Chronicles of Elyria was officially denounced as a scam last year and the team is now facing a lawsuit for it.I just watched a couple of Youtube videos about another game of similar situation, Chronicles of Elyria, which is a MMORPG with crafting and building and such, basically a dream sandbox game that was supposed to be out in 2017. Until now, 2022, it's still not even out of alpha, still continued to siphon people's money with virtual properties that don't even exist yet, and the dev team is being taken out to court (You should check out KiraTV on Youtube). Just reminds me of LT so bad that I had to say it here and dream of a day when either Inno takes the game seriously or LT becomes a community project like how Free Cities was.
The chances of Inno facing a lawsuit are close to none and there are a few reasons for it.
1) Despite the delays and questionable choices during development you can't call it a scam because progress is still being made and we have proof of it via free, public updates.
In 2020 we had 13 public updates (a portion of which were hotfixes). Last year we had 6 (again, including hotfixes). Progress may be slowing down but a free update every 2 months is still a better deal than you'd get from the worst examples of indie porn developers, especially those that gate their game behind a pay wall. Is it ideal? No. Could be worse? Yes. People would be less upset if Inno stopped making public estimates she cannot keep up with. We know it. She knows it. It would save everyone, including herself, the hassle if she just accepted this fact. The game is not in it's infancy anymore, the more it grows the more difficult it becomes to add and maintain things. We don't expect miracles, but we do expect some modesty (and honesty) from the developer.
2) Kickstarter is a crowdfunding platform with a one-off payment to help creators bring their projects to life. Patreon (and similar) allow creators to live off a monthly subscription in exchange for services. The main difference between the two is that the people who fund Kickstarters are usually seen as "investors", whereas Patreons are seen as "donators".
Investors want guarantees and may ask for their money back or even take legal action if they feel like you didn't fulfill your end of the bargain, whereas donations usually come with less strings attached for both parties. With Patreon, you are not entitled to the product or service unless you're active subscriber. The creator sets the parameters of what and when they are willing to deliver, and it is up to you whether or not you accept those terms. Unless the creator breaks the law, it will be hard to hold them accountable for their actions, as you can just withdraw your subscription should you become unhappy with the deal. You cannot, however, get your money back from previous donations.
With Kickstarter, you pay for the whole product. With Patreon, you pay for a portion of the final product and for every step of the way it takes to get there.
Last edited: