I think dev already my leg here by artistically telling she is his step-mother. Revisit this scene in a different perspective.
yeah, it's just teasing. but once you know Patreon rules, it's just an empty tease
"He is my dad... from another multiverse" is a bit weird.
there is "..." meaning there is something else that is supposed to follow and she is interrupted by a customer right after. the sudden interruption doesn't really work in VN format. Alexis will say "he's my dad's friend" or "he's my dad's former agent"
Nice.
New Theory: Probably Enzo is dad and he divorced Adriana after layla was born. Navarro eventually end up with Adrianna, Like Andres calls MC as dad, may be Alexis is calling him dad.
no, Enzo is still the dad and husband. Navarro cannot be Adrianna's husband ever because of Patreon rules. MC can't fuck his step sisters. and Enzo retired to spend time with his family, so it's not possible that he would be already divorced. they would have said he retired to spend time with his daughters instead.
I got to these questions after "what if Navarro is Santiago/Mc's dad/Gabi's likely husband/Alexis and Layla's dad all are same" which is the current cliffhanger. There are many plotholes in this case. I have structured everything it in order.
So, you know you have answered the questions, according to your assumption that Navarro is only MC's dad and explain your answers based on that and how dev might be right. Our both assumptions will never be right even if we know the story and played all paths. I think my 'maybe' cases are pulling your nerves. I guess. (I'm sorry
)
My point is everyone knows everyone, but not us.
In the beginning, My brain when MC knows Erynn, but not Alexis (Probably he forgot), Emily knows Adriana and Alexis coming to Melissa's house for Erynn since childhood, but never asked who is her husband for god sake (Probably she forgot to ask, but the husband loves the food at that restaurant). Melissa knows Alexis, but not asked about her dad even once (Probably she forgot to ask). Emily knows Santiago, but not his wife (Probably she forgot to ask). Gabi knows Adriana is Layla's mom, also sends layla to tutoring, but they don't talk (Probably they forgot to talk to each other). Emily knows Melissa, but not Erynn's dad (Probably she forgot to ask about one night stand).
it's not an assumption. it's a fact, because of Patreon rules. if Navarro is Alexis and Layla's dad, and Gabi's husband, then Nyx, the dev, is banned and loses her income, and will stop developping the game, simple as that.
also, Navarro can't be married to two women at the same time, it's illegal in the US, and in such a small town, he would get caught very easily, he is very well known as you find out in the story.
We only know Adrianna drove Alexis to Melissa's house. we don't know or see if Emily goes to Melissa's house at the same time. We only see Erynn visiting Emily's house in the flashbacks, we only assume Emily visits Melissa's. Alexis confirms she knew Emily before the story begins, so either Emily visited Melissa while Alexis is there, or Alexis went with Erynn to get MC and play. We can't conclude anything beyond that.
Why would Melissa knowing Alexis's dad be important ? and Melissa probably knows who Alexis' dad is, because Erynn knows him very well and Erynn usually tells everything to her mom.
Emily doesn't care who Santiago's wife is. She only talked about MC with him. and even if she knows, it doesn't matter.
Gabi and Adrianna have a professional relationship, they are not obligated to talk about their personal lives. and even if they did, it doesn't matter because your theory is incorrect. they don't have the same husband. honestly, it's a small town, they probably know who their respective husbands are.
Like I said, but it seems you don't read, Emily DID ASK Melissa about Erynn's dad, and Melissa told her what she knew. Elily even replied he looks like a Viking with tatoos and proceeded to fantasize about him... did you skip that flashback ? Melissa told everything she knows about him to Erynn too. Erynn confirms it's not that much beyond his appearance, and the one night stand.
are you assuming that because you, the player, can see things, the characters all see what you saw ?
But i'll give you that MC is not asking questions enough, that's for sure.