There were several things from the beginning that turned out bad the more the story progressed:There seemed to be a point where 3Diddly either got confused or bored with multiple paths and started basically making it a no-option route. Even though the choices were there, if you tried to isolate Katie with, say, just Mr. Wright, you eventually rejected everyone but Brian.
If you wanted the additional sex scenes, you had to take on Brandon and Jacob, too. When I compare it to the intricate weaving in GGGB, this left me wishing 3Diddly had kept his original enthusiasm.
So, I would have liked to see:
- A revenge path. Not really redemption, as Katie would like her more sexually expanded tastes, but would be able to "take out" the abuser-types (Brandon, Silver, etc.)
- A pervy path. All old guys. She keeps up with Dad, Silver, the Dean and any newer old guy.
- A lesbian path. Disgusted and disillusioned by men who use her, she just goes with Hannah, Vera and Candy.
- An incest path. We've already got Dad. How about Mom, too?
Brian bored me. Perhaps he was written that way purposely, to get players to send out Katie more. It seems the same way in GGGB with Eric. Makes sense, from a game standpoint. If the boyfriend is really a perfect fit, why experiment?
The point system - there were not enough points to count 'good' or 'bad' decisions unless he'd gone negative, so the dev had to keep Katie on the path you decided for her without having a chance to let her turn back or even switch paths.
Starting with two seperate directions right from the beginning - it was quite easy to guess what choice to make to stay on one of the paths. And, like in many games, 'yes' would be followed by a sex scene, 'no' by nothing.
The lack of ideas for the 'good' path - this stopped rather early.
The dev strongly underestimated the effort and time it would take to make a multiple path story. Weekly updates had to result in complaints about minimal content and disappointment by the patrons.
Some additional remarks: Maybe the dev hoped he could make a living with his patreon income and work fulltime on Katie's. The critical point was never reached.
Same thing was about the dev couldn't hire someone to do the proper coding.
Patreon's rule changes which didn't allow incest, blackmail or raping.
Maybe there's more.
As for Brian: He could have been a more interesting character. It would have been possible to let him cheat with Vera, join Katie in a threesome, really turn out to be dealing with drugs or something like that.
All the above isn't meant as an offense but simply to find an answer to why this game has gone wrong. If there should be anyone around here who is willing and able to continue Katie's I'd like to see some of the endings you suggest. Continuation should rather be kind of comic because Katie is stuck on her path anyway, no need for choices anymore. Btw: who is Silver?