"#43a0bf")]
Thanks :)
And done. Will be part of 0.4.0 - Time has been added as well.
1689763258300.png
 
Last edited:

DuckSwim

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2018
1,525
9,634
As I said in my edit, I'm not calling for the creator to do anything he doesn't want to do.

However, the things in my list are what the other girls get, and Brenda should get as well.
You can say a girl is "completed" because she's not going to be worked on any more, but until those boxes are checked, there's room for growth.

As to your objections: the options each girl has aren't just a copy of each other girl's other options. Take playing in the pool, it's different for each girl, but that's the joy of the game. The little differences create variety which is what makes the game good.
I know you can sit with Brenda on the lounger, but she could be like Desire and have the lounger option as well as being able to play in the pool.

While I don't want "all girls doing the same," because I value the little differences in each scene. However, if every girl had a copy of the topless yoga poses to give them a yoga option, I have no idea how this would kill the game. Though perhaps I misinterpret your meaning here. Can you give an example?

I can see how filling in all of the blanks could take years, but the creator expects the game to take a long time to finish, and I don't mind waiting. If Brenda is "done for now" and might see more in future, that's all I want.

Anyhow, I hope I have courteously clarified my thoughts here. Know that I don't expect to influence the game, I just want to advance the discussion among the players.

Thank you for reading.
The problem with talking about the concepts you refer to is that it is already official (on Patreon) what the situation is.
Any talk thereof is therefore somewhat moot.

But to elaborate,
  • The facts (and their implication), Part 1.
  • Why the concepts you refer to do not exist in the game / are not workable, Part 2-4
1. The facts
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
2. What other girls get
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
3. What a shared design involves
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
4. The story of Shared Design (history)
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Please Note.
This takes a long time to write and as the decisions have already been made I'll not invest more time into what is at this point, by developer choice, a theorectical exercise
 
Last edited:
4.00 star(s) 237 Votes