If Lexi's father was also the MC's father, their respective mothers would know. Let's remember that they met right around that time. Also, Layla and MC are the same age. In my opinion, it would be hard to explain how the mothers don't know about this relationship with the same man.
- Thread starter Maleficent
- Start date
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,726
True, but if the mother knew Alexis' dad was the mc's dad too, she would tell him to atleast break up with her and then tell him why he has to do that, they wouldn't keep it a secret, especially when his kids begin to date and fuck each other without knowing they are siblings.Cheating? Open relationship? One time thing while on a break?
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,726
I also don't think Alexis and MC are siblings. What I wrote was mere idea for the question asked.
The way the story is told, it is like the story writer is hiding the identity of their dad for a reason, so its likely going to be something MAJOR.
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,726
Erynn and Iris are half-sisters and Alexis' dad is most likely that sports agent dude. When Leya got embarrassed when she saw her was a hint I believe. Also same dude had/has a relationship with Gabi. Also looks like he will play major role in the future, I don't think they need anymore relative situation to him being something MAJOR.
Let's wait and see.
- Mar 28, 2021
- 2,541
- 4,034
no way it's the same dude, being married to two women at once... sports agent guy is Gabi's husband, that's why Gabi was pissed off at the sport event because he was there and didn't think of saying hi to GabiErynn and Iris are half-sisters and Alexis' dad is most likely that sports agent dude. When Leya got embarrassed when she saw her was a hint I believe. Also same dude had/has a relationship with Gabi. Also looks like he will play major role in the future, I don't think they need anymore relative situation to him being something MAJOR.
Let's wait and see.
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,726
- Jun 14, 2020
- 2,125
- 6,631
Husband. Why should she have a wedding photo with him on the wall if he's not her husband?
- Apr 25, 2022
- 1,503
- 4,973
There are some crazy stories out there about guys who travel a lot for business living two completely different lives with two different families and all. Would a guy have enough balls to try doing that with two different women in the same city? Extremely unlikely (but not impossible) in reality... but in the context of a porn game something like that seems practically ordinary.
Besides, Let's assume Santi is two-timing Adriana and Gabi and keeps the double marriage secret from both women. It would create a context for why both Adriana and Gabi being angry at their husbands for canceling on them so much if both of their husbands is the same man. Santi has already proven himself to be a royal douche when he dumped Emily after she refused to take his parents' money for an abortion. So I could totally see him being an asshole who would treat women that way.
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,726
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,726
I am expecting a plot twist over that. Like Santi did not know what parents did or something like that. But yeah he is a royal douche.
- Mar 27, 2022
- 333
- 1,041
I am sure that Santi and Layla's father are different people.
If Santi (Gabi's husband too) was Layla's father, Layla would have recognised him at the athletics track and would not have behaved like that with the MC.
If Santi (Gabi's husband too) was Layla's father, Layla would have recognised him at the athletics track and would not have behaved like that with the MC.
Last edited:
- Nov 14, 2017
- 59,914
- 29,981
1 night stand after night at bar.
- Apr 25, 2022
- 1,503
- 4,973
Unless it turns out that Adriana remarried and Santi is actually their stepdad. Then it wouldn't be incest.
- Mar 28, 2021
- 2,541
- 4,034
- Jul 25, 2020
- 1,845
- 3,976
I get that people are trying to spot future twists, but the simple facts are that no LIs can be blood related to the MC. Also Arianna and Emily used to be roommates at the time that Emily was pregnant, meaning there is no way that Arianna doesn't know that Santi is MC's father, and would be at least slightly uncomfortable with one of her daughters dating their stepfather's biological son. Therefore Santi is not stepfather to Alexis and Layla.
There's no such issue with Santi being Gabi's husband, and MC fucking his biological father's wife would be a twist that I can see Nyx using.
There's no such issue with Santi being Gabi's husband, and MC fucking his biological father's wife would be a twist that I can see Nyx using.
It would be jumping off the shark if he was Alexis/Layla's dad, when Emily was pregnant, Alexis was already a 2 year old and Adrianna was either already pregnant again or would be shortly.
The couple Adrianna and "Mr Monroe"(who seems to be a good father to both his daughters) is still going to this day, probably not something that would happen if he was messing around with her roomate while in a relationship with her.
Then again maybe he ducked going to the restaurant upon learning it was owned by Emily(just playing devils advocate lol).
There are hints about him from both of his daughters(makes it difficult to get all hints in a single playthrough)
When you train with Layla at the park she speaks a little about her father, that he was a basketball player.
Alexis on her path says they can't use her father as the guy who "hires" Erynn to trick Ethan because he is famous.
So i suspect their father is Zo, retired basketball player who the MC was a fan growing up.
Zo and Santiago are not the same person, they were friends in college, Zo is off-screen (he's always off screen or shot from his back) in that flashback where Santiago gets rejected by Emily.
The question has always been is the MCs father Navarro, aka the sports agent?
The name Navarro can easily be his surname and his full name Santiago Navarro.
Having a talented basketball prospect as a friend might've given Santiago a good route into being a sports agent, that familiar story of "started working with this one guy, later expanded" kind of deal.
Navarro (wether he is Santiago or not) is married to Gabi, it explains her being pissed off that he didn't stop to say hello in training camp, she also has a "he looks like him" thought bubble when she first hooks up with the MC.
They also have pictures together dating back to when Gabi was a highschooler(good going Navarro
).Solid point as well.
- Jan 8, 2022
- 492
- 932
Mine: Sports Agent is MCs Dad.