Honestly main reason I like Erynn is for the issues you have with her. Another game made me realize I have a thing for LI with issues where they need the LI to be there for them plus I love slow burn. That and she is wholesome and playful with the MC , childhood friend, she feels more like a girlfriend than a LI to me, this is just a bonus but I like how she acts motherly towards the MC like a second mother at times ( offering to make food , driving him to school etc etc) so she kind of checks all the boxes for me haha. she actually in my top 3 AVN LI list.
I dont mind girls with issues in games too much, i only hate them while the game is not completed. It is mainly because you end up with many years of updates and every time we get a scene with said girl, its always a BS issues scene again and again. But once the game is completed, i know that i can do the 'i can fix her' path and actually get it to its conclusion without frustrations.
I mean it was just a hypothetical / some girl talk wasn't anything serious I don't put to much stock into what she said at camp. Sure she did get her butt slapped and the beach scene says differently. But she did say she didn't want to make a scene at the beach and wish she hanged out with the MC instead. I kind of believe her tbh because of Tori and Darryl being kind of jackasses. Hard to say to much about her still a unknown maybe she just like to make the MC jealous and tease other guys who knows.
If you think that the MC's "rival" slapping the butt of a girl he probably thinks is interrested to the MC as a consequence of the MC slapping his girls ass is NTR, you are more of a snowflake than i tought and you should toughen up. Having a dude slaps a girls ass you barely know at that point doesnt make you a cuck.
As far as Valeria wanting to sleep with Darril, she dont want to. It's a hypothetical question. Tori asks of her to pick between the 4 males present, the MC, Darryl, the other black guy or the coach. Later on she say she would never fuck him because of his shitty personallity. And by that point, we are barely starting to be friends with her, and being new at the school and in Tori's group, i guess she goes with who she knows. At least she didn't say Zach.
As for Erynn getting groped sometimes by the shady guys, it actually is another one of my problems with her. Full of issues and badly written. She wants to be a teacher. She doesnt really study to become one. She say the video could destroy that future carreer that she seems to not care too much about. She obviously prefer modeling, goign as far as enduring the escorting for her dopamine hit of getting to be the star of the show. How can you be so shy and averse to touch and everything, but not caring about doing almost nude photoshoots with random strangers? The easiest way would just be to say fuck it and leave modeling and town. With the amount of porn videos on the internet, hers beign released would just be one in a million and hardly a focus.
I will no longer follow Valéria's path, she looks like a bus turnstile or an escalator everyone passes her hand on it
Weirdly, there is no indication she did anything with anyone, especially knowing that on her path you learn that she is very shy to touch / being seen nude, i still do agree with your description as her general feeling even without evidence.
What i will agree is that yes her constant over flirting with everyone, which attract touchy-feely and clingy npcs to which she never push back against. Even tough she not wanting it, she continues on again and again and it is annoying and made me also loose interest in her and having a save for her path. Especially since she comes so far off in the game that i'm already established by then.