I’ve just completed my first playthrough of the current version, and I have to say, it’s pretty damn good overall. The sheer amount of content is truly admirable. While some storylines aren't as developed as others, they all add depth to the world.
I focused on Alexis for this run, though the other love interests were also compelling, almost too compelling. If I had to rank my top LIs, it would look something like this:
1 - Alexis / Valeria
2 - Erynn
3 - Layla / Nikki / Iris
The others are great, too, but these stood out the most.
Alexis has a wealth of content, and her character is brilliantly written. I actually appreciate her flaws and mistakes, as they make her feel more real and contribute to her growth. Her relationship with the MC feels the most advanced, and their interactions are top-tier. Her background and past with the MC really plays well into her story here.
Valeria arrived late in the game, but her presence is undeniable. It's a testament to Nyx's writing that she managed to steal the spotlight so effectively. I’m still not sure how she holds her own against LIs with far more screen time, but she absolutely does. She's a magnet to the MC.
Erynn is another top-tier character. The only reason she isn't higher in my playthrough is that the MC simply spends more time with Alexis, both deepening their relationship and unlocking spicier content. Interestingly, Erynn's route seems to remain open even on a faithful Alexis path, the physical tension between them is palpable. I have no doubt Nyx will give the MC another chance with her, and I’ll definitely be pursuing her route from the start in the next update, even if it pains me to see Alexis hurt. With more content, Erryn would undoubtedly be more appreciated. Once again, another character that has a great background and her relation to the MC really flourishes in the story. Plus, she also has her share of flaws and mistakes, which helps her character stand out. I will probably bump her to 1# soon.
In terms of overall character depth, both she and Alexis are the undisputed winners.
An Alexis & Erynn throuple is urgently needed here
Layla is the typical school sweetheart, lovely and relatively low-drama (so far, aside from the obvious one). She’s great, though her relevance to the main plot feels smaller, making her content a bit milder. The same goes for
Nikki; she's a cool and sweet character, though it’s obvious a pregnancy arc is coming, which will be pure cinema.
Iris suffers from the "Erynn syndrome" but even more acutely; she’s awesome but arrives very late. I appreciate that she's now after her own thing, though.
Some paths are clearly tripwires, which can be unfortunate for players who want to focus on a single LI, but it certainly serves the game's purpose.
So yeah, great stuff so far. The main criticism would be the lack of music and how the MC can be oblivious to what's he doing to others at times. Still, *chef's kiss*.