- Sep 5, 2020
- 2,826
- 6,051
The big difference in the 3 modern Personas is in how dungeon design is handled.Btw, sorry for the off-topic but:
Since I know some of you here have played several Persona games, what would you recommend in my situation?
I played Persona 4 back in the day, like at least 15 years ago and really liked it.
I know bought Persona 4 Golden and Persona 5 Royal.
Should I indulge in my nostalgia and play through Persona 4 again or go straight to Persona 5? I understand the newer iteration has mor QoL features and just plays more smoothly. But I didn't necessarily hate the grind (though the dungeon design was kinda ass ngl), since I was a "gotta catch them all" addict when it came to collecting those cards or whatever they were, I don't even remember.
Any advice or suggestions are welcome![]()
Persona 3 has Tartarus, which is a single tower with a ton of floors, each procedurally generated (so it will change when you leave and come back). More floors unlock as story progresses.
Persona 4 has dungeons -- each story arc has an independent dungeon with a semi-randomized floor pattern tied to the part of the story you're currently on.
Persona 5 does both -- Palaces (dungeons) tied to that month's story arc (main quests) and a Tartarus-style dungeon called Mementos, which is where the side quests are handled. In Royal, Palaces are fixed-map, but Mementos is procedurally generated.
Persona 5 Royal tends to be easier than Persona 4 Golden, outside of one encounter that is artificially hard on lower difficulty settings because of how damage scaling and weaknesses work (it's actually easiest on the highest difficulty as a result).
In terms of story and characters, there's not really a wrong answer. If you like turn-based JRPGs, you're probably going to enjoy the 100 hours you sink into either one (and Persona 3 Reload, which came out this year, is also exceptional).